

By Hugh Cameron
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Ten months into his second term, President Donald Trump is being challenged by the very base he prides himself on creating, and he finds himself besieged by an army of issues that could threaten his MAGA support and spell trouble for lawmakers who remain by his side.
Reeling over the farmer furor that has met his plan to import Argentine beef, and now from Democratic victories in last week's off-cycle elections, Trump is facing friendly fire over perceived pivots on immigration, the state of the economy and the latest episode of the long-running Epstein saga that has dogged his second administration's every step.
Many of these tensions came to a head in an interview with Laura Ingraham that aired on Monday, during which the Fox News host challenged the president on offering 600,000 visas to Chinese students and his unexpected praise for the H-1B visa program, characterizing these as decidedly anti-MAGA stances.
Read More on Politics
Trump's defense—that China is no worse an adversary than France, and that foreign-born workers are needed to account for the U.S.'s lack of talent—seems to have sparked as much backlash as the positions themselves, though the White House says Trump's core commitments remain unchanged.
"In record time, President Trump has done more than any president in modern history to tighten our immigration laws and put American workers first," White House spokesperson Taylor Rogers told Newsweek, referencing the $100,000 fee attached to new H-1B applications and the Department of Labor's crackdown on abuse within the program.
The president himself was quick to reject the idea of a divide developing within the MAGA camp over any of these issues.
"Don't forget: MAGA was my idea. MAGA was nobody else's idea," he said on The Ingraham Angle. "I know what MAGA wants better than anyone else, and MAGA wants to see our country thrive."

...
A 'Presidency in Trouble'
"I think the MAGA base is splitting," said Peter Loge, a professor of media and public affairs at George Washington University. "Donald Trump will never lose his core support, but what it means to be MAGA or a true Republican is now suddenly being debated."
Loge, a former senior adviser to President Barack Obama, told Newsweek that the combination of snafus embroiling the administration, rather than any one issue specifically, seems to indicate Trump might be losing his footing.
"We connect the dots to make pictures, and the recent dots include Epstein, the election, the court being very skeptical of Trump's tariff policies, increasing economic insecurity, falling poll numbers," he said. "These bits of information, these dots, paint a picture of a presidency in trouble."
Todd Belt, a professor of political management at George Washington University, said evidence for fracturing in the president's base included the town hall meetings at which GOP lawmakers have been confronted over their support for the president. Further evidence were the lawmakers and media figures—the MAGA "elite"—who appear increasingly comfortable breaking with Trump on key issues.
Belt noted additional issues that had eroded the perception of an unflappable MAGA support for the president, including growing discontent with the U.S.'s support for Israel and Trump's "flip on Ukraine" that angered MAGA's isolationist wing. He added, the "really big one is Epstein."
The Justice Department's reluctance to release all documents related to the late convicted sex offender, and new details regarding Trump’s relationship to Epstein, have left the president, once the populist outsider, accused of becoming the very establishment he sought to overthrow.
"I think MAGA, in terms of the movement, is willing to forgive Donald Trump on a lot of things because they consider him to be the businessman, and he knows what he's doing when he's going back and forth with his tariffs and disruptive sort of behavior," Belt said. "But this is the one where it just really violates the ideology of, you know, deep state cover-ups and being an outsider—all the things that he promised and now seems to be on the other side of."
Though lawmakers in the lower chamber secured enough signatures to force a House vote on releasing the Epstein files, Belt believed the bill would fail to pass the Senate and avoid the explosive prospect of a Trump veto, adding that the issue itself was one that would remain a persistent thorn in the side of Trump's presidency.
Trump's Affordability Crisis
This latest flare-up in the Epstein saga adds to the woes Trump already faces over the economy—with polls finding that his approval on key issues, such as inflation, continues to erode even among Republicans.
Political scientist Sheri Berman argues that the one-two punch of Epstein and affordability—an issue many now agree has had political consequences for the GOP—has created a threat to Trump's presidency unlike any seen before, rattling both the hard-liners for whom the Epstein saga is central and the collection of "potentially switchable" voters who will consider rising costs when casting votes in 2026 and beyond.
"Either one of those things alone is something to manage, but the combination of discontent with the hardcore hard right and fears that these broad affordability issues might be causing people who might waver between voting Republican and Democrat to vote for Democrat," she told Newsweek, "that is a somewhat different situation than Trump has faced in the past."
Alongside criticizing his apparent defectors—telling reporters that Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene has "lost her way"—Trump's strategy has been to take a page from the book of his long-serving political confidant Roger Stone and deny outright that there is any issue to contend with.
The president has repeatedly claimed that grocery prices "are way down," contradicting the kitchen-table realities of most Americans, while declaring both affordability and uproar over Epstein are hoaxes created by his rivals.
"You can't out-message the economy," Belt said. "What people are feeling and what they're seeing in their finances, you can never out-message that in terms of saying it's a hoax."
Democratic strategist Doug Gordon believed Trump's conundrum was one he himself could overcome, at least with the diehards over whom he still holds an "iron grip." But Gordon told Newsweek that proximity to the president could come back to bite Republicans who have till now been able to rely on it for political lift.
"The problem for Republicans—which was once again made apparent in the recent elections—is that MAGA is a cult of personality," he said*.* "And when Trump isn't on the ballot, the MAGA base either splinters or stays home."
Loge called the 2026 midterms a "proxy for Donald Trump and Donald Trump's policies," one that will force Republicans to decide whether to upset the commander in chief or their constituents.
"Republicans are going to be in the position of having to either continue to defend an unpopular president and unpopular policies and risk losing the general election," he said, "or attacking an unpopular president and unpopular policies and risk getting attacked by that president during the election."
MAGA remains Trump's creation, and its most faithful will likely remain by his side through this perilous chapter of his presidency, but members of the broader Republican Party may soon discover the costs of devotion as they barrel toward a midterm reckoning.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines