Eric C. Tostrud, President Donald Trump’s then-nominee to be a District Court Judge for the District Court of Minnesota, gives testimony during a U. S. Senate Judiciary Committee Hearing on Capitol Hill in Washington on Wednesday, April 11, 2018.

...

Jenna Sundel

By Jenna Sundel

News Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A judge appointed by President Donald Trump found Department of Homeland Security (DHS) officials in contempt and ordered them to pay an immigrant detained by ICE.

Judge Eric C. Tostrud of the U.S. Minnesota District Court, who was appointed by Trump in 2018, on Monday granted a motion seeking civil-contempt compensation filed by the immigrant, who is identified as “Fernando T.”

“I find that Respondents’ conduct constitutes civil contempt, and Respondents (as defined herein) are jointly and severally liable for compensatory civil contempt sanctions for airfare costs Fernando incurred because of the violation,” Tostrud wrote.

Read More on News

The judge ordered the respondents, who include DHS Secretary Krist Noem and Acting Director of ICE Todd Lyons, to pay Fernando $568.29.

Eric C. Tostrud testifies during a U. S. Senate Judiciary Committee Hearing on Capitol Hill on April 11, 2018.

...

Why It Matters

Immigration enforcement has been a key focus of President Donald Trump’s administration. The administration has carried out a series of immigration enforcement operations in multiple states, including Minnesota.

The operations in Minnesota sparked protests and led to increased scrutiny of the Department of Homeland Security. Two U.S. citizens, Renee Good and Alex Pretti, were fatally shot by federal agents in the state last month as the department carried out enforcement operations.

What To Know

Fernando, a citizen of Mexico, filed a petition seeking his release from custody or a bond hearing on January 19 after he was arrested and detained in Minnesota for alleged immigration law violations.

The next day, Fernando filed a motion for a temporary restraining order, seeking to block his transfer from Minnesota while his petition was pending. Tostrud entered an order that same day, blocking DHS officials from moving Fernando out of Minnesota while his petition was pending.

Attorneys for the federal government said in a January 22 filing that Fernando was moved to Texas.

The judge included part of the response in his order, which read, “The undersigned counsel was randomly assigned to this case at 1425 on January 20. In that same communication, ICE was informed of the Order enjoining removal of Petitioner from Minnesota. On the same day, at 1503, ICE replied Petitioner was still in Minnesota and would not be removed outside the state. This morning at 0955, Respondent was made aware Petitioner was transported to Texas.”

A DHS spokesperson told Newsweek, "He was transferred shortly after the judge’s ruling. ICE officers had not yet been informed of the ruling and proceeded with the scheduled flight to a detention center."

The judge said the respondents admitted they violated the January 20 order by transferring Fernando to El Paso, “despite knowledge that his movement outside of this District was enjoined.”

“Respondents provide no explanation for Fernando’s transfer to El Paso despite the enjoinment of his movement from this District,” Tostrud wrote.

Fernando’s petition was granted on January 24. Tostrud said he was released the next day in El Paso, Texas, without his belongings.

“Respondents have not explained why they withheld Fernando’s belongings when they released him,” Tostrud said.

Fernando’s counsel paid $568.29 for Fernando’s airfare to return to Minnesota, the judge said.

“On January 23, I issued an Order requiring Respondents to identify Fernando’s location and the schedule for his return to the District of Minnesota, warning that absent assurance of Petitioner’s return by January 24, 2026, an Order to Show Cause would issue ...,” Tostrud wrote. “There is no dispute that Respondents had actual notice of both the January 20 and January 23 Orders—on January 23, Respondents affirmatively 'confirmed[ed] ICE informed it has [Fernando] scheduled to be back in Minnesota tomorrow, 24 January 2026.' ECF ... Despite this assurance, Fernando was released in El Paso on January 25, without his belongings.”

In a letter to the judge, attorneys for the respondents began by “acknowledging [Fernando] was released in El Paso, Texas, and that is a violation of this Court’s Order,” according to the order.

The letter also included “Respondents’ counsel’s efforts to instruct the agency ‘[a]t all times’ to return Fernando back to Minnesota,” according to the judge.

Tostrud wrote, “In a footnote, the letter explains that the ‘likely reason’ that Fernando’s January 24 flight from El Paso was canceled was a ‘major winter storm leading to [a] state emergency declaration’ in Texas ... The letter further states that Respondents’ counsel ‘does not have any indication the decision to release in Texas was made in willful disregard for [sic] the Court’s order.’”

The judge said that the respondents imply that “a canceled flight, a winter snowstorm, or haste to comply with the Court’s January 24, 2026 Order directing Fernando’s release” excuses the contempt in this case. He ruled that these explanations “do not support an inability to comply with the January 20 Order.”

A judge in another immigration case recently said the Minnesota District Court found a federal official in civil contempt of court. The petitioner in that case, Rigoberto Soto Jimenez, was also detained by ICE and ordered to be released after challenging his detention in court.

The court granted Soto Jimenez’s petition on February 9 and ordered the government to release him in Minnesota by February 13. The court also ordered the government to “return all property to him,” and file a status update no later than 3 p.m. on February 17, "certifying compliance with the order.”

“None of that happened,” Judge Laura M. Provinzino of the U.S. Minnesota District Court said in an order filed Friday. “Instead, Rigoberto S. J.’s counsel (not the Government) informed the Court on February 17 (after the Government’s deadline had passed) that Rigoberto S. J. had been released on February 12 in Texas (not Minnesota), and that the Government had kept his identity documents (specifically, his Minnesota Driver’s License, Minnesota Instruction Permit, and Mexican Consular ID card).”

Soto Jimenez’s attorneys also arranged for his return to Minnesota, the judge said.

Provinzino said that at a hearing, “it quickly became apparent that the Government had no idea what had happened in this case.”

“As an alumna of the U.S. Attorney’s Office for this District, this Court has immense respect for the dedicated attorneys of that office who live out its vital mission of doing justice. But it has become painfully clear over the past several months that the attorneys working on immigration habeas cases lack the basis resources and, in some cases, training necessary to comply with judicial orders,” Provinzino wrote in an order.

What People Are Saying

Judge Eric C. Tostrud of the U.S. Minnesota District Court, in an order: “To the extent Respondents imply that a canceled flight, a winter snowstorm, or haste to comply with the Court’s January 24, 2026 Order directing Fernando’s release excuse their contempt, these asserted justifications do not support an inability to comply with the January 20 Order. Respondents acknowledge they violated that Order.”

A DHS spokesperson told Newsweek: "We work as quickly as possible to process illegal aliens after their arrests.”

What Happens Next

Tostrud noted that he granted the motion without a hearing and gave respondents until Saturday to request a hearing. If no motion is filed, the order will be effective on March 1.

Do you have a story that Newsweek should be covering? Do you have any questions about this story? Contact LiveNews@newsweek.com

Update 2/25/26, 3:57 p.m. ET: This article was updated with comment from the Department of Homeland Security.

In a polarized era, the center is dismissed as bland. At Newsweek, ours is different: The Courageous Center—it's not "both sides," it's sharp, challenging and alive with ideas. We follow facts, not factions. If that sounds like the kind of journalism you want to see thrive, we need you.

When you become a Newsweek Member, you support a mission to keep the center strong and vibrant. Members enjoy: Ad-free browsing, exclusive content and editor conversations. Help keep the center courageous. Join today.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines