
...

By Robert Alexander
Senior Crime & Court Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Utah lawmakers are preparing to expand the state Supreme Court from five justices to seven, a move expected to be taken up early in the 2026 legislative session.
Supporters describe the proposal as a long-overdue response to population growth and rising court workloads, while critics argue its timing reflects political frustration with recent judicial rulings.
Newsweek contacted Senators Todd Weiler (R) and Stephanie Pitcher (D), Senate President J. Stuart Adams (R), House Speaker Mike Schultz (R) and Governor Spencer Cox (R) for comment by email on Wednesday. Newsweek also contacted the Utah state courts’ media office for comment.
Read More on News
Why It Matters
The proposal matters because it would reshape how Utah’s highest court functions at a moment of rising legal demand and political strain.
Supporters say adding two justices would ease record caseloads and bring the court in line with other states of similar size, potentially speeding up decisions that affect elections, criminal cases and state policy.
Critics counter that the timing—following a series of rulings that frustrated Republican lawmakers—raises concerns about judicial independence and whether structural changes to the court are being driven by efficiency needs or political pressure.

...
What To Know
The plan was confirmed publicly this week by state Senator Todd Weiler, who said the expansion would likely occur during the first week of the upcoming session.
Weiler and local lawyer Corey Astill host a weekly right-leaning show called Political as Heck.
Speaking on his locally produced political podcast, Weiler noted that Utah has operated with a five-member high court since the late 19th century, even as the state’s population has increased more than tenfold since achieving statehood.
Under Utah law, the Legislature sets the size of the state’s highest court, with the Constitution requiring a minimum of five justices but no maximum.
Utah has not changed the number of Supreme Court justices since 1917.

...
Rising Caseloads
Lawmakers backing the proposal point first to workload pressures. Utah’s appellate courts reported record filings in fiscal year 2025, with 270 cases reaching the Supreme Court and 1,143 filed with the Court of Appeals.
Combined filings for the two courts have increased by roughly one-third since 2017, according to court system data.
Supporters argue that additional justices would help reduce delays and speed up decisions.
Legislative leaders have said the Court of Appeals, in particular, has seen judges handling close to 1,000 cases annually, far more than in previous years.
While the immediate proposal focuses on the Supreme Court, lawmakers have also discussed adding resources across the appellate system.
Political Backdrop
The timing of the proposal has drawn scrutiny because it follows several high-profile rulings that frustrated Republican lawmakers.
Those include decisions that blocked enforcement of Utah’s near-total abortion ban and limited the Legislature’s ability to alter voter-approved initiatives without a compelling public interest.

...
More recently, tensions escalated after a district court ruling in a congressional redistricting case, in which a judge selected new maps after concluding lawmakers failed to follow a voter-approved anti-gerrymandering process.
Republican leaders have said they intend to appeal that decision to the Supreme Court, raising questions about whether an expanded court could hear the case with new members seated.
Democratic critics have characterized the expansion as political retaliation aimed at reshaping the court’s ideological balance.
Supporters reject that framing, emphasizing that all five current justices were appointed by Republican governors.
Governor’s Support
Governor Spencer Cox has endorsed the proposal, calling it “a good idea” and pushing back against claims that it amounts to court packing.
Cox has said his support is rooted in Utah’s growth and in comparisons with similarly sized states, most of which have seven or nine justices on their highest courts.
Cox has also emphasized that expanding the court would provide more resources to the judiciary overall, arguing that Utah is no longer the state it was even two decades ago in terms of population and complexity of legal disputes.
How Utah Compares
Nationally, Utah’s Supreme Court is smaller than most. Twenty-eight states operate with seven-member supreme courts, while 17 have five justices.
A smaller group, including some larger states, has nine.
Utah has remained at five justices despite growing to about 3.5 million residents.
Court expansions are not unprecedented, and several states have adjusted the size of their supreme courts over time in response to population growth and workload.
Still, judicial leaders in Utah have previously cautioned that adding justices at the Supreme Court level could slow deliberations, even if it helps distribute workload.
As the 2026 session approaches, the proposal appears likely to advance, setting up a debate that blends administrative concerns with broader questions about judicial independence and legislative authority.
What People Are Saying
Governor Spencer Cox said of proposals to expand Utah’s Supreme Court and the state’s appellate bench: “I support getting more resources to the courts generally.”
More than 900 Utah attorneys In a letter signed by opposing the proposal warned: “We cannot stand idly by and allow democracy to be so weakened,” arguing the effort would “attack, manipulate, retaliate, and control the Utah judiciary.”
What Happens Next
Lawmakers are expected to introduce and advance legislation early in the 2026 session to expand the Utah Supreme Court from five to seven justices, a change that can be made through statute rather than a constitutional amendment.
If approved by the Legislature and signed by Gov. Spencer Cox, two new seats would be created, triggering a judicial nominating and Senate confirmation process that could take weeks or months.
In the meantime, the court would continue operating with five justices, with the timing of any new appointments potentially affecting how upcoming high-profile appeals are heard.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines