Newsweek/AP

David Averre

By David Averre

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Jared Kushner spent Sunday in a room that Washington had treated as off-limits for nearly three decades: sitting across the table from the leader of Hamas, Khalil al-Hayya.

It’s just one part of a tour of the Middle East for President Donald Trump’s son-in-law and roving negotiator, who meets Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu today in an attempt to breathe life into stalled Gaza peace talks.

As if that were not tricky enough, the 60-day window for negotiations between the U.S. and Iran agreed in June’s memorandum of understanding also expires today. Washington and Tehran are now further apart than when the deal was signed, with no compromise over Iran’s nuclear program, the reopening of the Strait of Hormuz or Tehran’s claim to control it.

Read More on Analysis

These stalemates belie Kushner’s reputation as an unusually effective negotiator. During both Trump terms, the president’s right-hand dealmaker helped broker a string of high-profile agreements and was recognized each time as the man who made the difference. But the promise of Trump’s foreign policy-by-proxy approach has its limits.

His handpicked team of special envoys, including Kushner, cannot be everywhere, all at once. Without the support of ambassadors and diplomats, the concentration of power in their hands quickly becomes a liability.

The Kushner Key Opens Many Doors

Critics often dismiss Kushner’s role as a cut-and-dried case of nepotism: a family member handed a global brief by a president who runs politics like a family business. Those criticisms fail to acknowledge that the man gets results.

Ivanka Trump, the daughter of the US president, and her husband Jared Kushner pose during a summit on Gaza in Sharm el-Sheikh on October 13, 2025. US president Donald Trump landed in Egypt on October 13 for a summit on Gaza, following a lightning visit to Israel after a ceasefire he brokered entered into force.

...

Kushner’s first major diplomatic success came not in the Middle East, but in North America, when he helped negotiate the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA)—a trilateral trade deal that replaced the North American Free Trade Agreement, from which Trump had threatened to withdraw. Outgoing Mexican President Enrique Peña Nieto awarded Kushner Mexico’s highest honor for a foreign citizen for his role in the negotiations, much to the chagrin of Trump’s opponents.

Then, just two months after the USMCA took hold in July 2020, Kushner was instrumental in securing what Trump routinely trumpets as one of his administration’s greatest achievements: the Abraham Accords. UAE Foreign Minister Abdullah bin Zayed said at the White House signing ceremony that the initiative "would not have been possible" without Trump’s team, specifically naming Kushner as a key player in getting the deal over the line.

When Trump left office following Joe Biden’s successful presidential bid, his son-in-law left behind politics, leveraging his newfound connections in the Gulf to launch the Saudi-backed private equity firm Affinity Partners. But Kushner was drafted back into the fold during Trump’s second term, as negotiations over the war in Gaza reached a critical stage in 2025.

"We called in Jared," Trump later told Israel’s Parliament. "We need that brain on occasion. We gotta get Jared in here." Alongside special envoy Steve Witkoff, Kushner helped clinch the initial ceasefire and hostage agreement through negotiations with Hamas and regional mediators. Barack Obama’s former ambassador to Israel, Daniel Shapiro, said at the time that Kushner’s experience and relationships were key in helping "to produce a result fairly quickly."

This is Trump’s preferred style of international diplomacy. Kushner and co. can slice through diplomatic red tape and expedite deal making by making the institutional feel personal. They operate as extensions of the president himself; speaking with his authority, without the same notoriety.

Russia's President Vladimir Putin welcomes U.S. special envoy Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, the Kremlin, Moscow, January 22, 2026.

...

An MVP Still Needs a Team

Trump is hardly the first world leader who uses preferred representatives to achieve what ambassadors and career diplomats cannot.

A study of nearly 650 special-envoy appointments by world governments over 25 years, published in The Hague Journal of Diplomacy in 2018, found that their principal advantage lies in flexibility amid complex negotiations. Their direct relationship with the leader who appoints them produces immediate political clout, and their mandates can be tailored to a specific crisis and adjusted as negotiations shift.

However, the same study cautions that special envoys can only consistently deliver results when they operate with the "full-fledged operational support" of a robust, diplomatic machine behind them. Under Trump, that machinery is falling apart.

As of August 10, almost half of American ambassadorial and senior diplomatic positions in foreign countries sit vacant, according to AFSA—the U.S. Foreign Service’s labor union. The association also reported in May that more than 200 foreign service officials, including several officers with skill sets directly applicable to Iran, were removed from their posts amid sweeping cuts by the State Department.

Russia, Ukraine and Iran—three nations at the center of the world’s major conflicts with no peace deals in sight—are currently without a dedicated American ambassador.

Across the Indo-Pacific, 17 of the 35 nations represented in AFSA’s ambassador tracker currently lack a serving U.S. ambassador, despite the Trump administration’s own National Security Strategy stipulating that Washington must keep the region "free and open" and focus attention on competition with China.

Related Story

Don’t Fear The Reaper

Don’t Fear The Reaper

Just as ambassadors and career diplomats lack the flexibility or deal making power of a Kushner, they hold powers no special envoy could wield. They preserve institutional memory, interpret local politics, coordinate the work of multiple U.S. agencies and maintain the government-to-government relationships upon which showcase agreements are built.

Most importantly, though, they actually implement the deals struck by the special envoys. A negotiator like Kushner might secure the handshake and the signature; the diplomats and civil servants make sure the plans become policy long after the star operative has moved on.

Best of Both Worlds?

History shows that trusted envoys operating at the pleasure of the president can find resolutions for complex and bitter disputes. George Mitchell, former President Bill Clinton’s handpicked envoy to Northern Ireland, spent years shuttling between hostile parties before helping broker the 1998 Good Friday Agreement. Richard Holbrooke, empowered by Clinton to end the war in Bosnia, drove the negotiations that produced the 1995 Dayton Accords.

But neither worked alone. Irish Prime Minister Bertie Ahern later said Mitchell benefited from the backing of the U.S. Embassy in London, while Holbrooke operated alongside Secretary of State Warren Christopher, NATO pressure and a wider American negotiating team.

Perhaps Kushner’s biggest diplomatic successes can also be explained by a simpler truth: there was already something to bargain over, and all the parties involved had good reason to reach an agreement. The U.S., Mexico and Canada all wanted to preserve continental trade. Normalizing ties helped Israel and the Gulf states to further commercial interests and safeguard regional security. In these instances, Kushner’s access helped turn shared incentives into deals.

Gaza, Iran and Ukraine are different. In each instance, the parties remain fundamentally opposed on what an acceptable end state looks like; and leaders themselves have strong incentives to keep the war going. That is where the slower work of diplomacy becomes essential: maintaining channels, testing compromises, coordinating allies and monitoring whether agreements survive contact with reality.

It is against this backdrop that AFSA revealed these statistics in a survey of more than 2,100 members of the U.S. Foreign Service last year: 86 percent said the changes made to the State Department since January 2025 had harmed their ability to advance U.S. diplomatic priorities, while 98 percent reported poor morale. Those are union figures, but they paint a vivid picture of what happens when an administration concentrates power in a few exceptional individuals while the institution beneath them weakens.

Kushner can get adversaries into a room and, on a good day, drag an agreement across the line. America still needs diplomats to make sure the line holds after he leaves.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines