10
Loading video...

By Hugh Cameron
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
President Donald Trump's plan to introduce 50-year mortgages could increase the financial risks for both homeowners and lenders, according to Mark Zandi, the chief economist at Moody's Analytics.
Speaking with Newsweek, Zandi said borrowers taking on a five-decade loan would struggle to build equity—with most payments in the first decade being on interest rather than principal. With limited equity, homeowners would have less of a financial cushion should a shock occur—a drop in house prices or unexpected expense—and therefore be at "greater risk of default on these loans."
Given this heightened risk, Zandi said interest rates would be "significantly higher" than on standard 30-year mortgages, eliminating many of the cost savings that would result from the longer repayment period.
Read More on Politics
Why It Matters
The president has defended the proposal, the brainchild of Federal Housing Finance Agency Director Bill Pulte, by pointing out that extending the horizon on mortgages would lower monthly payments and provide a leg up for the Americans struggling to get on the housing ladder. The plan has garnered support from some housing market experts, and surveys show that many prospective buyers would consider taking on a 50-year mortgage.
However, others have questioned whether extending the life of a loan could meaningfully bring down monthly costs, given the higher interest rates these would be subject to, and warned that this could exacerbate the supply issues gripping the U.S. housing market.
What To Know
During a recent interview with the president, Fox News host Laura Ingraham noted opposition to the idea from sections of his base, who she said had framed it as "a giveaway to the banks and simply prolonging the time it would take for Americans to own a home outright."
"All it means is you pay less per month," Trump responded. "You pay it over a longer period of time. It's not like a big factor."
However, many have noted that extending the duration of a mortgage would significantly increase its total price tag. Realtor.com senior economist Joel Berner calculated that this could raise the total interest paid over a loan's lifetime by 86 percent.
Jeff Ostrowski, Bankrate's housing market analyst, similarly told Newsweek that a 50-year mortgage would "almost certainly" come with higher rates, calculating that the monthly savings compared to a 30-year loan would amount to only $56.
He added: "Are 10 lattes a month really enough to motivate me as a borrower to both extend the repayment period and to accept a higher rate? Probably not."

...
Last week, Berner told Newsweek that monthly savings would be largely negated by the higher interest paid on the riskier loans, and that the effects on an already strained housing supply could raise prices and put homeownership further out of reach for some.
In October, Goldman Sachs cited estimates that the U.S.'s housing shortfall stood between 1.5 million and 5.5 million units, adding that "at least 3-4 million additional homes beyond normal construction need to be built to address the shortage in U.S. housing supply and boost affordability."
Zandi told Newsweek that the 50-year mortgage "may only support more demand, and given the lack of supply, simply push up house prices, thus not helping with affordability."
Others, however, have supported the idea. Eric Zwick, an associate professor of finance at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business, told NPR: "Honestly, I kind of think it's a fine idea. It's not obviously so different from a 30-year fixed mortgage."
"I think affordability is a concern in the housing market," he added. "And one element is the down payment, but another element is the monthly payment. And a longer duration mortgage is gonna lower the monthly payment."
A recent survey by the financial resource website BadCredit.org found that 45 percent of Americans would consider a 50-year mortgage, a figure that rises to 54 percent among millennials.
"It's always worth considering different loan options, so it doesn't surprise me that Americans would consider it," Daryl Fairweather, Redfin's chief economist, told Newsweek in response to the survey results. "But I think once they see the math, most would ultimately choose a 30-year mortgage over a 50-year mortgage."
"Some estimates only put the monthly savings at $40 per month for a median-priced home," she added. "I don't think many homebuyers would trade a 30-year mortgage for a 50-year mortgage for that amount of monthly savings because it could double their interest paid over the life of the loan and limit their equity gained."
What People Are Saying
Mark Zandi told Newsweek: "This also does nothing to address the shortage of homes for middle-income Americans and may only support more demand, and given the lack of supply, simply push up house prices, thus not helping with affordability."
Joel Berner, a senior economist at Realtor.com, previously told Newsweek: "The drawbacks are that a 50-year mortgage results in almost double the interest payments of a 30-year mortgage and a longer path to meaningful home equity, and that the result of subsidizing home demand without increasing home supply could be an increase to home prices that negates the potential savings."
He added, "The 'savings' from 50-year mortgages may be totally negated by rising home prices."
Daryl Fairweather, the chief economist at Redfin, told Newsweek: "Millennials and Gen-Zers are having the hardest time becoming first-time homebuyers because of affordability challenges. The median age of first-time homebuyers is now 40 years old, according to NAR, so younger buyers need solutions. But this solution won't solve their affordability problems. We need to build more homes, to increase the supply of housing, in order to sustainably improve affordability. Coming up with new financial products for homebuyers to increase demand for housing won't solve the housing shortage, which is the root cause of unaffordability in housing."
What Happens Next
The proposal remains in its early stages, with no formal policy documents having been published and questions surrounding the affordability trade-offs. Last week, Pulte said the administration was "working on" the five-decade mortgage idea, calling it a "complete game changer."
A U.S. Federal Housing spokesperson previously told Newsweek that the government would "continue to evaluate all options to address housing affordability, including studying how to make mortgages assumable or portable."
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines