
...

By Tom O'Connor
Deputy Editor, National Security and Foreign Policy
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
As tensions surrounding President Donald Trump's threats toward socialist-led Venezuela draw divisive reactions across the Western Hemisphere, a new ally may soon emerge for the U.S. leader in the form a far-right presidential candidate leading the polls against a communist contender in Chile.
Chile's election, while focused first and foremost on domestic issues, speaks in many ways to a contentious ideological battle taking place across South America, a continent known for its dramatic swings across the political spectrum. And at a time where a "conservative wave" is overcoming the "pink tide" that resulted in leftist takeovers decades ago, the consequences of the vote may also be felt far beyond Chile's borders.
The stage is thus set in many ways for José Antonio Kast, a former lawyer and son of a World War II-era German Nazi Party member who fled to Chile. Kast, head of the Republican Party of Chile, placed a close second in the first round of the presidential election held last month, but as the next round approaches on December 14, he's poised to overtake former front-runner Jeannette Jara, who leads the Communist Party of Chile and is also a lawyer.
Read More on News
In his platform of being tough on crime and immigration that takes advantage of the plummeting popularity of incumbent left-wing President Gabriel Boric, Kast has openly portrayed himself as an ideological ally of Trump. Should he win as projected, the White House is set to gain substantially in the throes of Trump's hard-line policy in the Western Hemisphere.
Francisco Mora, former U.S. ambassador to the Organization of American States (OAS) who is now senior research scientist at Florida International University's Jack D. Gordon Institute of Public Policy, told Newsweek that Kast is "no question, someone who will be working much better with Trump than perhaps the current administration on a number of issues, particularly foreign policy issues."
Describing a "mind meld" between the two leaders as well as "greater support for U.S. priorities, perhaps at different multilateral organizations like Chile, the United Nations and maybe the OAS as well" on Kast's part, Mora said Trump will "certainly will have a friend, and I think the Trump administration will try to leverage that."
The New Wave
Trump's stunning reelection may have reinvigorated the U.S. right, but his triumph also comes as part of a hemispheric backlash against incumbent leadership since the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020.
"COVID exposed the deficiencies that the region had," Mora said, "and it was able to kind of temper it and sort of muddle through, because there was some economic growth, but COVID exposed what people call, sort of the preexisting conditions of Latin America, its health care system, its educational system, and a number of public services, to include security that these governments at the time, mostly left of center governments, were not able to address."
"And in fact, things got in some places desperately worse, and so you would expect that at the next electoral cycle, which is where we are now and have been, that they would vote for the other right, anti-incumbent vote, or anti-ideological left, and that's what we're seeing today," he added. "They still haven't quite recovered from COVID. They're still living with the consequences of that. So, this is the political consequence."
Jorge Heine, a former Chilean ambassador and cabinet minister who today is research professor at Boston University's Frederick S. Pardee School of Global Studies, also spoke to the lingering impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the political landscape of Latin America.
"Ever since the pandemic, which especially affected Latin America, as the region—with 8 percent of the world’s population, had 28 percent of the world’s deaths from it—which led to high government spending and the ensuing inflation, in the majority of democracies around the world incumbent governments have tended to lose elections to the opposition," Heine told Newsweek. "Latin America is part of this pattern, and over the past few years we have seen this in Brazil, Colombia, Argentina, Chile, Uruguay, Panama and Bolivia, among other countries."
The trend does not solely favor right-wing incumbents. Brazil brought to power democratic socialist President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva in 2023, who previously served from 2003-2011, while Colombia elected its first-ever left-wing leader, President Gustavo Petro, in 2022.
But now Lula, Petro and, at least for the next week, Boric, find themselves at odds with the emboldened administration in the White House, whose own late-term grapple with COVID served as an obstacle to reelection only to stage a massive comeback in last year's vote.
And Trump's unique populist flavor has proven influential across Latin America, including Chile. Heine asserted that "there is no doubt that Mr. Trump’s discourse has affected Chile’s right-wing candidates, who mimic much of his phraseology, contempt for immigrants, hard line on crime and on cutting government spending," all of which, "is especially true for Mr. José Antonio Kast, the front-runner and odds-on favorite candidate to win the 14 December second-round elections."

...
The MAGA Monroe Doctrine
The Trump administration's turn to the Western Hemisphere has emerged as one of the most notable shifts in U.S. geopolitics in recent years. While the White House has continued to focus on peacemaking initiatives in various regions, including Africa, Asia and Europe, the U.S. leader has made clear that he tied developments across Latin America to domestic U.S. policy.
The assertion of a U.S.-led sphere of influence recalls past eras, particularly the two-century-old Monroe Doctrine declared by then President James Monroe in 1823 to expel the influence of European great powers from the Americas. This strategy was appropriated during the Cold War to specifically target perceived footholds of Soviet influence as communist movements began to rise throughout the region, resulting in a concerted and often covert effort to stamp out leftist sentiments.
Today, the Trump administration's focus on Latin America, rooted in the "Make America Great Again" movement, does have some ties to concerns of foreign influence, including an effort to combat growing Chinese investments taking hold throughout the region. But the White House has outlined two primary issues that dictate the course of U.S. foreign policy toward the hemisphere and that, according to Mora, is "migration and the issue of transnational crime."
In the words of the White House's own new National Security Strategy, "we want to ensure that the Western Hemisphere remains reasonably stable and well-governed enough to prevent and discourage mass migration to the United States; we want a Hemisphere whose governments cooperate with us against narco-terrorists, cartels, and other transnational criminal organizations; we want a Hemisphere that remains free of hostile foreign incursion or ownership of key assets, and that supports critical supply chains; and we want to ensure our continued access to key strategic locations."
"In other words," the document added, "we will assert and enforce a 'Trump Corollary' to the Monroe Doctrine."
While Trump has issued warnings to several regional leaders in line with this policy, the front-line target today is Venezuela. Last year marked the second time that President Nicolás Maduro's reelection has been challenged by the U.S. and a number of regional and European nations, who collectively view his 12-year rule since taking the mantle from the late Hugo Chávez as illegitimate.
Maduro, who succeeded the late Chávez as head of the so-called "Bolivarian Revolution" upon his death in 2013, was accused by the first Trump administration of election rigging and drug cartel complicity in 2019 and his ousting has been declared a goal of the current White House.
With Trump now backing his stated dedication to combating drug trafficking in the region with unprecedented airstrikes against suspected narco boats in the Caribbean, his open calls for the closure of Venezuelan airspace and amassing of U.S. naval power off the northern coast of South America have raised alarms of potentially imminent military action. Meanwhile, a flood of reports in recent weeks has indicated that the White House has already prepared active measures to unseat Maduro.
The Venezuelan leader may already have few active allies in Latin America beyond immediate partners Cuba and Nicaragua, though a number of leftist-led governments such as those in Brazil, Colombia and Mexico have voiced opposition to any U.S. military action. But Kast's election could prove particularly pivotal to enforcing Trump's vision of how the region could align with his views.
"A victory for José Antonio Kast would usher in a new right-wing force in the region, emphasizing the principles of security, immigration control, economic growth, and individual freedom," Felipe Bulnes, former Chilean minister of justice now a partner at the Bulnes and Urrutia law firm, told Newsweek.
Bulnes pointed out how current right-wing governments have already provided a model for the Trump administration, noting how Argentine President Javier Milei's policies "have shown that a right-wing government can achieve significant reforms while preserving social stability, which is being closely monitored in Chile."
These developments also reinforce the administration's skepticism of leftist leaders in the region, including Boric, who has publicly attacked Trump.
"There is no doubt that relations between Chile and the United States are not at their best, largely due to the significant ideological differences between Presidents Trump and Boric," Bulnes said. "President Boric has openly criticized President Trump, surprising many in Chile, as such open disagreement with an important strategic partner is not typical in Chile’s approach to international relations."
"Given these dynamics," he added, "it is likely that the level of agreement between José Antonio Kast and President Trump will be much higher, as they share similar views on several regional issues, including the situation in Venezuela."

...
The Return of the Right
While undoubtedly Trump's presence looms large over the election in Chile, the contest is rooted primarily in domestic concerns.
Trump has yet to weigh in specifically on the contest and the U.S. State Department declined to opine on the election, instead emphasizing its support for a free and fair election.
"The United States supports the right of the Chilean people to freely and democratically elect the leadership of their country," a State Department spokesperson told Newsweek.
Bettina Horst von Thadden, former counselor at Chile's Senior Public Management System now serving as executive director of the conservative Freedom and Development think tank, told Newsweek that "undoubtedly, the international context also permeates local debates across countries in the region."
"But elections in Chile have ultimately been decided based on the specific problems we face, which in this case are similar to some of the challenges the U.S. is also confronting: economic stagnation, the growing presence of organized crime, and illegal immigration," she said. "These are the main axes of Chile’s political debate and the primary concerns of its citizens."
In terms of where Kast and Trump may align, she said that the Trump administration "has more points of convergence with Kast than with our current President Boric, which would likely lead to a more fluid relationship between the two countries."
Kenneth Bunker, associate professor of political science at San Sebastián University in Chile's capital of Santiago, explained how "this Chilean election is mostly about Chile," particularly looking at the 2019 uprising known as the Social Outburst that rocked the nation, fueled by protests and riots over growing inequality, rising cost of living and a hike in public transit fares.
"Chile, despite being more successful in development than many neighbors, hit a major bump with the 2019 social outburst," Bunker told Newsweek. "That moment created long-running political uncertainty and a demand for stability."
Taking advantage of the popular frustration, Kast's law and order push is gaining ground among Chileans who have viewed the current government's efforts to address these top-line issues some six years later as inadequate.
"The central issue in this election is restoring order," Bunker said. "Kast is perceived as the candidate who can deliver that. The current left government, Boric and Jara, is seen by critics as unable or unwilling to manage security and immigration effectively."
And while he viewed the phenomenon as part of a "regional mood of backlash against an 'irresponsible left,' seen in places like Argentina, where the left is accused of mismanagement and cronyism," he saw Kast's ascension as uniquely rooted in grassroots issues on track to propel him to power.
Yet Bunker said Trump stands to benefit from having a new partner in Chile, given Kast's admiration for the U.S. administration, even if that position may be limited in the broader regional scope.
"He would likely support U.S. positions regardless of what Trump decides," Bunker said. "Still, he would be unlikely to play an active regional role beyond diplomacy. His concrete priority is domestic: to repatriate irregular Venezuelan migrants and tighten border controls."
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines