
...

By Sam Stevenson
Associate News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The U.S. Justice Department (DOJ) has rewritten a decades-old provision of civil rights law that allows for statistical disparities to be used as proof of discrimination.
Why It Matters
The DOJ’s decision to eliminate the use of a legal concept known as "disparate impact" marks a major change in how the federal government addresses allegations of discrimination.
Read More on News
For more than 50 years, disparate impact liability enabled civil rights enforcement agencies and courts to use statistical evidence—such as uneven outcomes among racial or ethnic groups—as proof that civil rights law may have been violated, even if no explicit intent to discriminate could be shown.
However, the new rule means only cases with proof of intentional discrimination will be actionable.
What To Know
On Tuesday, the DOJ finalized a rule that removes disparate impact liability from its Title VI regulations.
Disparate impact is a principle in U.S. civil rights law that occurs when a policy or practice that appears neutral on its face disproportionately harms a protected group, such as those defined by race, sex, national origin, age, or disability—even if there was no intent to discriminate.
Applied under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the rule means that even neutral policies can violate civil rights if they disproportionately harm protected groups—but recent changes now require proof of intent, making it harder to challenge systemic bias.
This move follows President Donald Trump's April executive order instructing agencies to eliminate disparate-impact liability wherever possible.
Under the change, organizations receiving federal funding can no longer be held liable for discrimination simply because their policies lead to unequal results for different racial, color, or national origin groups.
According to the DOJ, the shift will require claimants to prove intentional discrimination rather than rely solely on statistical disparities.
The move rescinds regulations enacted in 1973, which DOJ officials say were never part of the original Civil Rights Act passed by Congress.
The change is expected to affect enforcement in areas such as housing, education, criminal justice, employment, and environmental regulation. Critics argue the move dismantles a key tool in fighting institutional and systemic discrimination.
What People Are Saying
Assistant Attorney General Harmeet K. Dhillon said: "Our rejection of this theory will restore true equality under the law by requiring proof of actual discrimination, rather than enforcing race- or sex-based quotas or assumptions."
Attorney General Pam Bondi said: "For decades, the Justice Department has used disparate-impact liability to undermine the constitutional principle that all Americans must be treated equally under the law. No longer. This Department of Justice is eliminating its regulations that for far too long required recipients of federal funding to make decisions based on race."
Kenneth L. Marcus, who headed the Education Department’s Office for Civil Rights during both George W. Bush’s administration and Trump’s first term, said: "This is the sweeping elimination of disparate impact that conservative lawyers have been pushing for over the last quarter century. This new rule is the most forceful push for color-blind justice since the Supreme Court’s Harvard decision."
NAACP-LDF senior policy counsel Amalea Smirniotopoulos said: "The Trump administration cannot claim to value equality by undermining the very laws that keep people protected from discrimination. Removing the Department of Justice’s regulations prohibiting unfair discriminatory policies takes away critical safeguards against the most insidious forms of exclusion."
More than 200 former DOJ Civil Rights Division attorneys signed a letter criticizing the administration’s actions.
They wrote: "We must sound the alarm about the near destruction of DOJ’s once-revered crown jewel. The Administration wants you to believe that career staff who fled the Division 'were actively in resistance mode' and 'decided that they’d rather not do what their job requires them to do'. That could not be further from the truth. We left because this Administration turned the Division’s core mission upside down, largely abandoning its duty to protect civil rights."
What Happens Next
Legal challenges to the new rule are expected, as civil rights organizations argue that eliminating disparate impact liability undermines the intent of federal anti-discrimination laws and could stymie efforts to address systemic inequality.
The rule is likely to shape debates in Congress and the courts regarding the role of statistical evidence in civil rights law.
DOJ officials maintain the new rule will be enforced going forward, emphasizing that anti-discrimination claims must now be based on intentional acts rather than disparate outcomes.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines