One entirely new theory emerged on Wednesday night.
The Masked Singer returns from its baseball-induced hiatus to unmask two celebrities and give us a double elimination.
The show will return with at least one celebrity unmasked.
There's one celebrity name that viewers have associated with a handful of masks.
The family re-created eight iconic looks from the FOX reality show.
The MLB championship will air its final game on FOX tonight.
The World Series has something to do with it.
"They came into the house and kept like, ordering me stuff and it would show up to the house."
Are two of the show's contestants former Disney Channel stars?
Dr. Drew Pinsky, aka Eagle, described his time on the singing competition as "very bizarre."
There's an upcoming movie that links into the theory.
"It's been so much fun to be able to sing, do something that I've always wanted to do but was too shy to do because I didn't have confidence in my voice," the mystery singer said after elimination.
One of the two was unexpected, even to his biggest fans.
Ladybug blew away the judges and managed to stay in the competition in the first episode of Season 2.
The guesses range from A-list celebrities like Lady Gaga to a Trump employee.
"I mean, I heard that they were turning people down," says panelist Jenny McCarthy. "When you have to turn people down that's a true sign of success."
"The Masked Singer" returns Wednesday at 8 p.m. EST. Check out our spoilers and live recap of the Season 1 finale including who won and who was behind the Monster, Bee and Peacock masks.
Last night The Masked Singer revealed a clue about the Peacock that made his identity all too clear. Find out what the "Blurred Lines" clue means and who may be hiding behind the plumed mask, here.
Last night the Masked Singer revealed some bombshell clues that point to the identity of the Lion. Find out what Hailey, Chicago and the Bluegrass state of Kentucky have in common and how they link to the Lion's identity, here.
Last night the Masked Singer revealed a major clue to the identity of the Rabbit. Find out who he is, here.
Last night the Masked Singer revealed a key clue to the identity of the Bee. Find out who she is, here.
Last night the Masked Singer revealed an "arresting" clue about the identity of one of the remaining performers. Get the whole scoop, here.
Wonder who the Monster is on The Masked Singer? Check out our complete list of clues and best guesses for the performer's identity, here.
Who is the Alien on The Masked Singer? Check out all the clues and our best guesses for the Alien's identity, here.