
...

By Robert Alexander
Senior Crime & Court Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A Brooklyn woman is seeking $65 million in damages in a federal civil rights lawsuit that alleges she was falsely arrested inside the Target store at Kings Plaza and publicly humiliated before being detained for hours at a local precinct.
The complaint, filed October 1 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York, names the city of New York, the New York City Police Department, NYPD officers, Target Corporation and a Target “asset-protection” employee as defendants.
Newsweek contacted the NYPD and the city of New York for comment via email on Friday outside normal office hours.
Read More on U.S.
Why It Matters
The case tests the handoff between private retail security and police in New York, raising questions about how much independent verification officers must do before making an arrest triggered by a store accusation and how far a retailer’s “shopkeeper’s privilege” reasonably extends.
By alleging municipal training and policy failure, the suit could force discovery into NYPD practices and clarify city liability under Monell v. Department of Social Services (1978). The key Supreme Court case said cities could not automatically be held responsible for officers’ misconduct, and the plaintiff must prove the harm came from an official policy, practice or failure to train. The case also spotlights reputational harm from public detentions and the role of body-worn and in-store cameras in quickly resolving alleged thefts.
With a $65 million demand against both a Fortune 500 retailer and the city, the case’s outcome could shape arrest protocols, asset-protection training and taxpayer exposure.

...
What To Know
According to the complaint, the incident occurred on October 3, 2024, at Target’s Kings Plaza store in Brooklyn.
It said Angel Tepizila, a 22-year-old Hunter College student who has worked as a Target “guest advocate” since June 2022, accused plaintiff Sheila Lee of an unspecified wrongdoing and called the NYPD.
Officers then handcuffed Lee and transported her to the 63rd Precinct.
Lee said that while she was “lawfully and peacefully” inside the store, Target and Tepizila “wrongfully accosted, kidnapped, assaulted, battered, detained, arrested, [and] imprisoned” her. They then allegedly “importuned the NYPD” to arrest her, leading to her being handcuffed “in the open presence of the general public.”
According to his LinkedIn profile, Tepizila’s duties include assisting guests at registers or self-checkout, answering questions at the service desk, and completing order pickups.
Lee said the arrest and prosecution were based on “falsified information” attributed to the retailer.
The complaint said she was processed and held “for many hours,” despite her pleas and physical evidence she said showed her innocence.
The charges were “dismissed in her favor” on December 10, 2024, the filing said.
The suit lists as defendants the city of New York; the New York City Police Department; NYPD Detective Specialist Timi Tomacruz and Sergeant Mohammed Rahim, who were assigned to the 63rd Precinct; Target Corporation (including “Target Corporation d/b/a Target Stores”); the Target store at 5100 Kings Plaza; and Tepizila, who was described as a Target asset-protection/security employee.
Damages Claim of $65 million
The complaint pleads federal claims—asserting violations of the Fourth, Sixth and 14th Amendments—and state-law claims that include false arrest, malicious prosecution, assault and battery, defamation, and negligent and intentional infliction of emotional distress.
In an exclusive interview with Newsweek, Philip J. Dinhofer, Lee’s attorney, explained how the claim was apportioned.
“It’s the sum total of the $3 million compensatory and $10 million punitive damages allocated to each cause of action. $13 million times five causes of action equals $65 million.”
The suit also asserts a discrimination claim under New York executive law.
“Body-worn camera and/or in-store surveillance recordings, those would be items in the possession of the defendants. We shall see what they come forward with, if anything,” Dinhofer said.
Training and Policy Failures
Beyond the individual incident, the lawsuit alleges broader training and policy failures at the city and NYPD.
The complaint said police were “improperly educated and/or trained,” alleging that a “written or unwritten policy” gave retailers such as Target “preferential police consideration”—including allowing supervisors to “‘rubber stamp’ paperwork” authorizing arrests and prosecutions “without first conducting their own independent investigation.”
Public records show that the two NYPD officers involved in the case have a history of complaints against them. Rahim, whose service began in 2015, has three complaints and one lawsuit listed. Tomacruz, whose service began in 2008, has four complaints against him. He was previously placed on “dismissal probation for a year” in 2020 over a firearm incident.
The filing said Target secured and controlled the Kings Plaza premises. It alleged that the retailer and its employee asked police to arrest Lee and that statements made about her were defamatory and contributed to embarrassment and reputational harm.
Lee said she suffered “severe injuries, physical and emotional pain and suffering,” loss of reputation, “humiliation and mental anguish,” and a deprivation of her constitutional rights.
What People Are Saying
Philip J. Dinhofer, the attorney for plaintiff Sheila Lee, told Newsweek: “In the U.S., loss of liberty of its own is a very serious injury.”
He added: “It is not my intent, nor my client’s desire, to publicly broadcast this case beyond that necessary at this time. ... I work in a courtroom where the process from inception through trial is all a series of controlled exercises. I prefer to stick with that.”
What Happens Next
The lawsuit’s allegations are unproved, and no court has made findings on the merits. The plaintiff has 90 days from October 1 to serve each defendant. After service, defendants typically have 21 days to answer or move to dismiss (60 if they waive service). Likely proceedings include early motions targeting the NYPD as a non-suable entity, challenges to the Monell policy claims against the city, qualified immunity defenses for individual officers, and shopkeeper’s privilege and defamation challenges from Target.
If any claims survive, the case will move into discovery—exchanging store video, body-worn camera footage, arrest paperwork and Target-NYPD communications—with possible requests to bifurcate policy discovery to narrow scope. Courts often nudge parties toward settlement talks or mediation once key evidence is exchanged. Otherwise, the case proceeds to summary judgment and, if needed, trial on liability and damages.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines