10
Loading video...

By Brooke Erin Duffy and Jess Rauchberg
Associate Professor, Department of Communication at Cornell University; Assistant Professor of Communication Technologies at Seton Hall University
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Nearly two decades after a reporter chronicled the guileless bloggers "[taking] over the tents" at New York Fashion Week, social media personalities are no longer cast as media industry interlopers. Rather, they wield sway across nearly every facet of social and civic life—from health and fitness to finance and agriculture. But perhaps their most remarkable incursion has been in the news and information landscape. Earlier this year, the White House even granted these "new media voices" access to press events.
It's no small wonder that culture critic Kyle Chayka declared 2024 "the year creators took over." But a crucial dimension of this takeover remains overlooked—gender politics. The legitimization of influencers has coincided with an influx of unabashedly masculine voices.
Roots in Women's Digital Culture
Read More on Opinion
The rise of the "influencer industry"—a sector that, by bullish estimates, could swell to $33 billion over the next few years—has been fueled by a confluence of factors: the astounding growth of social platforms, most especially the consumer-centric hubs of Instagram and TikTok; marketers' frantic search for a direct line to ad-weary consumers; and post-pandemic labor market shifts. As the 9-to-5 loses its luster, independent work in the so-called creator economy beguiles with promises of creative autonomy and flexibility.

...
But feminized forms of cultural production—especially mommy blogs and personal style vlogs—laid the groundwork for this industrial boom. This gendered foundation is often forgotten now that digital influence has expanded far beyond "women's work."
The story bears recounting. When we began studying online content creation more than a decade ago, social media aspirants were already using many of the euphemisms that have since become axioms of the creator economy—authenticity, passion, and "doing what you love." Brands began to seed first-gen fashion bloggers and beauty vloggers with comped products, hoping they would tout the virtues to viewers. This commercial tit-for-tat, and the system of exploitation that it wrought, augured in a new era of sponsored content. And, as The Influencer Industry author Emily Hund put it, authenticity became a commodity for brands and bloggers alike to monetize.
At the same time, these early participants—overwhelmingly women—faced an uphill battle in the quest for status, legitimacy, and—crucially—income. Popular culture parodies and hand-wringing headlines devalued this work by constructing influencers as glib and narcissistic. Social media influence was, moreover, burdened by its not-quite-work leisure status. These early influencers were, moreover, dismissed as "girls with no jobs"—despite their role in financially revitalizing fashion and beauty journalism. It is in this vein that SheSpeaks Founder Aliza Freud described the disparagement of influencers as "a misogyny problem."
Though reliable statistics on such a sprawling labor market are notoriously elusive, countless surveys point to a gender gap. A 2023 survey of influencer profiles revealed that roughly 77 percent were women. Still, these influential women were paid significantly less than their male counterparts. And, crucially, this pay gap is far worse for women of color.
A Gender Reversal?
In recent months, the gendered nature of the influencer industry has been contested on several fronts. Consider usage of the very term "influencer." While outsiders long balked at a term with trappings of frivolity and consumerism, it's a category increasingly brandished by participants in the manosphere.
The 2024 U.S. presidential campaign was a tipping point in the influencer industry as participants garnered clout in an unlikely domain. In the lead up to the campaign, both parties leveraged influencers—at times courting them with reckless abandon. But it was the Trump campaign that ingratiated itself to voices like Charlie Kirk and Ben Shapiro—who embody hyper-partisan, and supposedly hyper-masculine opinion leadership. A visual diagram published in Wired brought the gender divide into sharp relief— notwithstanding important exceptions on both sides of the political spectrum (V Spehar and Heather Cox Richardson), the boldest voices in the election were men.
Beyond the specifics of this so-called influencer election, the wider realm of news influence is dominated by men—63 percent, according to a 2024 survey from the Pew Research Center. Minding this gender gap is even more critical given that the same report found that more than one in five Americans rely on influencers for news.
While men are taking over news influence, attention to the plucky, "have-it-all" girlboss of the 2010s has shifted to the hyper-feminine tradwife—figures who, despite raking in millions, downplay their business acumen. This digital entrepreneurship, often centering a child-rearing homemaker, is obfuscated by stylistic, edited videos. While male podcasters are uplifted, shaping young men's political perspectives and worldviews, lifestyle influencers and bloggers are further disavowed. This amounts to a recasting of Victorian separate spheres in the social media space—the public (that is, political) masculine world, and the private, domestic feminine world, where we see women work, but we don't hear their voices.
On the surface, the growing valuation of influencers is a boon, especially in a long-dismissed and overlooked career field. But the history of gender-coded technological labor offers another explanation. Consider the computing revolution. Historians like Nathan Ensmenger and Jennifer S. Light have explored the masculinization of U.S. computing in late 20th century, when "women computers"—actual women who did the work of high volume data computation—were ousted by high prestige, high salary professionals in mechanical computing and technological development. The latter were, of course, almost exclusively men.
Taking Influencers Seriously
The role of influencers is changing in the ascendant political climate—one shaped by precarious economic conditions, political polarization, and crucially, a social and political assault on women's rights. But the upshot is a fundamental divide in what kinds of influencing we take seriously—increasingly, white, gender-normative separate spheres which crowd out or silence alternative femininities and masculinities, creators of color, LGBTQ creators, and other non-normative voices.
Influencing's third decade marks a gendered difference in digital entrepreneurship as the industry strays from its roots in fashion and style. As the industry transforms, will we remember a time—borrowing Jennifer Light's framing of tech's masculinization—when influencers were women?
Brooke Erin Duffy, Ph.D., is an associate professor at Cornell University, where she studies the role of social media in work, employment, and society. She is the author of three books, including (Not) Getting Paid to Do What You Love: Gender and Aspirational Labor in the Social Media Economy (Yale University Press, 2017/2022).
Jess Rauchberg, Ph.D., is an assistant professor of communication technologies at Seton Hall University. She researches inequalities in the creator economy, with a focus on disability and gender. Twitter/X: @JessRauchberg.
The views expressed in this article are the writers' own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines