10
Loading video...

By Steve Mollman
News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Chinese President Xi Jinping occupied center stage. President Donald Trump projected warmth in his greetings but appeared less commanding during formal talks. Russian President Vladimir Putin smiled broadly, even as his movements suggested possible unease.
Those contrasting signals emerged from body language experts' assessments of Thursday's historic trilateral meeting in Shenzhen, China, held on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit.
British psychologist Peter Collett, body language expert Patti Wood and behavioral scientist Dr. Abbie Maroño, speaking separately to Newsweek on Thursday, identified differences in how the three presidents presented themselves.
Read More on News
Collett said the summit's choreography reinforced Xi's position as the central figure, while Trump's unusually tactile behavior appeared designed to project familiarity and friendship.
Wood offered a more critical assessment of the American president, pointing to his slumped posture, wandering gaze and subdued vocal delivery during the formal meeting.
Maroño, meanwhile, identified a shifting balance of physical assertiveness between Trump and Putin, with the Russian president initially taking the initiative before Trump began setting the pace.
Their observations provide another perspective on a summit that produced a joint declaration on nuclear security, United Nations reform and energy supplies, but no agreement to end Russia's war in Ukraine.
Xi Jinping's Body Language: Who Controlled the Summit?
For Collett, a former Oxford University academic and author of The Book of Tells, the clearest demonstration of power was not a handshake or facial expression. It was the arrangement of the meeting itself.
Xi occupied the central position during key moments of the gathering, with Trump and Putin positioned on either side. The Chinese president also hosted the leaders at Kylin Villa, where their closed-door talks lasted approximately 90 minutes.
Collett described the staging as a demonstration of status, with Xi occupying center stage while the other leaders were relegated to the wings.
He pointed to a principle of nonverbal communication: In encounters involving unequal status, the person of lower status often makes more of the physical effort to approach the other.
Collett said the arrangement, with Trump and Putin approaching Xi, reinforced the Chinese president's position as host and central figure.
Wood, author of SNAP: Making the Most of First Impressions, Body Language, and Charisma, identified another contrast during the roundtable discussion.
While Xi sat upright with his shoulders back, Trump's shoulders were stooped and his posture angled forward and downward, she said. Putin leaned forward to consult his notes but otherwise maintained a more erect posture.
"Trump's posture during the actual roundtable meeting, with his stooped shoulders and forward, downward posture, made him look shorter and, overall, smaller in stature than the other two leaders," Wood told Newsweek.
She said Trump occasionally turned his body and gaze away from the other leaders toward the cameras, further weakening his appearance of engagement.

...
Donald Trump's Body Language: Slumped Posture and Subdued Delivery
Wood's assessment of Trump extended beyond his posture.
She said the president appeared unusually low on energy throughout the formal meeting, including when delivering his own remarks.
His voice also lacked the emphasis she would normally expect when discussing significant diplomatic achievements, Wood said.
Wood pointed to Trump's remarks about the success of his previous meeting with Xi. Although his words conveyed enthusiasm, his voice dropped and faded as he spoke, she said.
She said the mismatch between his language and delivery suggested that he was not projecting the confidence his words were intended to convey.
The behavior stood out because Wood had previously observed Trump appearing disengaged during meetings before becoming more animated when it was his turn to speak.
This time, she said, that change did not occur.
"Trump looked done in and had to use every spare bit of energy just to get through the meeting, rather than being fully present, powerful, and engaged," Wood told Newsweek.
Scott Rouse, a body language analyst and author of Understanding Body Language, told NewsNation on Wednesday that Trump appeared unusually relaxed during his earlier interactions with the leaders.
Rouse said Trump displayed fewer of the facial expressions he associates with stress and seemed more connected to those around him.
Trump and Xi Jinping's Hug: A Diplomatic Power Play?
Trump's behavior during his greetings was notably different from his demeanor at the negotiating table, according to the experts.
Collett observed that Trump largely avoided his familiar aggressive handshake, in which he grips another person's hand and pulls them toward him.
Instead, the president appeared more polite and conciliatory, although Collett said Trump continued to position his hand in ways that could allow him to control the interaction.
Collett also drew attention to Trump's repeated touching and patting of the other leaders.
Such gestures can serve as reminders of status, he explained, but he interpreted Trump's behavior in Shenzhen primarily as an attempt to project familiarity, affinity and friendship.
Wood saw a more confrontational dynamic in Trump's greeting with Xi at Shenzhen Baoan International Airport on Wednesday.
She said Trump extended his hand before using his left arm to grab Xi's upper arm and pull him closer, turning the handshake into an embrace.
Wood interpreted the maneuver as an attempt to overpower Xi physically.
According to Wood, the Chinese president gave a restrained smile before patting down on Trump's hand, a gesture she interpreted as an attempt to stop and rebuke the American president.
"This is a power battle," Wood told Newsweek.
Maroño offered a more measured interpretation of the embrace.
"When Xi greeted Trump at the airport, Trump kept their hands clasped, reached around Xi with his free arm and gave him a pat," she told Newsweek.
"The half-embrace came across as warm and friendly, with a subtle element of dominance."
Maroño said Trump had taken the liberty of introducing a more personal gesture into a formal diplomatic greeting, with the pat giving his assertiveness a friendly quality.
Rouse also identified the embrace as unusual.
He said Trump appeared to pull Xi slightly off balance, catching him by surprise.
Rouse interpreted Trump's repeated movement into and out of Xi's personal space as a form of physical dominance.
Collett offered a different emphasis, viewing Trump's gestures as an effort to create an impression of personal closeness.
Trump and Putin's Handshakes: Who Was in Control?
Maroño, who specializes in trust, influence and nonverbal communication, identified a more subtle contest for control during Trump's interactions with Putin. At the APEC photo call, Trump tapped Putin's arm twice in a gesture she likened to a casual greeting between teammates.
Their separate meeting before the trilateral talks also began warmly.
Trump smiled, called Putin "my friend" and extended his hand early. Putin then took hold of Trump's elbow and maintained his grip as they shook hands.
Maroño said the sustained contact made Putin's gesture more assertive than Trump's brief taps.
"Brief taps can signal familiarity, while holding the elbow gives the person who initiates the contact more influence over how the greeting unfolds," she told Newsweek.
The leaders kept their hands clasped even as Trump leaned closer to speak privately, extending the handshake into a more personal exchange.
Maroño also identified moments when the two appeared unusually coordinated.
As Trump said he was looking forward to their meeting, they stood in nearly identical postures. Putin then nodded in response to Trump's nod.
"Mirroring posture and movements is a form of nonverbal mimicry and can signal rapport," Maroño said.
But that coordination briefly broke down when Trump gestured toward Putin's chair.
Putin began to sit, only for Trump to remain standing and continue speaking. The Russian president straightened up and buttoned his jacket.
Maroño interpreted the adjustment as possible "social preening," giving Putin a purposeful way to recover from a moment when the two leaders were out of sync.
By their second handshake, however, Trump appeared to be setting the pace.
He extended his arm only partway, prompting Putin to lean farther forward to meet him. Trump then patted Putin's upper arm, echoing the additional contact Putin had initiated earlier.
A similar pattern emerged as the leaders prepared to sit.
Putin looked at his chair, glanced back at Trump and nodded as the American president began to sit.
"Putin had taken the initiative with the elbow grip," Maroño said. "By the end of the exchange, it was Trump initiating the movements and Putin adjusting to him."
Vladimir Putin's Grin: Confidence or Unease?
Putin's frequent smiles were among the most noticeable features of the summit.
But Collett cautioned against interpreting the Russian president's apparent pleasure as evidence that he was entirely comfortable.
He said Putin appeared pleased to be sharing the stage with the leaders of the United States and China, particularly after years of diplomatic isolation following Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022.
At the same time, Collett identified unusual movements around Putin's mouth that he interpreted as possible signs of uneasiness.
The contrast was significant, Collett suggested, because Putin's presence alongside Trump and Xi carried considerable symbolic value even without a major diplomatic breakthrough.
The contrast was significant, Collett suggested, because Putin's presence alongside Trump and Xi carried considerable symbolic value even without a major diplomatic breakthrough.
Collett also observed what he interpreted as unusually deferential behavior by Putin during some greetings, suggesting an acknowledgment of Xi's status.
Rouse independently noticed a change in Putin's demeanor.
He described the Russian president as moving around more than usual, gesturing with his hands and appearing unusually animated.
"He's got a lot of energy during this," Rouse told NewsNation.
Rouse said the behavior could reflect excitement or heightened attention to the significance of the negotiations, although he did not draw a firm conclusion about Putin's motives.
Xi Jinping's Body Language: Restraint and Control
While Trump was physically expressive during his greetings and Putin unusually animated, Xi remained comparatively restrained.
Rouse told NewsNation that the Chinese president appeared relaxed but difficult to read, with little visible evidence of anger or contempt.
He cautioned that cultural differences can influence the interpretation of facial expressions and other nonverbal behavior.
Wood also emphasized the cultural context of Trump's embrace, arguing that the gesture departed from the restraint generally expected in formal Chinese diplomatic encounters.
Collett, meanwhile, highlighted Xi's limited use of physical contact.
He suggested that Xi did not need to rely on touching other leaders to reinforce his position because the diplomatic setting already emphasized his status.
Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here. Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Henry Holloway and Edward T. Cummins.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines