
Photo-illustration by Newsweek/Getty

By Hugh Cameron
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
President Donald Trump’s plan to import Argentine beef and rein in rocketing domestic prices has already sparked a political firestorm, and the proposal now faces another issue that could threaten Americans' food safety and elements of his economic agenda.
On Sunday, the president told reporters that the U.S. could purchase “some” of the country's supplies to curb rising consumer costs—comments which have led to a growing chorus of criticism from farmers and lawmakers within his own party, who both view the proposal as undermining domestic agriculture and a betrayal of the “America First” promise on which Trump was elected.
The backlash deepened after Trump said the enraged farmers “don’t understand” the benefits his policies have provided them, and urged them to “get their prices down.”
Read More on Politics
“American farmers aren’t doing well, in fact we are struggling more than under Biden,” John Boyd, founder of the National Black Farmers Association, previously told Newsweek.
“It's unconscionable to tell struggling farmers to lower prices while they're losing their farms.”
A White House official confirmed to Reuters on Thursday that the U.S. will be quadrupling the amount of beef that can be imported from Argentina at a reduced tariff rate, raising the quota to 80,000 metric tons.

Photo-illustration by Newsweek/Getty
But beyond the political fallout lies a more material risk, namely that the beef destined for American shelves through the deal may not come from Argentina at all.
In a letter sent to the president on Tuesday, the U.S. Cattlemen’s Association (USCA) noted that Argentina is currently importing record levels of beef from Brazil to address its own issues with supply and soaring prices, which it said indicates “that U.S.-bound 'Argentine' beef could actually be Brazilian.”
“There are growing concerns that Brazil—a country previously suspended over food safety—could ship beef to Argentina for re-export to the U.S. under an Argentinian label, then taking advantage of a ‘Product of USA’ loophole,” the trade group wrote.
“Imported beef that is merely sliced, trimmed, or repackaged in the U.S. can receive a domestic label," it explained. "This practice enables multinational packers—especially the Big 4—to flood the market with cheaper imported product, sell it at U.S. prices, and significantly increase profit margins, all while U.S. beef is unfairly cast as ‘too expensive.’'"
Newsweek contacted Argentina’s agricultural ministry on Thursday for comment. The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) did not address this risk when approached, but a spokesperson said that Secretary Brooke Rollins was “committed to reduce risk for cattle producers, deliver robust disaster relief to cattle country, and support new and beginning ranchers across the country."
“These actions coupled with President Trump’s work to secure lasting markets for beef producers abroad sends a strong message to American cattle producers—raise more beef and rebuild the herd,” they added.
Brazil has historically been one of America’s principal beef suppliers, and continued to ship at record levels for the first seven months of 2025. However, exports have begun to slip and are expected to fall further after Trump imposed a 50-percent tariff on the country—bringing total rate on beef to around 76 percent given the tariff-free export quota has already been exceeded for the year.
The Cattlemen's Association on Tuesday said that there was a “high” likelihood of Brazil taking advantage of Argentina's strong relationship with the U.S., and using the beef-buying program “to dump more inferior beef into Argentina and therefore into the U.S.”
“The U.S. is at risk of indirectly subsidizing Brazilian beef, through Argentine imports,” it said, “a move that would undermine America First goals while rewarding unreliable foreign supply chains.”
In an interview with Newsweek, USCA President Justin Tupper said this would not be out of character for the Brazilian meat industry, whom he called “notoriously bad actors” while citing past scandals involving child labor, deforestation and corruption.
A notable case came in 2017, when an investigation dubbed “Operation Weak Flesh” revealed that the sector had bribed health inspectors and government officials to overlook tainted meat, some of which was mislabeled and eventually shipped to major markets including the E.U., China and the U.S.
Bill Bullard, CEO of the Ranchers-Cattlemen Action Legal Fund, told Newsweek his group had concerns over a repeat of this episode with several South American countries beyond Brazil, “as we don’t believe they have the necessary veterinary and enforcement infrastructure to maintain the higher production and safety standards here in the United States.”
And beyond the potential safety implications, Tupper said the possibility of Brazil transshipping beef through Argentina would directly undermine Trump’s tariffs on the country—of which U.S. farmers have been supportive—while further reducing the competitiveness of America’s producers.
“Brazil, their prices are really low right now. They’re notoriously low,” he said. “So they can buy it extremely cheap and put it into a market that [is] the highest we’ve ever been.”
But even if every ounce of meat imported under Trump’s plan comes directly from Argentina, U.S. cattlemen are still cautious that this will undermine America's ranchers while doing little to meaningfully lower prices.
“Argentine beef imports will only lower the price of hamburger meat, not high-quality cuts like ribeyes, strips, and sirloin,” Texas Agricultural Commissioner Sid Miller said on Thursday. “We already import grass-fed Argentine beef, which is ground into hamburger meat because it comes from Brahman breeds that produce tough, stringy meat. Importing more of it does nothing to strengthen America’s beef industry or improve food quality for consumers.”
And Trump's own Agriculture Secretary has raised concerns about Argentine cattle potentially carrying foot-and-mouth disease (FMD). While Argentine officials have disputed this as an issue, pointing to the country's recognized FMD-free status, others continue to caution that the issue remains one to watch if the U.S. plans to significantly increase imports.
“FMD has always been a worry about importing fresh and frozen product from anywhere in South America,” livestock and food economist David P. Anderson told Newsweek. “Cattle producers have been very skeptical about importing fresh beef from there due to disease worries and worries about those countries disease reporting, controls, safeguards, inspection and the like.”
And as anger continues to grow over the plan to import more foreign beef, the USDA has sought to ease the concerns of America’s own ranchers, releasing a three-prong plan on Wednesday it says will “strengthen the American beef industry” with financial, regulatory and market support.
But after years of market shocks and rising costs, and a new influx of Argentine beef poised to undercut their own, it is unclear whether the administration’s new measures will be enough to keep farmers' livelihoods and loyalty intact.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines