10

Loading video...

Tom O'Connor

By Tom O'Connor

Deputy Editor, National Security and Foreign Policy

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A CNN report citing U.S. intelligence alleging Iranian efforts to detonate a so-called "dirty bomb" in Washington, D.C., has sparked new fears of a possible weapon of mass destruction in the hands of the Islamic Republic.

As with President Donald Trump's accusations that Tehran has sought nuclear arms, one of the core pretexts for the war launched against the Persian Gulf power nearly nine months ago, Iranian officials have vehemently denied the claim.

Trump, who has often criticized CNN and other media outlets carrying wartime intelligence findings, told reporters Tuesday that he is taking the report "very seriously." The White House earlier said that "there are no credible threats to the homeland."

Read More

Map Shows How Iran ‘Dirty Bomb’ Could Impact Washington, DC8 min read

Map Shows How Iran ‘Dirty Bomb’ Could Impact Washington, DC

An attack of this kind has never before been conducted, and analysts said the feasibility and impact vary drastically based on several factors should Iran, its allied networks or supporters abroad actually pursue such a plot. And while the nature of the threat remains uncertain and unverified, they warn that the prospect of a hostile actor acquiring and using a dirty bomb, sometimes called a radiological dispersion device (RDD), is not to be outright dismissed.

"Unfortunately, the threat posed by the potential acquisition or construction of a crude RDD is credible," Margarita Kalinina-Pohl, director of the CBRN Security Program at the Middlebury Institute of International Studies at Monterey's Center for Nonproliferation Studies, told Newsweek.

Iranian security walk past a billboard that reads, "We will kill Trump," referring to the U.S. president, at Enghelab Square in Tehran on November 16, 2026.

...

What Is a Dirty Bomb?

A "dirty bomb" is most commonly defined as a device capable of spreading radioactive material across a large area. The means of dispersal can include conventional explosives or other mechanisms, although the repercussions are more widely associated with the contamination of a major population center.

"A dirty bomb refers to a radiological dispersal device, which combines radioactive material with some sort of dispersal mechanism," Phillip Bleek, fellow at the Middlebury Institute of International Studies at Monterey's Center for Nonproliferation Studies and Center for Terrorism, Extremism and Counterterrorism, told Newsweek.

"Usually, we think of the bomb version as using explosives for dispersal, but a radiological dispersal device could also use incendiary material or a fan, or a so-called radiological exposure device could just involve placing material in a location, like a garbage can, where it irradiated anyone proximate."

Examples of potential elements that could be equipped to such a device range from fissile materials used in the production of nuclear weapons such as Plutonium-239, Uranium-235 and Uranium-233 to commercially available materials such as Americium-241, Cesium-137 and Cobalt-60, according to the Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation.

Bleek described an "inverse relationship between how feasible a radiological weapon would be and how consequential it would be."

The deadlier it is, the harder it is to acquire and deploy behind enemy lines.

"For example, radiological sources are used in the oil industry to survey rock formations or test pipes, and those sources are relatively compact and relatively less radioactive," Bleek said. "At the other end of the spectrum, spent nuclear fuel from a reactor is highly radioactive, but bulky and because of its radioactivity, hard to work with and to transport."

Related Story

Map Shows How Iran ‘Dirty Bomb’ Could Impact Washington, DC

Map Shows How Iran ‘Dirty Bomb’ Could Impact Washington, DC

How a Dirty Bomb Differs From a Nuclear Bomb

While there may be some overlap in the radioactive nature of a dirty bomb and nuclear weapon, Bleek pointed out that the latter "is in a completely different category, harnessing nuclear fission and/or fusion to generate explosive yield, making possible extraordinarily powerful bombs."

Eight nations openly possess nuclear weapons: the United States, Russia, the United Kingdom, France, China, India and Pakistan. Israel is widely known to have an arsenal as well, though it routinely neither confirms nor denies its existence.

Iran is not assessed to have developed a nuclear weapon. However, its advanced nuclear program, missile prowess, dual-use space-launch technology and other factors have repeatedly fueled speculation that the Islamic Republic secretly sought to acquire such a capability.

A fatwa, or Islamic ruling, issued decades ago by the late Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei—slain by the U.S. and Israel at the outset of the ongoing war that began on February 28—is widely cited by Iranian officials as a central obstacle to the prospect of the country ever acquiring a nuclear bomb or other devices with nuclear, chemical, biological or radiological properties.

Yet the doctrine has long faced public scrutiny. And whether the judgment holds under his son and successor, Supreme Leader Ayatollah Mojtaba Khamenei, remains a key topic of debate among supporters and detractors of the Islamic Republic.

Still, there have been no public indications that Tehran has shifted its position, either on obtaining a nuclear weapon or going down the dirty bomb route. But the latter choice would constitute an entirely different strategy and set of consequences.

"The impact would be far more economic and psychological than physical," Carl Peterson, senior analyst of emerging technology and non-states actors at Militant Wire, told Newsweek. "Most casualties would likely come from the blast itself, not the radiation.

"The real damage is fear, area denial and a cleanup that could take months and cost enormous sums. The dark joke about this is that it should be called a weapon of mass disruption rather than mass destruction."

Italian Air Force members simulate an intervention on a possible dirty bomb in a low oxygen ground floor corridor at the Al Qaqaa military base, in Doha, Qatar, on December 7, 2022.

...

What Was Iran's Alleged Plan to Detonate a Dirty Bomb in Washington?

The CNN report, published Monday, cited seven unnamed U.S. officials and sources familiar with the alleged intelligence at hand. Details included Iranian chatter of bomb-making materials hidden on U.S. soil, possible plans to use chemical weapons against U.S. troops in the Middle East and a series of contingency planning meetings held by U.S. officials over the past week.

Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesperson Esmaeil Beqaei portrayed the report as part of a dedicated effort by the U.S. to fabricate pretexts for further escalation against his country, also noting a recent report in The New York Times that sought to link Iran's dam network with the locations of underground missile sites.

"Those who initiated the aggression against Iran are now seeking to lay the media groundwork for their sinister designs by manufacturing and disseminating baseless allegations, including the recent claims published by The New York Times and the fabricated media narrative surrounding an alleged “dirty bomb” propagated by CNN," Beqaei wrote Tuesday on X.

"Step by step, they are attempting to manufacture a veneer of legitimacy for further aggression and atrocities."

Beqaei and other Iranian officials have also recently slammed reports alleging ramped-up Iranian efforts to assassinate top U.S. officials, including Trump. Iran has previously been linked by U.S. intelligence to plots against Trump, particularly after the president's first-term decision to order the killing of Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) Quds Force commander Major General Qassem Soleimani in January 2020.

Iran's hostility toward Trump has only deepened with the slaying of Khamenei and other top officials in the ongoing conflict. Banners directly threatening the U.S. leader's life have been a common sight in the country since the start of the war.

But as Peterson explained, "a dirty bomb is a terror weapon, not an assassination tool," and, "if the goal is targeting specific officials, it's a poor fit."

He noted how some past high-profile assassinations using deadly agents, such as the killing of Russian defector Alexander Litvenko with radioactive polonium-210 in 2006 and the killing of North Korea's Kim Jong Nam, half-brother of Supreme Leader Kim Jong Un, in 2017, utilized "close-range poisoning."

"So, I read this as Iran building options, which is how CNN's own sources described it, rather than a sign that an attack is imminent," Peterson said. "Worth taking seriously, but worth keeping in proportion."

Who Has Tried to Build a Dirty Bomb Before?

While no individual or group has ever managed to detonate a dirty bomb in an attack, the threat is not without precedent.

Peterson highlighted how Chechen militants had left a container of radioactive material in a Moscow park in 1995, during Russia's first war with its southern separatist state, in an apparent warning to the Kremlin.

Months after the 9/11 attacks conducted by Al-Qaeda, U.S. citizen Jose Padilla was arrested in 2002 on suspicion of plotting a dirty bomb attack, though his subsequent conviction did not carry that specific charge. In 2004, U.K. national Dhiren Barot was arrested on terrorism charges after authoring a lengthy portfolio of instructions on home-made bombs, including those incorporating radiological materials.

Some of the most serious concerns emerged with the Islamic State militant group's (ISIS) takeover of vast swathes of Iraq and Syria, including a wealth of radiological material in large cities such as Mosul. While the group was found to have made limited use of chemical weapons stockpiles it captured, the dirty bomb threat never manifested.

Such threats have not always been tied to Islamist actors. White nationalist James Cumming was found in possession of uranium and thorium along with explosive precursors and dirty-bomb-building literature during authorities' search of his Maine residence after he was shot to death by his wife in 2008.

"Internationally, there have been cases of illicit trafficking, unauthorized possession, and attempts to sell radioactive materials that could be used as components for such a device," Kalinina-Pohl said. "This demonstrates why securing radioactive sources and preventing their unauthorized acquisition remain important priorities."

Nickolas Roth, senior director of nuclear materials security at the Nuclear Threat Initiative, argued that while protections for such materials exist, they are not airtight.

"Radioactive sources are used every day in hospitals, universities, industry and research facilities around the world," Roth told Newsweek. "Many are well protected, but security practices vary widely, and not all sources are adequately secured."

A 2016 infographic details the impact of a dirty bomb attack on Washington D.C.

...

Would Iran Even Want a Dirty Bomb?

In Iran, the war may actually serve to further erode these protections, exposing them to capture by "rogue" elements.

A Congressional Research Service report published in March, just over a week after the conflict began, said that Iranian "facility operators may lose control of civilian radiological material, which could be transported across borders and used in explosive devices."

As to whether the Iranian government may opt to make use of these materials in warfare, the Islamic Republic's active nuclear program and known ties to allies and sympathizers abroad may give it an edge over lone wolves or militant groups. But this would break with a well-established playbook that has already allowed Iran to withstand the U.S. assault and retaliate with other, proven forms of asymmetric warfare.

"I’m not aware of evidence that this tactic fits the pattern of Iran-affiliated groups, and from a strategic standpoint it would make little sense," Roth said. "Given the potential consequences of such an accusation, it should be held to a very high standard of evidence."

Bleek also expressed skepticism, estimating how such an attack "would likely be a terrible miscalculation on their part."

"But if such an attack occurred and we were trying to explain it, I would say the primary reason Iran might conduct a radiological attack would be shock value," Bleek said. "It would send a signal of their willingness to cross normative lines in the sand.

"It would also be what political scientists call a costly signal because Iran would risk serious blowback, including military retaliation, but also reputational risk, and costlier signals are more potent than cheaper signals."

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Samantha Beech and Dave Siminoff.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines