
...

By Wendy Cutler
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
When I served as the chief U.S. negotiator for the U.S.-Korea Free Trade Agreement (KORUS), I learned that the most durable partnerships are not those without disagreements. They are the ones with enough trust, pragmatism, creativity and shared interest to work through them.
KORUS was never an easy negotiation. Sensitive issues, including agriculture, automobiles, and pharmaceuticals tested both sides. Securing U.S. access to Korea’s beef market was among the most sensitive. KORUS succeed in reducing Korea’s steep beef tariffs, while the separate question of when and under what conditions Korea would fully reopen its market remained deeply contentious.
After a case of bovine spongiform encephalopathy, commonly called mad cow disease, was discovered in the United States in 2003, Korea and many other partners suspended imports of U.S. beef. When Seoul agreed in 2008 to reopen its market, the decision touched off weeks of mass candlelight demonstrations. Night after night, central Seoul was filled with protesters.
Read More on Opinion
At the time, it seemed like the controversy would leave a permanent scar on the bilateral economic relationship. It did not. Through round-the-clock negotiations, Washington and Seoul agreed on additional safeguards which paved the way for the reopening of this important market.
Since 2021, Korea has been the largest overseas market for American beef by value. A product that once threatened the overall U.S.-Korea relationship turned into a success story for both sides.

...
That transformation did not happen because either side dismissed legitimate concerns or pretended that the disagreement was trivial. It happened because both sides stayed engaged, addressed the substance and refused to let a single difficult issue define the entire relationship.
That is an important lesson for both countries today. We find ourselves back in a world where U.S. concerns over a few Korean restrictive trade measures is, unfortunately, defining our relationship.
This is not in the interest of either side, particularly in a turbulent world that is experiencing active conflicts, fragmentation, weaponization of trade, technology competition and supply chain vulnerabilities. In such a world, the U.S. and Korea should work together closely to address these challenges.
The beef controversy was hardly the last test. In 2017 and 2018, the United States sought significant changes to KORUS only a few years after the agreement had entered into force. There was political pressure and no shortage of sharp rhetoric. Yet the two governments negotiated amendments largely to address U.S. automotive concerns, preserved the agreement and put the updated accord into effect in 2019. The committees and working groups created under KORUS have continued to provide both sides with practical channels for addressing concerns in agriculture, customs, technology and other sectors.
This history offers useful perspective.
Individual disputes should be taken seriously and addressed on their merits. Friends should be candid when they believe their concerns are not being met. But they should also keep disagreements in perspective and manage them through the channels the two countries have built and used over decades exactly for these purposes.
As a treaty ally, Korea hosts 28,500 U.S. troops in one of the world’s most strategically consequential regions. It is also investing deeply in America’s industrial future. Korean companies are building semiconductor fans, battery plants and automotive facilities across the United States, creating American jobs and sharing advanced manufacturing know how.
Korean investment stock in the United States surpassed $90 billion in 2024, more than twice its level a decade earlier.
That investment is now moving further upstream into the industrial capabilities the United States needs most. Korea Zinc is planning a $6.6 billion critical-minerals smelter in Tennessee that would strengthen domestic supplies for defense, semiconductors and advanced manufacturing. Hyundai Steel is preparing to break ground on a $5.8 billion low-carbon steel mill in Louisiana, its first steelmaking facility in North America. These projects show that Korean investment is not simply adding production capacity. It is helping rebuild foundational links in American supply chains.
The next chapter in U.S.-Korea relations could be even more consequential. The United States is seeking to rebuild industries central to both economic and national security, especially shipbuilding. Korea is one of the few democratic countries with the industrial scale, skilled workforce and commercial experience to help. Shipbuilding, semiconductors, energy, critical minerals, pharmaceuticals and advanced technology all offer opportunities for deeper cooperation. Turning that potential into operating facilities, resilient supply chains and good American jobs will require sustained political support on both sides.
The lesson of American beef in Korea is not that current disputes are unimportant or should be ignored. Rather, it is that even an issue capable of filling the streets of Seoul in protest need not derail the overall partnership. The United States and Korea have faced thorny problems before and resolved them through engagement, pragmatism and creativity. As a result, they have emerged stronger and ready to tackle the larger matters on the strategic horizon.
They should do so again.
Wendy Cutler is Senior Vice President at the Asia Society Policy Institute and former chief U.S. negotiator for the U.S.–Korea Free Trade Agreement.
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines