10
Loading video...
By Heather Hall
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Companies are racing to adopt AI, but too many are measuring the wrong thing: whether people are using the tools, rather than whether the business is actually getting better. Boards and executives should demand evidence that AI improves productivity, strengthens judgment, preserves institutional knowledge, and creates measurable financial value, not simply evidence that employees are logging in.
This matters far beyond technology departments. AI is already changing how people work, how customers interact with companies, and how leaders allocate capital. According to Boston Consulting Group (BCG), 50 to 55 percent of U.S. jobs could be reshaped by AI within the next two to three years, while 10 to 15 percent could potentially be eliminated over the longer term. The central business question is not whether work will change. It is whether companies will manage that change intelligently.
Measure AI Value
I worry that many are starting at the wrong end. Leaders buy a tool because AI is fashionable, then ask employees to find something to do with it. That is backwards. AI should begin with a business problem, a baseline, and a definition of success.
Read More on Leadership Insights
The distinction is critical because automating a task does not automatically improve a business. Saving five hours is meaningless if those hours simply disappear into more meetings. A faster report is not valuable if it contains more errors. And reducing headcount based on expected productivity gains can destroy institutional knowledge before those gains ever materialize.

...
I have seen AI work beautifully when it is treated as a thought partner rather than an oracle. In financial modeling, for example, I want humans to build the core model, understand the assumptions, and challenge the business logic.
AI can then help test formulas, incorporate complex updates, summarize changes, and accelerate iteration. The technology makes the work faster; human judgment makes it useful.
That human element is becoming more important, not less. As BCG’s research shows, many jobs are likely to be reshaped rather than eliminated. The opportunity is to move people away from repetitive, reactive work and toward judgment, creativity, relationships, and strategic problem-solving.
Done well, AI can make a workforce more capable. Employees can develop new skills, companies may be able to reduce some future hiring needs, and productivity gains can be reinvested into growth.
Done badly, the opposite happens. Companies celebrate adoption while workflows become fragmented, employees receive inadequate training, multiple tools duplicate each other, and tacit knowledge walks out the door. The organization may look leaner on paper while becoming weaker underneath. That is not transformation. It is hollowing out the business and calling it efficiency.
Track What Matters
Boards and CFOs need a better standard: an AI value scorecard established before implementation and reviewed after deployment. Financial measures should include total cost, revenue impact, margins, cash flow, payback, and return on investment.
Operational measures should include cycle time, error rates, rework, cost per output, and whether AI is embedded in real workflows rather than merely used. Human measures should track training, employee sentiment, retention, skill development, and, most importantly, where the time created by AI actually goes.
Risk and judgment belong on the scorecard, too. Leaders should know how often AI output requires correction, whether decisions are improving, and whether security, compliance, or accuracy problems are emerging. These are not secondary concerns. They affect profitability, customer trust, succession planning, and long-term enterprise value.
Keep Humans in the Loop
The opportunity is clear. AI can remove drudgery, give employees more time for strategic work, improve processes, and turn productivity gains into growth. But the consequences of getting it wrong are equally serious. Businesses can chase adoption numbers, cut costs prematurely, lose critical expertise, and become more dependent on systems they do not properly understand or evaluate.
Boards and executives must stop treating AI adoption as the finish line. Before approving a major AI investment, establish the baseline, define the business outcome, assign measurable financial and operational targets, and decide how human impact will be tracked. Then automate the dashboard and review the results regularly.
Remember that AI does not create value merely because it is used. It creates value when people use it to build a better business.
Heather Hall, CPA and CGMA, is founder of Sapphire CFO Solutions, where she advises companies and boards on financial strategy, governance, operational growth and technology investment.
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines