10
Loading video...
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The federal government’s killing of a nursing wild foal and two other young horses during a Wyoming roundup has prompted a petition demanding an investigation into how the Bureau of Land Management decides when animals deemed blind should be euthanized.
The dispute is drawing renewed attention to the Trump administration’s management of America’s wild horses as the BLM expands removals from public lands and faces scrutiny from animal welfare advocates over what happens to horses after they are taken off the range.
More than 20,000 people have signed the petition over the death of Saffron, a young cremello foal, while the sanctuary behind the campaign is calling for veterinary examinations before horses are euthanized for suspected blindness and offering to take members of Saffron’s surviving family.
Read More on News
The deaths occurred during the BLM’s 2026 Red Desert Complex gathering in Wyoming, which ran from October 15 to 27. The agency said the operation was intended to address overpopulation and protect rangeland across the Antelope Hills, Crooks Mountain, Green Mountain, Lost Creek and Stewart Creek herd management areas. It planned to gather about 1,035 horses during the fall operation.
The BLM has said the three horses were euthanized because of their lack of eyesight, not their pigmentation. Clare Staples, founder of Oregon-based Skydog Sanctuary and creator of the petition, disputes the determination and told Newsweek that her organization would have taken the horses even if they had been blind.
Newsweek has contacted the Bureau of Land Management and the Department of the Interior for comment.
...
Why Saffron's Death Is Being Challenged
Staples told Newsweek that her concerns about the treatment of cream-colored, blue-eyed horses predated Saffron’s death. She said she became concerned three years ago after 11 of 22 horses euthanized during an Oregon roundup were cremellos, prompting her to contact BLM officials and offer sanctuary to horses with special needs.
When Saffron and two other young cremello horses from the same band were killed during the Wyoming operation, Staples said the combination of their coloring and age immediately alarmed her.
"The fact that they killed three cremello horses in the same band was unusual and the fact that they were so young was horrifying," Staples told Newsweek.
Staples also questioned the blindness determination after reviewing video Wyoming photographer Chad Hanson recorded weeks before the roundup. She said the footage showed Saffron responding visually to other horses' behavior and sometimes walking ahead of her mother.
"We have a dozen or partially sighted horses and two completely blind horses at Skydog and I very much recognize the behavior of blind horses," Staples said. "I did not see signs of blindness in Saffron in the video I observed."
That observation does not establish that Saffron had normal vision when BLM personnel later assessed her. It does, however, form a central part of Staples' challenge to the agency's decision and her demand for an independent review.
What Science Says About Blue-Eyed Horses and Blindness
Scientific evidence challenges the broader assumption that blue-eyed horses are inherently more prone to vision problems.
A 2014 peer-reviewed study published in Equine Veterinary Education examined 164 eyes from horses with diagnosed ocular disease and 212 eyes from horses without ocular disease. Researchers found blue eyes were equally common in the two groups and found no increased prevalence of several categories of eye disease among blue-eyed horses.
The study did identify an important distinction: horses with blue or heterochromic irises were more likely to develop ocular squamous cell carcinoma than horses with brown irises. But researchers did not find them more likely to have corneal or intraocular/orbital disease or to be presented for ophthalmic disease generally.
Veterinary ophthalmologist Amber Labelle, one of the study's authors, has previously said the findings counter the misconception that blue irises make horses more likely to suffer cataracts, vision problems or recurrent uveitis.
Staples said she believes an enduring belief about cremellos and blindness may have influenced the decision involving Saffron. BLM, however, has said pigmentation was not the reason the horses were euthanized.
Questions Over How BLM Determined the Horses Were Blind
The core of the dispute is therefore not whether a blue-eyed horse can be blind, but how blindness was diagnosed in this case and whether that diagnosis warranted immediate euthanasia.
Staples told Newsweek that the testing at the trap involved a "menace response," which generally assesses whether an animal reacts to a threatening gesture toward an eye. She argues that relying on the response under roundup conditions was inadequate and says a veterinary eye specialist told her such a response can be unreliable in young foals.
"The BLM's gather reports give no indication that a veterinarian examined the horses before they were euthanized," Staples said, adding that the agency has said its staff and contractors are qualified to identify blindness and other health conditions.
That distinction could matter because the BLM says it checks horses arriving at designated holding facilities after the Red Desert gather with a veterinarian. The agency's description of the operation also says staff and contractors conduct gathers under its Comprehensive Animal Welfare Program, including special precautions for foals and other compromised animals.
Staples and the petitioners want an additional safeguard earlier in the process: a requirement that an equine veterinarian assess animals at the trap site before blindness is used as grounds for euthanasia.
"Qualified equine veterinarians need to be present at the trap sites during roundups, and must assess the horses before euthanasia decisions are made," Staples said.
Sanctuary Says the Horses Could Have Been Saved
Skydog Sanctuary says it had another option available regardless of whether BLM's diagnosis was correct.
Staples told Newsweek that she has repeatedly informed BLM personnel at corrals that the sanctuary is prepared to accept blind and other special-needs horses. She said there is no consistent BLM-wide process guaranteeing such horses will be offered to sanctuaries before euthanasia and that individual decisions can be made at the field level.
Had Saffron been confirmed blind, Staples said Skydog still would have accepted her, along with her mother and sister.
"Skydog absolutely would have loved to take not just Saffron, but her mother and her sister as well," Staples said. "We would have provided immediate sanctuary, and safely transported them by keeping them together."
Staples said the sanctuary already cares for horses with a range of visual impairments, including a completely blind mare rescued following a Forest Service roundup who lives with a younger daughter that helps guide her. Other visually impaired horses at the sanctuary, she said, live with herds across large areas of rugged terrain.
"Whether or not Saffron and the two other youngsters were visually impaired, they did not have to die," Staples said. "Unfortunately, BLM reached for a gun instead of the phone."
Petition Demands Investigation and New BLM Safeguards
The petition asks BLM Director Steve Pearce to investigate the circumstances surrounding the deaths, including how often cremello horses are euthanized and what evidence was used to determine that Saffron and the two other horses could not see.
Staples said she wants an accounting of who assessed the horses, what behavior they observed and who ultimately authorized the killings.
"I would like to be given a report of what happened that day, what behavior they observed to make this life and death decision, and who made the ultimate decision and shot those babies," she said.
The petition also calls for suspected blindness to be evaluated by a qualified veterinarian before euthanasia and for BLM to make greater use of sanctuaries willing to accept horses with disabilities or other special needs.
Staples is separately asking BLM to release Saffron's mother, Moonflower, and another cremello foal to Skydog. She said Saffron was still nursing when the family was separated and that she wants to prevent the surviving horses from remaining in federal holding or facing euthanasia over possible vision problems.
Wild Horse Roundups Expand Under Trump Administration
The controversy comes amid a much larger federal effort to reduce wild horse populations on Western public lands.
For the Red Desert Complex alone, BLM said recent aerial surveys showed an estimated 2,278 wild horses in an area it estimated could sustainably support 480 to 720. The agency said it planned to gather about 1,035 horses to reduce pressure on forage and water during severe drought conditions.
BLM says wild horse populations can grow by 15 to 20 percent annually and potentially double within four to five years without management. The agency argues that excessive populations can deplete forage and water, damage habitat and ultimately put the horses themselves at risk of starvation and injury.
The agency's fiscal 2027 schedule calls for a combination of removals and fertility control in the Red Desert Complex, with horses treated with GonaCon and some returned to the range.
The administration's broader approach was already under scrutiny before Saffron's death. As Newsweek previously reported, approximately 3,700 wild horses were sold by BLM in 2025, more than twice the previous year's total, according to bureau records cited by The New York Times. Animal welfare advocates have raised concerns that horses resold after leaving federal custody could ultimately enter slaughter channels.
In that earlier report, the Department of the Interior told Newsweek that BLM "does not sell or send wild horses or burros to slaughter" and investigates allegations involving violations of federal law or sales agreements.
BLM maintains that removals are necessary to satisfy its responsibilities to both the animals and public lands. In announcing the Red Desert operation, the agency said its program operates under the Wild Free-Roaming Horses and Burros Act and that it would prepare gathered horses suitable for placement for adoption or sale.
For Staples, however, Saffron's death raises a narrower question within the larger fight over wild horse management: whether an animal judged disabled should be killed when a sanctuary is prepared to take it.
"My hope is that Saffron will not have died in vain," Staples said. "I hope that it will result in the BLM offering more special needs horses to sanctuaries and rescues that I know will be willing and happy to take them rather than see them shot."
She described Saffron as "the most beautiful, tiny golden foal" and said she hopes the case leads to greater scrutiny of how vulnerable horses are treated during future federal roundups.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Steve Mollman, Gray R. Thomas
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines