U.S. Continuing Taliban Negotiations to Release Hostage Mark Frerichs Despite Troop Withdrawal

As the U.S. plans to withdraw all troops from Afghanistan on the anniversary of September 11, the U.S. confirmed Monday that it is continuing to negotiate with the Taliban to secure the release of American hostage Mark Frerichs, a contractor from Lombard, Illinois, according to the Associated Press.

"Any leverage that we had, we've just now announced to the world and to the Taliban and the Haqqanis that we're going to pull out. Not only is it our leverage, it's our military capability to rescue him," Representative Michael Waltz (R-Fla.) told AP to express that the U.S. troop withdrawal might decrease chances of rescuing Frerichs. "So it's just utterly disheartening."

Frerichs was kidnapped in Afghanistan in January of 2020. His family is frustrated at the failure of the U.S. in securing his return while the Biden administration has previously said it regards returning American hostages as a top priority, according to AP.

For more reporting from the Associated Press, see below.

President Joe Biden on Afghanistan
President Joe Biden speaks from the Treaty Room in the White House on April 14, 2021, in Washington, D.C., about the withdrawal of the remaining U.S. troops from Afghanistan. Andrew Harnik/AFP via Getty Images

Frerichs was not mentioned in President Joe Biden's address on Afghanistan last week. Neither was the troop withdrawal, scheduled to be complete by September 11, conditioned on his release from custody, fueling concerns that the U.S. could lose bargaining power to get Frerichs home once its military presence is removed from the country.

Despite the return of hostages being a top priority for the Biden administration, the fate of a single captive is unlikely to sway the broader policy interest in ending a 20-year war that began in response to the September 11, 2001, attacks. It's not uncommon for detainee issues to be eclipsed by other foreign policy matters, as appeared to happen last week when the administration didn't mention Russia's detention of two Americans, even as it announced reasons for taking punitive action against Moscow.

The Trump administration signed a peace deal in February 2020, just weeks after Frerichs vanished.

His sister, Charlene Cakora, said in a statement that the military withdrawal "puts a time stamp on Mark. We have 150 days to get him home or our leverage is gone."

Frerichs' home-state senators, Democrats Tammy Duckworth and Dick Durbin, raised similar concerns in a letter earlier this year to Biden.

In an interview Monday, Duckworth said she has been reassured by the administration that Frerichs has been part of the discussions and that officials are aware of his case. She said she spoke privately with Biden last Thursday, handing him a note with information about the case.

"He said he was very well aware and he asked me to also let the family know that he was aware and was on top of it," Duckworth said.

The U.S. has not disclosed much about Frerichs' fate or status but confirmed Monday that it was in active negotiations with the Taliban.

State Department spokesman Ned Price said in a statement that U.S. peace envoy Zalmay Khalilzad, working closely with Roger Carstens, the special presidential envoy for hostage affairs, "has continued to press the Taliban for Mr. Frerichs' release, and continues to raise his status in senior level engagements in Doha and Islamabad. We place a high priority on Mark Frerichs' safety and will not stop working until he is safely returned to his family."

AP reported in January that the Taliban during the Trump administration had sought the release of a combatant imprisoned on drug charges in the U.S. as part of a broader effort to resolve issues with Afghanistan. The request prompted dialogue between the State Department and the Justice Department about whether such a release could happen, though it ultimately did not.

Duckworth, who has spoken about the case with Khalilzad, said the Taliban remained "insistent" on that release and not moved off that condition.

The announced withdrawal from Afghanistan was one of two significant foreign policy moves announced by Biden last week. The other involved sanctions on Russia for election interference and for the hack of federal government agencies.

The White House did not use that opportunity to call out Moscow for what U.S. officials said is the unjust detention of at least two Americans: Paul Whelan, a corporate security executive from Michigan sentenced to 16 years in prison on espionage charges, and Trevor Reed, a Marine veteran who was convicted in an altercation with police in Russia and sentenced to nine years.

Whelan's brother, David, said in a statement that he was hopeful for rapprochement between Moscow and Washington but also concerned that the tit-for-tat actions—Russia responded to the U.S. sanctions with its own diplomatic sanctions—may have made that more challenging.

"First, the sanctions continue to make it difficult for the two nations to create the relationship and dialogue necessary to create conditions that might lead to Paul's release," Whelan wrote. "Second, the winnowing of US Embassy staff in Russia will make the difficult work of consular support even harder."

Correction: This article has been updated to say that Frerichs was kidnapped in Afghanistan.