10
Loading video...

By Faye James
US news reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
President Donald Trump’s plan to replace advanced aircraft-launch and weapons-elevator systems on a future U.S. aircraft carrier with older technology could add billions of dollars and years of delays to the project, according to a warning from the Senate Appropriations Committee.
The issue is mentioned in an explanatory statement accompanying a proposed fiscal year 2027 defense spending bill. The statement says a major redesign could add "many billions of dollars to the program, and calls for more analysis before changes proceed.
An August memorandum by Trump directed that a plan be developed for replacing the systems on CVN-81, the future USS Doris Miller. The memorandum gives the Department of War 60 days to provide the president with proposed measures, timelines and resource requirements. It does not order a retrofit of every existing carrier.
Read More on News

...
The debate is unfolding as the Navy’s schedule for the ship has already slipped. Its fiscal 2027 shipbuilding plan moved CVN-81’s expected delivery from February 2032 to February 2034, citing shipyard construction-space constraints. That delay was identified before any potential redesign.
Newsweek has reached out to the White House, the Department of Defense and the Senate Appropriations Committee for comment via email outside office hours.
What Trump’s Plan Would Change
The U.S. Navy currently has two Ford-class aircraft carriers in active service and the USS Doris Miller will be the third. Ford-class carriers use the Electromagnetic Aircraft Launch System, or EMALS, to launch aircraft from their flight decks. The system uses stored kinetic energy and electrical power conversion rather than steam pressure. The ships also use Advanced Weapons Elevators, which move munitions from storage areas to the flight deck.
Trump’s memorandum calls for planning a switch to steam catapults and hydraulic elevators on CVN-81. Those systems were used on earlier carriers, and the White House has described the change as a return to traditional technology, while the Senate committee says the Navy should compare the systems’ performance and costs before proceeding.
The difference involves more than swapping one piece of equipment for another. The Navy describes Ford-class ships as having an all-electric design, with systems built around electrical power rather than steam service lines. A change to steam and hydraulic equipment could require redesign work across the ship and its aircraft operations.
The Senate committee has asked the Navy to assess how the older catapults could affect aircraft not designed to withstand their higher launch stresses. It also wants comparisons of elevator speed and efficiency, and estimates of the staffing needed to operate and maintain steam catapults.
Why the Cost Could Grow
The committee’s warning is not a detailed estimate or a bill for taxpayers. It gives no specific dollar figure or schedule analysis. Instead, it says the potential redesign could add "many billions" and "many years" to the CVN-81 project and directs the Navy to provide Congress with a report if the legislation is enacted.
The scale of the ship helps explain why a redesign could be expensive. The Navy’s fiscal 2026 budget estimated CVN-81’s procurement cost at about $15.2 billion, before its delivery schedule was moved to 2034. That is the budget estimate for the carrier itself, not an estimate of the cost to change its launch and elevator systems.
The Navy awarded General Atomics a $1.204 billion contract modification for EMALS and the Advanced Arresting Gear on CVN-81. The contract covers production, installation and support for those systems; it is not a published estimate of the cost to switch to steam and hydraulic equipment.
How much work has progressed, which components could be reused and whether contracts would need to be altered are central questions for the Navy and contractor. The committee’s proposal calls for a cost and schedule assessment covering construction and retrofits, as well as the operational effects of a switch.
Newsweek has reached out to the Navy and General Atomics for comment via email outside office hours

...
What the Navy’s Performance Record Shows
The Senate committee says recent combat experience with Ford-class carriers appears to demonstrate higher sortie rates, readiness and combat effectiveness than earlier-generation carriers. In July, a Navy official said the USS *Gerald R. Ford’*s 326-day deployment involved more than 11,000 fixed-wing aircraft launches and recoveries.
The Navy says EMALS can launch a wider range of aircraft, from lightweight unmanned systems to heavy strike fighters, and offers smoother acceleration and reduced maintenance requirements compared with steam catapults. Those are the service’s stated benefits; they do not by themselves settle whether the newer systems have met every performance goal.
An independent Pentagon testing office has documented continuing challenges. Its fiscal 2025 report said EMALS reliability remained consistent with earlier test data and noted that the Ford-class had yet to demonstrate weapons transfer to the flight deck at rates matching its design reference mission. That record gives lawmakers a basis to seek comparisons while showing why performance claims need to be assessed against operational test data.
At a Senate hearing Tuesday, Acting Navy Secretary nominee Hung Cao defended the administration’s push, saying the current systems had contributed to delays. Senator Roger Wicker, the Republican chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee, said: "Returning to steam is a nonstarter." Senator Tim Kaine, a Democrat, urged Cao to consider sailors’ experience before pursuing a potentially more expensive or less capable change.
Newsweek has reached out to Senator Roger Wicker’s office for comment via email outside office hours.
What Congress Could Do
The Senate Appropriations Committee’s explanatory statement warns against a major change without "substantive analysis, justification, and Congressional approval." It also directs the Navy to provide a report within 90 days of the bill’s enactment, comparing sortie rates, aircraft compatibility, elevator performance, costs, schedule effects, combat survivability and staffing needs.
That language is part of a spending proposal; the explanatory statement alone does not block the administration’s plan. Congress could use binding legislation or funding restrictions to limit or condition the redesign. The White House memorandum itself says the plan is subject to applicable law and appropriations.
The dispute is therefore about more than whether steam or electromagnetic systems are better. It will also turn on the Navy’s cost and engineering analysis, what Congress puts into law, and whether officials can show that a redesign would improve carrier performance enough to justify the expense and schedule risk.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Rebecca Flood and Tony Phillips.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines