
...
By Sophie Clark
Live News Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The transgender military members suing the Trump administration for the expulsion of transgender troops said the move is disrespectful and contradicts the U.S. military's values.
"The forced separation of dedicated, qualified servicemembers, the dismantling of careers, and the disrespect shown to families who have sacrificed so much is so counter to our military values," Second Lieutenant Nicholas Talbott, one of the plaintiffs in Talbott v. Trump, told Newsweek.
Why It Matters
The troops suing the Trump administration told Newsweek that firing transgender servicemembers will "unleash unfathomable harms upon the lives, families and careers of transgender servicemembers."
Read More on Politics
The U.S. military is already experiencing recruitment struggles, and plaintiffs in Talbott v. Trump argue that transgender service members have already been invested in by the government and have proved they meet readiness standards, so they should not be removed from their posts.
A military scholar told Newsweek on background that without diverse recruitment, the military will not be able to reach its retention goals or recruit top talent.

...
What To Know
Talbott v. Trump is a suit over the Trump administration and Department of Defense's (DOD) decision to separate transgender troops from the military.
The case is an equal protection suit, as the plaintiffs claim they were denied their Fifth Amendment right to due process after being placed on administrative leave without cause.
The plaintiffs also argue that the military's firing of transgender troops is not only illegal but a waste of resources. The military has already invested in their training and readiness and is now placing them on leave simply because they are transgender, not because they cannot meet military standards.
"The military that we know and love and that I have dedicated my life to is suddenly rushing to place on administrative leave and then purge every transgender service member for reasons unrelated to our ability to do our jobs or meet the standards," Major Erica Vandal, another plaintiff in the suit, told Newsweek.
"[Purging transgender troops] is systematically dismantling our careers and seeking to place a stain upon our permanent records for nothing more than who we are," said Vandal, who has received a Bronze Star "for heroic or meritorious achievements or service while engaged against an enemy of the United States."
The Trump administration's reasoning for firing transgender troops is outlined in Trump's executive order "Prioritizing Military Excellence and Readiness."
In the order, Trump says: "A man's assertion that he is a woman, and his requirement that others honor this falsehood, is not consistent with the humility and selflessness required of a service member...military service must be reserved for those mentally and physically fit for duty."
The assertion was questioned by U.S. District Court Judge Ana Reyes during a hearing about the order, when she asked DoD attorneys: "So, people with gender dysphoria can't be honest, humble or have integrity. You think that's demeaning to people with gender dysphoria?"
Reyes also pointed to how transgender people experience higher rates of depression, a reason given by the DOD for why they are unfit to serve, because of discrimination—such as being fired suddenly for being transgender, not because of mental health struggles inherent to being transgender.
The executive order goes on to say: "It is the policy of the United States Government to establish high standards for troop readiness, lethality, cohesion, honesty, humility, uniformity, and integrity. This policy is inconsistent with the medical, surgical, and mental health constraints on individuals with gender dysphoria."
The reasoning is inconsistent with Vandal's and Talbott's experiences in the military, as they have trained throughout their adult lives—in Vandal's case even being part of the military as a child growing up on bases—to reach their readiness potential and serve in their positions in the U.S. Army.
Vandal and Talbott brought the suit along with Kate Cole, Gordon Herrero, Dany Danridge, Jamie Hash, Koda Nature and Cael Neary.
They are suing Trump in his official capacity as president of the United States; the United States of America; Peter B. Hegseth, in his official capacity as secretary of defense; Mark Averill, in his official capacity as acting secretary of the Army; The United States Department of the Army; Terence Emmert, in his official capacity as acting secretary of the Navy; the United States Department of the Navy; Gary Ashworth, in his official capacity as acting secretary of the Air Force; The United States Department of the Air Force; Telita Crosland, in her official capacity as director of the Defense Health Agency; and the Defense Health Agency.
"As a matter of policy, the Department does not comment on ongoing litigation," the DoD told Newsweek.

...
What People Are Saying
Major Erica Vandal told Newsweek: "I have served with distinction in the United States Army for nearly 14 years. Before me, my father served for four decades. I grew up on military bases. The military was and continues to be my entire life. I also have an incredible family. I am married with two children, and their support for me and my military career has required tremendous sacrifices on behalf of our country. I am grateful to have them in my life and for their support, as I know so many service members are to their own families. It's difficult to have a conversation with them about what's happening. It's hard to fully comprehend the full scope and impacts of a ban. The military that we know and love and that I have dedicated my life to is suddenly rushing to place on administrative leave and then purge every transgender servicemember for reasons unrelated to our ability to do our jobs or meet the standards. It is systematically dismantling our careers and seeking to place a stain upon our permanent records for nothing more than who we are."
Second Lieutenant Nicolas Talbott told Newsweek: "From growing up and working on my grandmother's family farm in Lisbon, Ohio to my pursuit of a graduate degree in criminology, I have been focused on one thing: training, studying, and meeting my goals to become a member of our military. I am now a platoon leader for my military policing unit in the U.S. Army Reserve, and more than anything, I just want to continue to do the job that I have qualified for, trained for, and committed to in order to serve my country. The forced separation of dedicated, qualified servicemembers, the dismantling of careers, and the disrespect shown to families who have sacrificed so much is so counter to our military values. These policies disregard merit and achievement and unleash unfathomable harms upon the lives, families, and careers of transgender servicemembers."
Jennifer Levi, senior director of transgender and queer rights at GLBTQ Legal Advocates & Defenders and one of the lead attorneys representing transgender service members in this case, previously told Newsweek: "I have heard from all across the military that what matters when you are in a foxhole is that the person next to you will do everything to save you. It doesn't matter whether they are transgender or not. When you put on the uniform, differences fall away. What matters is their courage, their commitment, and their willingness to sacrifice for their fellow service members and for the ideals that our nation represents. What matters is that they stand ready to defend our freedom."
What Happens Next
The plaintiffs have asked for a declaratory judgment that the ban on transgender troops is "unconstitutional," and has asked for the court to serve "a preliminary and permanent injunction prohibiting the categorical exclusion of transgender people from military service."
Reyes is expected to make her ruling in Talbott v. Trump by Wednesday. The ruling will likely be appealed to a higher court.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines