10
Loading video...

By Jesus Mesa
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
President Donald Trump's approval rating has settled in the high 30s to low 40s, and the generic congressional ballot has favored Democrats by roughly 6 to 7 points for months. By the historical patterns that usually govern midterm elections, that combination should be enough to hand Democrats the House and put the Senate within reach.
The party controlling the White House has lost an average of 22 House seats in a midterm going back decades, a pattern rooted less in any single policy failure than in a durable voter instinct that change is healthy.
"We’re facing typical midterm election political headwinds and some economic headwinds, because people are concerned about the economy and costs and everything else, which they should be since those are pocketbook issues. That’s what most elections are really about," told reporters Senate Majority Leader John Thune during an event Friday at Southeast Technical College in Sioux Falls, South Dakota.
Read More on Politics
But three factors sitting on top of that grim polling picture could still be enough to keep Republicans in power in November: a redistricting push that reshaped the House map in the GOP's favor, a Supreme Court ruling that just handed the party's Senate campaign arm a fundraising advantage, and a Senate map so structurally tilted toward Republicans that Democrats have almost no room for error.
A Cushion Built From New Maps and a Court Ruling
New congressional maps in Texas, Missouri, Indiana, Florida and other states have given Republicans a net gain of roughly 12 to 14 seats nationally this cycle, while Democrats have clawed back a handful in California. The effort is the largest mid-decade redistricting push either party has undertaken in a generation. It also changes the math for how many seats Democrats need to flip to take control of the House.
A June Supreme Court ruling adds another advantage for Republicans in the Senate. The decision struck down limits on coordinated spending between national party committees and their candidates, giving the committee with more cash on hand greater room to coordinate spending. For now, that is the National Republican Senatorial Committee. The dynamic is different in the House, where the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee continues to outraise the National Republican Congressional Committee.
Then there is the Senate math itself. Democrats need to flip four seats to win control of the chamber, and only one race, North Carolina, currently leans their way. Everything else on the map would have to break in their favor on election night for Democrats to have a realistic path to the majority.
Republican strategists who spoke with Newsweek describe those three factors as real, but not sufficient on their own to overcome the environment.
"These new boundaries are not impenetrable," said Alex Patton, a Republican strategist at Ozean Media. "The current political environment remains so unfavorable for Republicans that they are still likely to lose the House, just by a smaller margin than otherwise expected."
Matt Klink, a Republican strategist at Klink Campaigns, described the same trade-off in the Senate. Maine, Alaska and Ohio are the true tossups that will decide which party controls the chamber, he said, with Michigan and Texas as more competitive wild cards and Kansas worth watching only if November 3 turns into a full wave election for Democrats, an outcome he called highly unlikely.
"These factors must be balanced against a horrible election environment for Republicans, particularly voter frustration with the Trump Administration, and general minority party gains in midterm elections," Klink said.
Related Story

The Price America Pays for Trump’s Reliance on Kushner the Closer
Related Story

Moderna Cancer Trial Success Is a Shot in the Arm for Trump
Where the Race Is Being Played
Some Republicans see a relatively narrow group of Senate races as the real battleground, with a handful of states likely to determine whether the party holds its majority. Their assessments differ on how far Democrats could expand the map, but they largely agree on the most consequential contests.
Klink divided the Senate battlefield into three tiers. He described Maine, Alaska and Ohio as the true tossups that will determine control of the chamber, with Michigan and Texas as more competitive wild cards. Kansas sits another step out, he said, and would become relevant only if Democrats were headed for a full-scale wave on November 3, which he considers highly unlikely.
"Democrats need to net four seats. North Carolina is the only seat currently leaning their way, which is exactly why everything needs to break the right way on Election Night for the Democrats to have a chance," he said.
Related Story

Donald Trump’s Advantage on Immigration Has Collapsed
Thune offered a similar assessment. Republicans are playing offense in Michigan, Minnesota, New Hampshire and Georgia, he said on Friday, arguing that Democratic Senate nominees in Michigan and Minnesota come from the party's left flank and make both states more competitive this cycle. On defense, he identified Maine, Ohio, Iowa and Alaska as the party's firewall.
"If we don't keep certain states, we'll lose control of the Senate," Thune said.
Patton emphasized Texas more than either Klink or Thune, pointing to Democrat James Talarico's challenge to Republican Attorney General Ken Paxton as a test of whether the GOP's structural advantages can withstand a strong Democratic candidate. He described Paxton as deeply flawed and Talarico as exceptionally strong, though he acknowledged that Democrats still have a long way to go before Texas becomes a true blue-wave target.

...
"I will believe a Democrat can win Texas, when a Democrat wins Texas," Patton said. "If Talarico wins, the rout is on."
Patton also pointed to Maine, where he said Democrats have run a chaotic campaign operation, culminating in Graham Platner’s withdrawal, but still have a real chance against Susan Collins, a longtime Republican incumbent, because of the broader political environment.
A Republican-favored map, he said, cannot fully shield individual candidates from a national mood this unfavorable to the GOP. "Something unexpected and weird is likely to happen in November due to this environment," Patton said.
A recent Fox News poll shows Democratic candidates leading in six other battleground states: Georgia, North Carolina, Ohio, Iowa, Texas and Maine. Those gains would offset a loss in Michigan and give Democrats a Senate majority if the party nets four seats on November 3. Republicans lead only in Michigan, a Democratic-held seat.
How the Supreme Court Rewired the Money
The battleground may be narrow, but Republicans have another advantage in the races that matter most: money. The new spending rules give the National Republican Senatorial Committee (NRSC) more flexibility to put its resources directly behind candidates, potentially stretching its advertising dollars further than Democratic committees can.
For now, that gives Republicans an edge in the Senate. The balance is reversed in the House, where the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee continues to outraise the National Republican Congressional Committee.
In a donor memo obtained by the Washington Reporter, the NRSC called itself "the most important investment vehicle in the 2026 cycle" now that the spending cap is gone. Before the ruling, the committee said that coordinated spending was capped at roughly $4 million per race. Spending beyond that amount had to go through an independent expenditure arm that was legally barred from communicating with the campaign, a firewall the memo said resulted in "waste, duplication, and misaligned messaging."
The NRSC is now winding down that independent expenditure unit and shifting to ad buys coordinated directly with candidates. The committee says the change lets it buy the same airtime at the discounted rate available to campaigns rather than the higher rate paid by outside groups.

...
The financial advantage is already visible in some of the races Republicans see as central to holding the Senate. In Maine, Republicans have reserved $107 million in advertising, compared with $55.5 million for Democrats, in the race between Senator Susan Collins and Democrat Troy Jackson.
The new rules could widen that gap by allowing the NRSC to make coordinated purchases at the campaign rate. NRSC Chair Tim Scott has told donors that spending in Maine alone could reach $600 million, with North Carolina potentially drawing even more.
Ohio and Michigan are also part of the NRSC's new spending strategy. The committee has said it will wind down its independent expenditure operation in both states and shift to coordinated ad buys with candidates. Internally, the NRSC has described the resulting rate advantage as three to 13 times cheaper than what outside groups pay for the same airtime.
That financial edge only matters if Republicans have voters to spend it on persuading, and the party's own numbers suggest the electorate isn't sold on either side. Pew Research found the two parties within a point of each other in the spring, with 59 percent of adults holding an unfavorable view of Democrats against 58 percent for Republicans.
Iran War: The Variable Nobody Controls
None of the structural advantages are guaranteed to hold through November. Klink said reversing the historical midterm pattern would require a fast and favorable end to the war with Iran, fuel prices returning to prewar levels, and a stronger economic rebound than the current uneven recovery has produced. Thune pointed to the same variable.
"Ultimately the way people are going to judge this is: How is it affecting the economy, how is it affecting gas prices, is the Strait of Hormuz open?" Thune said.
The polling average maintained by Silver Bulletin, the newsletter run by statistician Nate Silver, put Trump's approval rating at 38.1 percent and his disapproval rating at 58.2 percent as of August 18, for a net rating of -20.1. Approval has not been lower at any point since Trump's second term began, according to the tracker. Net approval reached its widest point of the summer on July 30, when the gap hit -20.6.
Those numbers show that even the most optimistic Republican strategists concede the party's private mood does not match its public confidence.
"In private, when the microphones are off, most read the tea leaves and whisper, 'It's going to be a bad night,'" Patton said.
Thune, asked directly whether Republicans can hold the Senate majority, did not promise it.
"It's a tough year," he said. "These midterms always are."
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Jason Lemon and Sam Wilson.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines