10

Loading video...

Giulia Carbonaro

By Giulia Carbonaro

Senior Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


President Donald Trump signed an executive order on Monday allowing the use of tax-free dyed diesel on the road through the end of the year, in a move that should bring down soaring gas and diesel prices as the midterms quickly approach.

"Tonight, I am going to sign a historic executive order to officially waive the off-road requirement and allow anyone to purchase tax-free red-dye diesel for any reason," Trump said while speaking at a campaign event in Nebraska.

But some analysts are skeptical that this temporary expanded use of dyed diesel—also known as red diesel, which is typically sold tax-free for off-road vehicles—will benefit all American drivers.

Read More

Mass Layoffs, Trucking Bankruptcies Mount Amid Diesel Price Shock5 min read

Mass Layoffs, Trucking Bankruptcies Mount Amid Diesel Price Shock

Trump’s ICE Policy to Face Supreme Court Justices He Regrets Nominating6 min read

Trump’s ICE Policy to Face Supreme Court Justices He Regrets Nominating

Donald Trump Vows to Fund TV Ads Facing Bipartisan Backlash7 min read

Donald Trump Vows to Fund TV Ads Facing Bipartisan Backlash

President Donald Trump dances at a campaign rally at the Pinnacle Bank Expo Center on October 5 in Grand Island, Nebraska.

...

Experts Weigh in on Dyed Diesel Order

"I wouldn't call the executive order for diesel much ado about nothing, but it really doesn't alter the supply problems," Tom Kloza, the senior energy and market adviser at Gulf Oil, told Newsweek. "It should, however, put some downward pressure on street prices since dyeing the diesel allows the recipient to avoid federal and state or local taxes."

"The dyed (red) diesel order sounds big, but most drivers won't benefit," Patrick De Haan, the head of petroleum analysis at GasBuddy, wrote on social media. "States still enforce their own rules, it's not truly tax-free, and it doesn't add a single gallon of supply."

"It probably won't do a whole lot, really," Gregory Ibendahl, an agricultural economist at Kansas State University, told The New York Times, adding that "something big" is needed "to get the prices back where they were before the Iran thing started." He specified that taxes are not the problem.

Matt Perdue, the president of the North Dakota Farmers Union, the largest general farm organization in the state, told Newsweek that his group appreciates the executive order and Republican Governor Kelly Armstrong's earlier executive order to allow dyed diesel fuel on roadways.

"Together, the two actions provide meaningful relief for farmers and ranchers. At the same time, they fall well short of addressing the full impact of high diesel prices," he said.

"Truckers are feeling the pain at the pump. Every $1 increase per gallon in fuel costs our members around $400 more per week, and sustained high prices will put many truck drivers out of business," Todd Spencer, the president and CEO of the Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association (OOIDA), told Newsweek.

"Meanwhile, oil executives pad their profits while working families struggle. Consumers also pay the price. Roughly 70 percent of domestic freight moves exclusively by truck, and the cost of fuel ultimately gets passed on. OOIDA believes allowing the wider use of red-dyed diesel will provide minimal relief. Market stability is essential to bring down costs for the long haul."

How High Are Diesel and Gas Prices?

As of Tuesday morning, the national average diesel price was $6.31 per gallon, up from $3.68 per gallon a year ago, according to the American Automobile Association (AAA).

Compared to the days before the Iran war began on February 28, causing the disruptions in global oil supply that have driven up energy prices across the world, it is up by more than $2.5 per gallon.

The highest diesel prices were in California, where drivers paid a statewide average of $8.36 per gallon. Prices were above $7 per gallon in two other states: Washington ($7.33) and Hawaii ($7.22). Drivers in Texas ($5.73), Georgia ($5.80) and Oklahoma ($5.81) paid the lowest diesel prices in the nation.

The national average gas price on the same day was $4.37 per gallon, up from $3.13 per gallon a year ago. Before the U.S. and Israel launched joint strikes on Iran, gas prices had been falling for weeks, dipping to $2.98 per gallon and allowing the Trump administration to claim lower costs as a victory.

Drivers in California once again paid the highest prices in the nation, for a statewide average of $6.38 per gallon, followed by Hawaii ($5.63), Washington ($5.48), Nevada ($5.48), Oregon ($5.04) and Alaska ($5.02). The cheapest price at the pump was found in Indiana ($3.72), Ohio ($3.78) and Georgia ($3.85).

What Is Dyed Diesel?

Dyed diesel and regular diesel are chemically identical; the only real difference between them is the way they are taxed. Dyed diesel is exempt from federal excise taxes and restricted to off-road use for construction equipment—including excavators, bulldozers and loaders—and agricultural machinery, among other things.

It is also known as red diesel as it is dyed red so that it can be easily identified. Under normal circumstances, if law enforcement finds a driver using dyed diesel on a highway, they may face hefty fines.

Trump's executive order affects red diesel. Another type of dyed diesel, also known as blue diesel, is used for U.S. government vehicles and equipment only.

Can Trump’s Order Lower Diesel Prices?

Trump's executive order allows dyed diesel to be used for on-road vehicles without paying the 24.4 cents per gallon federal tax normally imposed on highway diesel, or about $60 on a 250-gallon fill.

"Where states match this federal action, savings will top $100 per fill—a real difference for the hardworking Americans who haul the freight and grow the food," the White House said in a news release.

But analysts doubt the move will have a significant effect on diesel and gas prices.

"It really just buys some time—taxes aren't paid, and one might assume that this increases deficits for entities that depend on tax receipts for funding," Kloza said. "Real crunch time comes with dead-of-winter since diesel and heating oil are essentially the same molecules."

A driver passes a marquee displaying gas prices at a Menlo Park, California, Chevron station on October 5.

...

"Sounds big, but for most diesel users it likely won't change much at the pump," De Haan wrote on social media, adding: "Dyed diesel is basically identical to ULSD/on-road diesel, the dye just marks it as untaxed. Farmers already buy it tax-free for off-road use, so they don't see much change. This is really aimed at truckers, local haulers and diesel pickup owners."

However, De Haan said there was a "catch" in the measure. An executive order cannot overrun states that have their own dyed diesel laws. While Alabama, Louisiana, Nebraska, North Carolina, North Dakota, Oklahoma and Texas have already eased rules on the use of dyed diesel, with Louisiana doing so only for farmers and timber harvesters, "in most states running red on the road is still illegal," De Haan said.

"A clean federal diesel tax suspension would need Congress, but it would hit every gallon in every state," he added.

The executive order will not make dyed diesel completely "tax free" either, the analyst said, as "many states charge sales tax on dyed diesel instead of their fuel tax, and the fact sheet reportedly says the federal tax is 'deferred,' not eliminated. If it comes due later, anyone who switched could owe it."

There is also another issue: While Trump's executive order can provide some immediate relief, it does not address the issue of supply. Global supply disruptions are what have driven up diesel and gas prices.

De Haan said, "This adds zero gallons of supply and could squeeze farmers mid-harvest in some cases."

How Will Trump’s Order Affect Farmers?

Like De Haan, farmers are skeptical. "We have completed harvest on our farm. While we still have plenty of grain to haul, the exact impact of the relief is difficult to nail down. The biggest benefit will be felt by corn and soybean farmers," Perdue said.

"A farmer hauling 10 miles to market might save around $1.20 per 1,000 bushel load. Farmers who have fuel remaining in on-farm storage tanks may experience greater savings," he added.

While Trump has talked about the measure as being able to "drive down the costs of all goods, including groceries," Perdue said the savings wouldn't be large enough to affect North Dakota's farming costs or the prices consumers ultimately pay.

"Farmers and ranchers are 'price takers.' We do not control the prices consumers pay, and we don't often benefit from higher food prices," he said.

"In fact, farmers receive only 11.2 cents of the consumer food dollar. The actions will have modest benefits at the farm-level, but fuel costs remain significantly higher than in recent years," he continued.

The temporary expanded use of dyed diesel will have short-term benefits, Perdue said, "but high prices for fuel, fertilizer and other inputs are not sustainable. The best long-term solution is for the administration to bring an end to the Iran conflict, calm trade and other geopolitical conflicts, and tackle corporate consolidation in the markets farmers buy from and sell to."

In theory, Kloza said, the Trump administration's executive order "could bring diesel prices down by the 24.4cts/gal federal tax, but I would stress that global prices often trade in a 10-40cts/gal range each and every day," he said.

Kloza continued: "The world has a diesel problem—inventories are very low on both sides of the Atlantic, and there is no real solution in sight. These 'cosmetic' measures put a bit of downward pressure on prices."

How To Buy Dyed Diesel

While the purchase and use of dyed diesel is normally restricted, Trump said on Monday that the executive order he signed would "allow anyone to purchase tax-free red-dyed diesel for any reason."

Dyed diesel can typically be purchased from fuel distributors, agricultural or farm fuel suppliers, commercial fuel stations and some truck stops or equipment-fuel providers that have a pump labeled "Dyed Diesel," "Off-Road Diesel" or "Non-Taxable Diesel."

Federal rules require sellers to clearly label dyed diesel as "dyed diesel fuel, non-taxable use only, penalty for taxable use."

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Rebecca Flood and Shakeema Edwards.

Update 10/6/26, 10:35 a.m. ET: This article was updated with additional information.

Update 10/12/26, 3:45 a.m. ET: This article was updated with a comment from Todd Spencer.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines