A woman confronts her mother in law

...

Maria Morava

By Maria Morava

Relationships Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


People make choices about how to parent from a variety of deeply personal factors. When they're not respected, it can sting.

This was a central issue in a post to Reddit's "Am I The A******?" forum, which has gone viral. A woman, u/Vast-Cartographer588, sent her mother-in-law a bill for a refrigerator she had bought for her 5-year-old daughter in an effort to encourage intuitive eating, which her mother-in-law threw away. Newsweek spoke to psychotherapist Melissa Klass about the post, which, since being published, has received over 12,000 upvotes.

"We appreciate that our parenting style is very different from that of our parents," the original poster (OP) began. "Due to my own experience with an eating disorder caused by my upbringing, we prioritize autonomy in food for our daughter and plan to do the same for our son. To foster this, we set up a tiny semi-functional kitchen for our kids. It includes a small, functional fridge."

Read More

D’Vontaye Mitchell Update: Everything We Know as Murder Charges Referred4 min read

D’Vontaye Mitchell Update: Everything We Know as Murder Charges Referred

More From Newsweek Vault: Best Savings Accounts for Kids and Teens

A woman confronts her mother in law

...

The poster wrote that her daughter keeps snacks in her personal fridge and pantry and has the freedom to eat a portion of whatever she wants. Explaining her idea, she said: "This method has resulted in our daughter not going crazy at the prospect of candy or chips because she can decide when to have them. She also knows that once she eats her snacks for the week, that's it, so she has learned to pace herself."

More From Newsweek Vault: Rates Are Still High for These High-Yield Savings Accounts

The system took a hit when the woman's mother-in-law came to town, who, the poster wrote, has very set ways and was not a fan of the tiny kitchen: "She thinks we're going to make our daughter obese by allowing her to have snacks when she wants," the poster said.

On one instance when the child's parents were out of the house, the mother-in-law insisted her granddaughter eat fish, which the child didn't like. She was sent to bed after being unable to eat it, and after going to her small kitchen to get a snack when she was hungry later on, her grandmother got angry.

"[Mother-in-law] heard her, took the food away, threw it out, and brought out the rest of the fish, insisting she finish her dinner if she was hungry," the poster wrote. "Our daughter started crying and, while trying to eat, threw up at the table...

"To make matters worse, I discovered the next morning that [mother-in-law] had unplugged our daughter's fridge and put it outside. It rained heavily overnight, and the fridge was completely ruined...she brushed it off, saying it was for our daughter's own good and that she didn't need a fridge."

The poster was livid about what she described as her mother-in-law overstepping her boundaries. She told her mother-in-law that she would not be welcome to stay with them if she could not respect these boundaries, and, as a final act, sent her a receipt for the ruined refrigerator.

Reddit users cheered. "Why do some grandparents think they have the right to demand respect when they don't respect their adults' kids and their partners' parenting choices and decision?" one person wrote. "She isn't the parent here. You and your husband are."

'Avoids the Conversation'

Melissa Klass, a licensed psychotherapist in California, told Newsweek about how the situation can move forward from here and the dynamics at play.

"Parenting evolves significantly from generation to generation often leaving a large gap in understanding and approach," Klass said. "If parents from former generations (grandparents) are unconscious about their own parenting and parenting style (how they were raised and how they raised their own kids) it often leaks out in the way described in this article."

Klass said grandparents can hold subconscious beliefs that their parenting style was good because they see their adult children who have turned out OK. This isn't always the case, though—Klass described the difference between an "authoritarian" parenting style, which it seems the mother-in-law subscribes to, and an "authoritative" parenting style, which the parents seem to embody.

"Authoritarian parents tend to expect obedience and might punish children instead of assisting them to find solutions," Klass said. "Authoritative parents, on the other hand, offer emotional support and utilize logical consequences to enable children to learn. Children raised by authoritative parents often have better mental health in adulthood."

Moving forward, Klass said that the poster made her expectations known to her mother-in-law, which was a good first step. It might have been helpful to share more about her beliefs about intuitive eating to provide more context to the mother-in-law, she added. As for the aftermath, Klass said it was reasonable to take some distance—but the receipt may not have been the best move.

"I don't love sending the receipt," she said. "That avoids the conversation that needs to take place and sends what message exactly? The mother's displeasure was already known to the [mother-in-law], sending the receipt feels somewhat passive aggressive and has no clear purpose or meaning."

Despite the lapses in communication, Klass said the OP's approach to food was admirable.

"The mother's approach to food is excellent. Kids are born knowing when to eat and when to stop. When well-meaning parents and other adults interfere with that, we train children to stop listening to their bodies and start to rely on external cues about hunger and satiety," she said.

Newsweek reached out to u/Vast-Cartographer588 for comment via Reddit.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines