
...

By Anna Rahmanan
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
When New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani appeared in a video on November 3 discussing men's health and a $4 million investment in prostate cancer care, viewers could perhaps be forgiven for finding themselves distracted by something they couldn't quite put their finger on.
It was, rather unexpectedly, his mustache.
The mayor had first unveiled it two days earlier, having dispensed with the neatly trimmed beard that had become part of his familiar appearance. In its place sat a rather solitary strip of hair, looking almost theatrical, reminding of silent-film villains or perhaps a young Charlie Chaplin experimenting with a different cut.
Read More on Analysis
At the risk of spending too much time examining the precise geography of Mr. Mamdani's upper lip, the mayor is perfectly entitled to wear whatever facial hair he pleases. Especially since he has explained that it is for Movember, the annual campaign promoting men's health.
For those wondering how growing a mustache helps fight cancer, Movember's explanation is that an unusual appearance attracts attention, starts conversations and encourages donations. Judging by the attention Mamdani's mustache has received, the first part seems to be working.

...
The reactions suggest that a mustache can be almost anything its audience wants it to be.
Some admirers on Instagram thought Mamdani was pulling off the new look. Others were less impressed. One commenter thought he looked like "Super Mario in disguise," while another offered a more local comparison: "He looks like the guy selling kebabs outside Shay Stadium."
Others reached for Western pop culture, while critics went considerably further. After Mamdani appeared in a November 16 video, some compared him to Saddam Hussein. Conservative commentator Will Chamberlain even suggested the mustache was an attempt to evoke Iraq's former Baathist rulers and deflect accusations of Islamism.
Quite a range of associations for a mustache grown to promote men's health.
But the mustache is even more interesting than that, because for all its apparent frivolity, the small patch of facial hair has a surprisingly serious political history.
When Mustaches Became Symbols of Revolution
Consider the Ottoman Empire, where facial hair once helped distinguish an emerging political generation from the establishment it sought to replace.
Related Story

Trump Wants His Great Power Legacy—There’s Nothing America Can Do About It
Related Story

The TSA’s 25-Year Airport Security Charade
Related Story

Mamdani’s New York Has a Plan for Police Violence. What About Rioters?
Avner Wishnitzer, a professor of Middle Eastern history at Tel Aviv University and author of the 2018 study Beneath the Mustache, explained to Newsweek that beards had traditionally represented maturity, religious devotion and patriarchal authority.
The younger officers, journalists, teachers and civil servants who challenged the old order increasingly favored mustaches.
"Before the revolution, a mustache could mark a younger man as distinct from the bearded world of established, patriarchal authority associated with the Hamidian order," Wishnitzer said.
Following the revolution of 1908, these men advanced through the Ottoman establishment. Their preferred facial hair accompanied them.
Even the imperial palace eventually followed suit.
Wishnitzer noted that Sultan Mehmed V appeared wearing only a mustache, departing from the bearded tradition of Ottoman rulers. His successor, Mehmed VI, also wore one.
A style associated with ambitious young reformers had become fashionable at the very summit of imperial power.
Wishnitzer cautioned that he knows nothing about Mamdani's mustache and sees no reason to connect the mayor's personal grooming decisions to Ottoman history. Although the comparison is historical rather than an explanation of Mamdani's intentions, the history offers an intriguing example of how an ordinary grooming preference can acquire political significance.
When the Wrong Mustache Could Be Dangerous
In modern Turkey, the symbolism became considerably more explicit.
During the ideological conflicts of the 1970s, different political factions developed recognizable mustache styles.
Ultranationalists favored long, downward-curving mustaches, sometimes interpreted as resembling the letter M for milliyetçi, meaning nationalist. Leftists preferred fuller styles, while religious conservatives tended toward closely trimmed mustaches.
These distinctions could have serious consequences during a period of violent political confrontation.
Decades later, Turkish bureaucrats were reportedly shaving off their distinctive almond-shaped mustaches—worn by President Recep Tayyip Erdogan—following the ruling party's electoral setback in June 2015.
The apparent calculation was straightforward: when political fortunes change, looking like the previous establishment may become inconvenient.
What Voters See in Facial Hair
There is also evidence that facial hair affects political judgments even when no ideological message is intended.
A study of U.S. congressional candidates found that participants perceived politicians with facial hair as more masculine and less supportive of feminist positions. Yet researchers found no corresponding difference in their actual legislative voting records.

...
Another study published in Economics & Politics found that Australian participants evaluating unfamiliar Swiss politicians associated masculine appearance, including facial hair, with lower honesty and competence.
Such findings offer evidence of appearance-based judgments, although neither study establishes how voters interpret Mamdani's particular mustache.
Pierce Dignam, an assistant professor of sociology at the University of Central Florida who studies masculinity and political identity, told Newsweek that appearance can help communicate membership in a political movement.
"Being able to conform to group norms regarding appearance makes it easier to show your outward conformity to a movement," he said.
He also pointed to the importance of politicians' personal presentation in shaping public perceptions.
Mamdani has given a perfectly straightforward explanation for his mustache: he grew it for Movember, to raise awareness of men's health and there is no evidence that he intended to make any broader political statement. But as the history of facial hair suggests, politicians do not necessarily get to decide what their appearance communicates. A mustache can acquire associations its wearer never intended, and Mamdani's explanation, however sincere, cannot determine how others interpret it.
History suggests its political meaning, if it acquires one, will depend as much on the people looking at it as the man wearing it.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines