...
By Mark P. Braboy
Award-Winning Music and Culture Multimedia Journalist
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
From the moment Ye, formally known as Kanye West, broke out with his monumental debut album in 2004, The College Dropout, contrarianism has been his calling card.
We saw him enter as the pink polo-wearing Chicagoan who stood in contrast to the then-dominant hypermasculine imagery of gangster rap, echoing the sentiments of Black people across the country during Hurricane Katrina 20 years ago, proclaiming “George Bush doesn’t care about Black People.”
...
Read More on Opinion
In the wake of the Black Lives Matter (BLM) movement and the murder of George Floyd, Ye flipped into one of the earliest supporters of Donald Trump’s first presidential campaign in 2016. For a decade, he descended into spreading anti-Black, antisemitic and misogynistic messages to his audience. And as rappers like Youngboy Never Broke Again (NBA Youngboy), Nicki Minaj, Snoop Dogg and others would pledge their allegiance to the MAGA movement, amid a growing wave of fascism in the United States with the second Trump administration, it seems that Ye’s changing his tune … again.
Despite several “apologies” in the past, Ye’s been on a public accountability campaign since November 2025. He met with Rabbi Yoshiyahu Yosef Pinto, which, by his account, were his “first steps” to repairing his relationship with the Jewish community. Since then, he’s strategically taken out an ad in The Wall Street Journal and delivered a lengthy apology for his years of antisemitic behavior.
In Ye’s apology, he revealed a shocking factor no one publicly knew. The infamous car crash that nearly took his life in 2002, according to him, caused injury to the right frontal-lobe of his brain.
“Comprehensive scans were not done, neurological exams were limited, and the possibility of a frontal-lobe injury was never raised. It wasn’t properly diagnosed until 2023. That medical oversight caused serious damage to my mental health and led to my bipolar type-1 diagnosis,” the letter said.
Then, Ye gave an interview via email with Vanity Fair where he expounded on his sentiments. He apologized to both the Black and Jewish communities for the years of harm, acknowledging that it all went too far.
As someone who has long battled his own mental health wars (though I don’t have bipolar disorder like Ye recently admitted), I can empathize. Especially to those who are open about it because we are stigmatized, misunderstood and sometimes ostracized by our own communities. And at times, we do engage in self-destructive and self-sabotaging behavior that can harm everything we work so hard to build, if left untreated. I know this firsthand as Kayne wasn’t lying when he wrote in his letter, “Once people label you as 'crazy,' you feel as if you cannot contribute anything meaningful to the world.”
Psychosis is a known symptom of bipolar disorder. The music industry has never been known to value the mental well-being of artists. However, there’s a nuance here that untreated mental illness muddies. Where is the line between reckless behavior caused by mental illness and nefarious behavior? Who is the real Kanye Omari West?
In 2022, CNN reported that Kanye had a history of admiring Adolph Hitler, going as far back as 2018. “He would praise Hitler by saying how incredible it was that he was able to accumulate so much power and would talk about all the great things he and the Nazi Party achieved for the German people,” the unnamed source told CNN. Kanye recently declined to share the origins of these beliefs.
However, Ye’s Nazism bled into his music. He collaborated with rapper/songwriter Dave Blunts to create arguably the vilest song in all of hip hop, HH, which was leaked on X in 2025. And even as Kanye’s been trying to salvage what’s left of his image, the viral denizens of the so-called manosphere brought that cursed song back to the forefront on Miami Beach. This shows that despite Ye’s alleged reform, his actions still carry long-lasting consequences.
In 2025, Ye was accused of sexual assault and sex trafficking by his former assistant Lauren Pisciotta. This encapsulates what makes his redemption so complicated. While the bulk of his apology, and the effort behind it, appears to be geared toward the Jewish community, he has yet to atone for his alleged vicious misogyny. Nor have these accusations been resolved. What example does this set when his beautiful, talented daughter North West is old enough to learn of his transgressions against women for herself?
We’re seeing immediate results of Ye’s apology. He signed a new deal with independent label Gamma, pushing his forthcoming album, Bully, back to March 20. While Kanye denies that his umpteenth attempt at redemption “isn’t about reviving my commerciality,” it is all adjacent.
I don’t blame rappers for using their albums as pegs for other things, but none of this exists in a separate context when it comes to Kanye. He clearly wants his empire back. It’s a completely individual decision if you want to embrace his music again, because at the end of the day, no one can hold him accountable except his own community. Right or wrong, we see him, but he has a significant way to go if he wants to heal the harm he has caused through his actions, mental illness, or otherwise.
Mark P. Braboy is an award-winning music and culture multimedia journalist from Chicago. Through his writing and photography, he documents music culture and the world that shapes it.
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines