10

Loading video...

Matthew Impelli

By Matthew Impelli

Life & Trends Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Frustration is growing over stalled efforts by a United Nations summit to respond to several different environmental issues.

What's New

In recent months, United Nations-led negotiations on climate change, plastic pollution, biodiversity loss and desert expansion have largely stalled or delivered underwhelming results, failing to match the urgency of the crises at hand. It's been three years since climate activist Greta Thunberg criticized such efforts as "blah-blah-blah," a phrase that has since become a rallying cry for young environmentalists demanding tangible action.

Read More on World

The Associated Press (AP) spoke with over 20 experts who described multilateral environmentalism as broken, citing a slow-moving consensus process, the influence of the fossil fuel industry, shifting global geopolitics, and the sheer scale of the environmental crises as key obstacles to progress.

Why It Matters

The current state of global environmental negotiations is a stark contrast to the optimism of 1987, when a landmark treaty successfully curbed the depletion of the ozone layer by banning harmful chemicals.

That momentum carried into the 1992 Earth Summit, which established the United Nations framework for addressing environmental challenges, most notably through the Conference of Parties, or COPs.

UN Summit

...

What To Know

A string of recent environmental conferences has ended in disappointment. October's biodiversity COP in Cali, Colombia, ran out of time, producing no major agreements beyond acknowledging the role of Indigenous communities.

The November climate change COP in Baku, Azerbaijan, met its target of boosting financial aid for poor nations to tackle global warming, but the limited funding left developing countries frustrated and analysts unimpressed.

At a plastics pollution summit in Busan, South Korea, nations expressed willingness to act but failed to deliver concrete solutions.

Meanwhile, the desertification conference in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, fell short of reaching an agreement on addressing drought.

Nine years after more than 190 nations united to adopt the landmark Paris Agreement, the collective mindset that recognized the universal benefits of a healthy planet has fractured, according to Christiana Figueres, the former U.N. climate chief who helped broker the deal.

"We've lost track of that," Figueres said. "We're now entering as though we were gladiators in the Colosseum with an attitude of fighting and confrontation. And that mindset is not very productive."

What People Are Saying

Panama's lead negotiator, Juan Carlos Monterrey, who participated in all four meetings, described the entire system to The Associated Press as "fundamentally broken."

"It feels like we have lost our way, not only as countries and governments, but as humanity. It feels like we no longer care for each other," Monterrey said during a meeting in Riyadh.

According to Michael Oppenheimer, a climate scientist and international affairs professor at Princeton University, a key issue is that the geopolitical landscape has shifted since the 1980s.

Back then, two superpowers shared "enough common interest among themselves to knock heads together and to make something happen," Oppenheimer said.

"If you are not feeling some kind of grief about what's going on, you're obviously not understanding what's going on," climate negotiations analyst Alden Meyer of the European think-tank E3G said.

United Nations Environment Programme Executive Director Inger Andersen also spoke about concerns, saying, "Is it frustrating? Yes. Is it difficult? Yes."

Johan Rockstrom, director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research in Germany, said, "We can sum up all these four multilateral meetings of 2024 that we are still failing."

While speaking with the AP, U.N. Climate Secretary Simon Stiell said, "Let's not forget that without U.N.-convened global cooperation, we would be headed for up to 5 degrees Celsius (9 degrees Fahrenheit) of global heating (above pre-industrial levels) — a death sentence for most of humanity."

What's Next

Despite the setbacks, experts interviewed by the AP said they remain hopeful—whether because of the progress made so far or in spite of it. "

"To be hopeless is to give up on the lives of people today," climate activist Mitzi Jonelle Tan said. "To be hopeless is to give up on my family, on our experiences here. To give up is to give up life."

This article includes reporting from The Associated Press.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines