
...

By Joe Edwards
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The U.S. Supreme Court's decision to intervene in Alabama's redistricting dispute days before a primary has ignited heated debate online, with social media users arguing the move may have violated the Purcell principle, a long-standing legal doctrine meant to prevent last-minute changes to election rules.
On Monday, the Supreme Court lifted a lower‑court order that had required Alabama to continue using a congressional map with two majority‑Black districts, clearing the way for the state to pursue a Republican‑drawn map adopted in 2023 that includes only one such district. The move came less than a week before primary voting was set to begin, prompting critics to argue that the court's action risks voter confusion and administrative chaos—precisely what the so‑called Purcell principle is meant to avoid.

...
Read More on News
What Is the Purcell Principle?
The Purcell principle is a legal doctrine in U.S. election law that cautions courts against altering voting rules shortly before an election, as late-stage judicial changes risk confusing voters and disrupting election administration.
The principle takes its name from the 2006 U.S. Supreme Court case Purcell v. Gonzalez. The case arose from a challenge to Arizona's voter identification law, which had been temporarily blocked by a lower court shortly before a midterm election. The Supreme Court intervened and reversed that decision, emphasizing that last-minute judicial orders affecting elections can create uncertainty and discourage participation.
The Purcell principle is often invoked in election law disputes when a litigant seeks to prevent a lower court's ruling from taking effect until an appeal has been heard by a higher court. In such cases, a party may request that an appellate court grant a "stay," temporarily delaying the lower court's decision. According to Britannica, courts consider this request alongside several factors, including the likelihood that the appeal will succeed and the potential for irreparable harm.
The Supreme Court has not defined a precise cutoff for when changes are considered "too close" to an election or how potential voter confusion should be balanced against other factors, including ensuring that voters are able to access the ballot, which has led to varied applications across cases.
What Did the Supreme Court Decide for Alabama?
The Alabama case stems from years of litigation over whether the state's congressional maps comply with Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act. In Allen v. Milligan (2023), the Supreme Court upheld a lower‑court finding that Alabama's post‑2020 census map likely diluted Black voting strength and ordered the creation of a second opportunity district.
After Alabama's legislature adopted a revised map in 2023 that still included only one majority‑Black district, federal judges blocked its use and imposed a court‑drawn map with two such districts for the 2024 elections. Following a full trial, the lower court ruled in 2025 that Alabama's 2023 plan violated the Voting Rights Act by intentionally discriminating against Black voters.
However, the Supreme Court's decision last month in Louisiana v. Callais narrowed how Section 2 applies to race‑conscious districting. Citing that ruling, Alabama officials asked the justices to act quickly and lift the injunction blocking the 2023 map.
On Monday, the court agreed, vacating the lower‑court orders and sending the case back for reconsideration in light of Callais. The order effectively reopened the possibility that Alabama could use its map with one majority‑Black district in upcoming elections.
The decision prompted criticism from some justices. Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote in a dissent to the ruling that the ruling "will cause only confusion as Alabamians begin to vote in the elections scheduled for next week."
Did the Decision Break the Purcell Principle?
Some analysts suggested the decision ran counter to the principle, but others disagreed.
Joyce Vance, who served as the U.S. attorney for the Northern District of Alabama from 2009 to 2017, wrote on social media: "The Supreme Court, which ordered Alabama to create a second Black opportunity district just three years ago, has lifted that order one week before the primary. The Purcell principle says courts shouldn't permit chaos too close to an election—it's now an open question as to whether there will even be a primary on schedule."
Sean Trende, a senior elections analyst at RealClearPolitics, wrote in response to Vance: "So this isn't what Purcell says and it gets confused all the time. Purcell says federal courts won't *order* changes to state administrative procedures close to an election. It says absolutely nothing about states' own abilities to change those procedures on their own."
NBC senior Supreme Court reporter Lawrence Hurley also weighed in, writing: "And the court in a 2020 case said the aim of the Purcell principle is to avoid 'judicially created confusion.' To the extent there is confusion now, it has been created by the Supreme Court itself, not lower courts."
Officials backing the ruling contend that the Supreme Court was right to step in, arguing that allowing elections to proceed under a map they see as legally flawed would have caused greater harm.
Alabama Solicitor General Barrett Bowdre argued to the justices that the state would otherwise be forced to "hold elections under a map that was erroneously ordered at best and unconstitutional at worst. Nothing requires that result," the court watcher SCOTUSblog reported. He added, "Americans, no less in Alabama, deserve a republic free of racial sorting now, and state officials deserve an opportunity to give it to them."
Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall said in a May 8 statement referencing the Louisiana ruling: "Alabama drew a map based on lawful policy goals, not race, and the Supreme Court's recent ruling vindicates that approach. We were punished for doing the right thing, and we are asking the court to correct that now."
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines