Is Taylor Swift a 'Silence Breaker' Like 'Time' Magazine Claims?

Taylor Swift
Taylor Swift performs "Out of the Woods" at the 58th Grammy Awards in Los Angeles on February 15, 2016. She appears, along with four other women, on the cover of "Time" magazine's Person of the Year issue. Mario Anzuoni/Reuters

Taylor Swift has had a complicated year.

She laid low for months. She released Reputation, her most aggressive, pointed album to date. She clapped back at the Kim/Kanye Gossip Industrial Complex—as well as the mainstream media—and granted virtually no interviews during a lengthy promotion cycle. She courted the condemnation of the American Civil Liberties Union when her lawyer aimed empty threats at an unheard-of blogger for criticizing the singer's politics.

She also won a high-profile lawsuit against a former radio host who allegedly groped her in 2013—a significant achievement that has risked getting lost amid all the celebrity drama that surrounds the star.

And now she appears, along with four other women, on the cover of Time magazine's Person of the Year issue.

The unusual cover is meant to honor "The Silence Breakers"—the women who came forward this year to speak out about sexual assault and harassment, sparking an ongoing national reckoning about abuse in the workplace, in Hollywood, in politics and everywhere in between. Swift appears alongside women like Ashley Judd, who has accused Harvey Weinstein of sexual harassment, and Susan Fowler, who came forward with explosive claims about sexism at Uber.

Related: What it's like to share a name with Taylor Swift

In the cover story—and in a separate Q&A with the magazine—Swift speaks candidly about her experience facing down the man who groped her in a courtroom. It is a frank conversation about some bold decisions on Swift's part: both speaking out about her experience and then countersuing the DJ for a symbolic $1.

"I was angry," the singer reflects. "In that moment, I decided to forgo any courtroom formalities and just answer the questions the way it happened. This man hadn't considered any formalities when he assaulted me, and his lawyer didn't hold back on my mom—why should I be polite?"

In the published interview, Swift is not asked to reckon with the broader political moment. She does not address Donald Trump, the nation's so-called abuser-in-chief, whose presidency is identified by Time as having stoked the rage for this feminist reckoning. (In a surreal twist, Trump was a runner-up for this issue's cover.)

And she does not talk about the time her lawyer tried to silence a young, female blogger who took her to task for not condemning the white supremacists who worship Swift. (Whether these subjects were off-limits as a precondition for the interview is not known.)

For Swift fans and skeptics alike, the contradictions are difficult to reconcile: Swift is honored as a "silence breaker" while remaining conspicuously silent on most contentious political subjects (those that threaten her livelihood). Can one be an outspoken feminist while evading all discussion of the present administration's threat to women?

In 2017, the pop star has been roundly criticized for seeming to value her brand over political convictions.

Most Swift fans delighted in her appearance on the Time cover. Some commentators were critical, or openly scornful, mounting a backlash to the star's inclusion on social media.

So, how are we calling Taylor Swift "silence breaker" when the only time she bothered to break her silence is when the shit happened to her?

— Genie Lauren (@MoreAndAgain) December 6, 2017

Um why the fuck is Taylor Swift, a woman who has stayed silent on MYRIAD political issues, on the TIME Silence Breakers cover

— Ej Dickson (@ejdickson) December 6, 2017

It’s kinda weird that “silence breaker” Taylor Swift tried to sue a blogger for an op-ed about white supremacists who like her music. 🙃🙃🙃

— Tyler Coates (@tylercoates) December 6, 2017

Why is Taylor Swift on the cover of TIME, doe? 🙄😒

— Luvvie is the #ProfessionalTroublemaker (@Luvvie) December 6, 2017

Yes, I know she sued the dude and won but I just think there are others who shoulda been there instead of her. See: KESHA, who lost a lot from her silence breaking. ORRRR the person they picked to be INSIDE the magazine for starting #MeToo 10 years ago: @TaranaBurke.

— Luvvie is the #ProfessionalTroublemaker (@Luvvie) December 6, 2017

Just a question, .@TIME: Taylor Swift? The person who refused to use her platform last year to contribuite to defeat Donald Trump? What kind of silence breaker is she? #TimePOTY

— Angie (@angiedam2) December 6, 2017

None of these controversies seem to have harmed Swift's commercial dominance. Reputation was released last month and has already become the best-selling album of 2017.