Twitter Denies Working With Governments After Accusations of Censoring Complaints on China

Twitter has denied working with governments after the platform was accused of censoring complaints on China.

Anne-Marie Brady, a professor at the University of Canterbury in New Zealand, said Twitter temporarily put restrictions on her account over the weekend after she posted tweets mocking China's celebration of its Communist Party's 100 year anniversary last week.

Brady's account was restored Monday and she tweeted, "Seems like @Twitter may have briefly forgotten they don't work for Xi Jinping."

"To set the record straight, the assertion that Twitter is in coordination with any government to suppress speech has no basis in fact whatsoever," Twitter said in reaction to accusations of working with China. "We advocate for a free, global and open internet and remain a staunch defender of freedom of expression."

Brady is an expert on China and known to be critical of its government, according to the Associated Press.

"Some of the biggest names in social media, from @Twitter to @LinkedIn @Zoom & @Facebook, appear to be getting into a habit of silencing CCP critics. Yesterday it was my turn to be censored," Brady tweeted.

For more reporting from the Associated Press, see below.

Twitter Logo
Twitter denied working with governments after accusations of censoring critiques on China. This photograph was taken on October 26, 2020 and shows the logo of US social network Twitter displayed on the screen of a smartphone and a tablet in Toulouse, southern France. Lionel Bonaventure/AFP via Getty Images

Brady said two of those tweets were temporarily marked "unavailable" by Twitter and her account was temporarily restricted over the weekend, before it was restored on Monday.

Twitter did not say what prompted its actions.

Edward Lucas, a columnist for The Times newspaper in Britain, wrote that it probably resulted from an online campaign of complaints by Communist Party agents which would have triggered an automatic response from Twitter while it investigated.

"After I had stoked a furor on Twitter and sent umpteen complaints, her account was restored," Lucas wrote. "Less prominent victims of Chinese censorship would have scantier chances of redress."

Brady tweeted her thanks to Lucas, saying that she'd been unable to get a reply from Twitter herself.

In a statement, Twitter said that when it detects unusual activity from an account, it can sometimes add temporary notices until it gets confirmation from the account owner.

Brady's tweets made fun of the lack of international validation of the centenary. Russian President Vladimir Putin was among the few leaders who sent congratulations to China.

In one tweet, Brady suggested an alternative headline for a news article about the celebrations: "Xi: its my Party and I'll cry if I want to," she wrote.

Brady said her account has been restored. "Opening my work laptop this morning I was greeted by a "Welcome back" message on my screen from @Twitter, as if I was the one who left them," she wrote.

In 2017, Brady wrote a groundbreaking paper "Magic Weapons" which detailed what she said were the Communist Party's efforts to exert political influence in New Zealand. Subsequent burglaries and break-ins at her home and office remain unsolved.

The Chinese Embassy in Wellington did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The Chinese government has not commented on any action online against Brady and has heatedly denied accusations that it interferes with foreign media and political systems.

However, under Xi, who is also leader of the Chinese Communist Party, the government has taken an increasingly combative approach toward its critics, whether individuals, organizations or foreign governments.

University of Canterbury Professor Anne-Marie Brady
University of Canterbury Professor Anne-Marie Brady poses for a picture taken on Monday, May 21, 2018, in Wellington, New Zealand. Nick Perry/AP Photo