
...

By Didi Kirsten Tatlow
Senior Correspondent, International Affairs
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
At first glance, Greenland and Iran have little in common—one icy, the other with scorching deserts.
Yet the U.S.-Israeli war on Iran may, unexpectedly, have strengthened President Donald Trump’s arguments that the United States needs to own Greenland—arguments he made most forcefully in January, horrifying European allies in NATO and the public, most of all in Denmark, which owns the territory.
So when some of those allies declined to support the U.S. in its war that began more than two months ago, Trump’s stated goal of better protecting the nation in a fast-changing geopolitical and technological era may just have made owning Greenland even more pressing, especially with the island on a potentially unpredictable path to independence, experts have told Newsweek.
Read More on World
Others, however, say that with the congressional midterm elections in November approaching fast, Trump’s hands are tied on any further moves on the Arctic territory. As much as he wants to own it, aggressive action could cost him votes, even among his core MAGA supporters who increasingly are unhappy about his growing foreign interventions.

...
The White House has highlighted the connection it sees between Greenland and Iran, reposting the president’s remarks in April on its X account as the U.S. and Iran prepared for talks in Islamabad on ending the conflict: “NATO WASN’T THERE WHEN WE NEEDED THEM, AND THEY WON’T BE THERE IF WE NEED THEM AGAIN. REMEMBER GREENLAND, THAT BIG, POORLY RUN, PIECE OF ICE!!!” Other messages by the president on his Truth Social account also linked Iran, Greenland and NATO.
The path between Greenland and Iran may be winding, but for the current U.S. administration they are part of something directly relevant: the future of transatlantic cooperation and of NATO, the post-World War II defensive alliance that kept the peace during the Cold War and which turned 77 years old in April.
Speaking on background, a White House official told Newsweek: “As President Trump has said, NATO was tested, and they failed. President Trump has made his disappointment with NATO clear, and as the president has emphasized, ‘the United States will remember.’”
Perception of Security Threats
At the heart of Trump’s arguments for owning Greenland is a gulf between American and European perceptions of security threats, said Michael Lucci, the founder of State Armor, a political organization that works for national security resilience at the state level in the U.S. Lucci pointed to how some NATO allies, including Britain, France and Spain, were unwilling to fully or partially support the U.S. in its war on Iran, refusing basing or overflight to the Air Force or to send warships to patrol or open the Iran-controlled Gulf of Hormuz.

...
“The gap between American and European perceptions of security threats is quickly becoming unsustainable,” Lucci told Newsweek.
“In January, European capitals took great offense when President Trump argued for U.S. ownership of Greenland. By March, America’s military was being denied the use of bases and airspace…because some NATO allies do not view Iran as a threat, and therefore took the position that undermining American lethality against the Iranian regime was the right thing to do,” Lucci said.
“This underlines why President Trump argued for American ownership of Greenland,” he continued. “Greenland has dramatic security implications for North America…and the gap between American and European perceptions of external threats continues to grow.”
Others took note, too. “NATO insists US doesn’t need to own Greenland; having bases there is good enough for natl security,” KT McFarland, a former senior national security adviser who has served four U.S. presidents, wrote on X.
“But NATO countries just refused us access to OUR bases to refuel, they won’t even let our planes overfly their airspace. They just proved the point why we DO need to own Greenland,” McFarland wrote.
But it was an exaggeration.
Germany continued to provide the U.S. with its Ramstein military base, and Romania in Europe’s southeast approved an American request to deploy capabilities including for aircraft refueling and satellite communications, “effectively expanding the geographic reach of allied air power,” wrote Alex Serban and Kirsten Fontenrose of the Atlantic Council, a Washington, D.C.-based think tank.
For sure, it’s complicated. Others don’t see a connection—just chaos, albeit underlined by an “America First” policy. “The thread is naked self-interest and absolutism around America First. And anything else is transactional,” said Andy Pryce, a former British diplomat who specializes in countering information threats and cognitive defense. He is also a senior nonresident fellow at the Center for European Policy Analysis, headquartered in Washington, D.C., with branches in London and Brussels.

...
China's Underlying Role
Yet Pryce said that something even bigger underlined the logic of this complex geopolitical moment: China. Because China largely controls the global production and refining of rare earths, and has used this to pressure the U.S. for concessions as it seeks to displace America’s global standing.
“So, [owning] Greenland is [about] rare earth metals, and potentially the sort of more peripheral arguments on defense, but they’re sort of taken care of anyway, in terms of the current treaty and the current capability they have in Greenland,” said Pryce, referring to a 1951 defense agreement between the U.S. and Denmark which allows Washington to maintain military installations in Greenland. “And I suppose underneath the immediate tactics on rare earths is, I think, long-term economic warfare with China.”
Overall, the U.S. had a strong strain of isolationism that had been reflected in Trump’s reelection, Pryce said. “The starting point is that 77 million people voted for Trump and a decent proportion of those people knew what he is and what his agenda is globally, or lack of agenda globally. At the moment [he] has few guardrails, few checks and balances,” Pryce said.
“We might want to kid ourselves...that somebody else becoming president and saying nice things about NATO changes the real-life deterrence, [but] I don’t think it does. I don’t see the political will to work with Europe to defend Europe. You’re not hearing many Democrats jumping up and down shouting about this,” Pryce said. “So, I think any government in Europe would be crazy to think within the next 20 years that you’re going to have any degree of stability of the Atlantic…European governments really need to think long and hard about every aspect of their national security.”

...
Three-way talks between the U.S., Denmark and Greenland on the island’s future began in January and are ongoing, though Denmark’s Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen, who recently submitted her government’s resignation, and her Greenland counterpart Jens-Frederik Nielsen have opposed Trump’s bid to own it.
“The administration is participating in diplomatic high-level technical talks with the governments of Greenland and Denmark to address United States’ national security interests in Greenland,” the White House official told Newsweek.
“We are not going to participate in a back and forth through the media, but we are very optimistic that we’re on a good trajectory,” the official said.
Right About Russia
For years, the U.S. called on Europe to spend more on its own defense. Budgets fell instead. For years, too, Europe failed to see that Russia threatened its security, deeply frustrating the U.S. and weakening the transatlantic bond, said Lucci.
“American leaders have become exasperated with Europe’s leaders because our European allies have consistently taken a much narrower view of security threats at the expense of European security,” he said.
“The American view of Russia as a persistent threat to Europe was proven correct, but America’s leaders were unable to convince Europe’s leaders to stop buying Russian gas, strengthen their economies and build up their militaries until three years into Russia’s second invasion of Ukraine,” in 2022, he said. Russia is also waging hybrid war across Europe, with governments scrambling to respond.
“Today, the U.S. argues that China, Russia and Iran are threats to both American and European security. European leaders do not seem to recognize [the] need for serious action to counter Iran and China, despite both of those regimes quite openly supporting Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and despite the broader threats of Iranian-sponsored terrorism and CCP [Chinese Communist Party] economic and hybrid warfare upon Europe and the U.S.,” Lucci said.

...
Midterms as a Break?
Still, the midterm elections are likely to dampen any further effort to push for outright control of Greenland, at least kinetically. “The Greenland debate won’t flame up again because before the midterms it would provide food for those who oppose it, and that’s both the breakaway MAGAs and the Democrats,” said Nathalie Vogel, a research fellow with the Center for Intermarium Studies at the Institute of World Politics in Washington, D.C.
“They’re saying, ‘He wants to involve us in another foreign adventure, but we have enough problems at home’. It would cost him the election and I don’t think it will happen,” Vogel said.
She pointed out that polls showed that most Americans oppose the U.S. seizing Greenland, and bipartisan legislation has been introduced in Congress to prohibit the use of federal funds to annex or seize the territory without consent.
With the Iran war, “the mood has gotten even worse within MAGA about foreign intervention,” Vogel said.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines