
0.cached.png
![]()
By Newsweek Editors
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
One aspect of the recent uproar over the errant testimony of Treasury Department officials to Congress still needs work. It concerns the young diarist, Joshua Steiner, who has been much ridiculed for seeking to disavow the words he had earlier written in his own diary. What interests me is the hilarity with which practically everyone greeted this testimony. People didn't just surmise that he might well be cooking up a story to protect his boss -- which strikes me as a strong possibility. They assumed he had to be cooking up a story since they found his assertion thoroughly implausible. Almost immediately after he spoke Steiner was everywhere tagged in broadcast commentary as "the kid who says he lied to his own diary . . . har, har, har" -- a concept evidently considered preposterous on its face. Who would lie to his diary? the merrymakers wanted to know. To which I reply: Where have these people been? Have they ever read a diary? Have they ever kept one?
Let's leave poor Steiner out of it and go straight to the big issue. It is, from Pepys to Packwood, the general factual reliability of this kind of writing, by which I mean not just diaries, but also autobiogra-phies, journals, memoirs, tapes and the rest. As an obsessive reader of such things, I need to say right here that I am nonetheless extremely uncomfortable with the way some diary-type documents in our time have been swiped, leaked, subpoenaed, impounded and otherwise snatched away from their muttering authors for use as evidence concerning public scandals and crimes. It has by now been explained to me at least 50 times how and why this comes about under law, and on what perfectly constitutional basis it may be justified, so that I have come to accept the exercise as a practical matter; but, in truth, I still hate it. Privacy, even the sanctity of the self, seems to me to be violated in many of these coercions, when the diary has not been voluntarily produced by the living author or at least post-humously published, ideally in accord with his will.
There is, of course, also reason to have misgivings about taking such material as gospel, whether dragged from the author or not. Everybody knows that eyewitnesses to the same event are notoriously liable to recall it in absolutely contradictory ways. And, in the case of political memoirs, everyone also knows that subjectivity leads participants in the same event to entirely different perceptions as to what happened; the one who writes the memoir, unsurprisingly enough, will see his own contribution as pretty great and that of the others as falling somewhere between nothing special and disastrous. So who is to judge which version of such contested events, most offered more or less in good faith, is the right one?
Read More on News
Where the private diarist or journal-keeper is concerned, however, the question gets many times harder, since good faith is not necessarily even in play, and this is true whether the document is willingly published or not. For while it is the case that a personal diary or journal is a setting in which it is singularly safe to tell the truth, just as important, it is also a setting in which it is singularly safe to tell a lie. And many practitioners use it for both purposes. Who says people are necessarily honest with themselves, in the first place? And in the second, the diary, crucially, doesn't talk back. It doesn't say "gimmme a break," when inscribed with a whopper. It doesn't even raise an eyebrow. A diary has never heard of cross-examination. A diary has heard only of what its proprietor chooses to tell it.
Remember that people keep diaries for many different purposes. Some do it to preserve a personal record too easily forgotten, or (especially in government) to have the makings of a book, or to have the goods on a disliked colleague, or to pass family lore on to the grandkids, or even merely to occupy time. But no one comes to the task without the conceits and blind spots and desire for praise and approval that are a built-in part of every life. And all are at least aware in some degree of how their entries would read to others. Even Samuel Pepys, the most honest diarist of them all, who is funny, dirty, unsparingly candid about his own bribe-taking and other lapses, and wonderfully acute on the subject of government, somewhat self-consciously and coyly dips into pidgin French or Spanish when recording his sexual infidelities, as if in the presence of another. ("And there I had . . . mon plain plaisir of elle.") Bob Packwood, paraphrasing one of his famous diary entries in the Senate, made it sound awfully pleasing to himself, awfully bolstering: "She stood up, approached me, put her arms around me, gave me a great big kiss and said, "You're wonderful'."
I don't know if that's true, but I do know that diaries provide their authors with a chance to recast their own lives more to their liking and this sure has the ring. The diary that I kept as a very young teenager, which was repeatedly broken into not just by my brother but also by my grandmother, who had a big role in my upbringing during those years and was not what you would call intensely interested in constitutional rights for 14-year-olds, reads this way to me now. Part amusing and part pathetic with all its endless entries about what I wore that day and about legions of boys I found "cute" and who liked me or those who elicited only an "ugh" of disgust, etc., it is preponderantly an improved, self-reassuring account of my life at the time, grounded in some truth, yet not really truthful. I portrayed myself to myself as I wished I were and thought I should be. Much of it came out of Seventeen magazine's account of how the ideal teenager looked and lived. Although I am at a loss to remember some of the people I talk about familiarly in that diary, even all these years later I can detect the falseness and wishfulness in individual passages.
Pepys is the most honest. Bob Haldeman, whose fascinating diaries were published this year, is the most flat and photographic that I have recently read, and in that sense a presumably trustworthy recorder; and yet he too is working from a particular outlook in those pages. Steiner sounded a bit infatuated and impressed with his role. These -- the great Pepys and the relatively tiny others -- don't belong in the same paragraph, but in all what makes the diaries interesting is not merely their account of what they saw, but also the way they interpreted what was happening to and around them. At least as much as poets, diarists take liberties with their texts.
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines