
...

By Jesus Mesa
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
When Zohran Mamdani walked onto a small stage in Long Island City Tuesday night to declare victory in the New York City Democratic mayoral primary, few in the political establishment expected him to be there. Fewer still grasped the full message his win delivered.
The 33-year-old state assemblyman, who began his campaign for mayor polling in single digits, stunned the Democratic hierarchy by toppling former Governor Andrew Cuomo in a high-turnout primary that redrew the city's political map.
Mamdani's insurgent campaign — backed by grassroots activists and first-time voters — overcame tens of millions in spending from Cuomo-aligned super PACs, endorsements from national Democratic figures, and an editorial nod from The New York Times.
Read More on Politics
"This wasn't just a local upset," said Joseph Geevarghese, executive director of Our Revolution, the progressive grassroots group that backed Mamdani's campaign. "It was a national referendum on the direction of the Democratic Party."
Mamdani surged to victory despite having virtually no name recognition or institutional support within the Democratic party. His win came on historically high turnout for a New York primary and drew immediate comparisons to Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's own upset of a longtime incumbent in 2018.
For some political experts, Mamdani's win sent a clear message to the party's old guard that people are unhappy with the current direction of the Democratic Party. Polling analyst Nate Silver called Mamdani's performance "a thorough ass-whooping" in a post-election dispatch on his Silver Bulletin Substack.
"Zohran thoroughly earned the win, and Cuomo and the Democratic establishment thoroughly earned the loss," he wrote.
Warning Calls for Schumer?

...
Mamdani's win wasn't just a blow to Andrew Cuomo — it was a boost for Ocasio-Cortez. She backed him early, framed the race as a referendum on the party's direction, and rallied her base around his campaign. The result reinforced her role as a national progressive leader and positioned her at the center of a growing rebellion against the Democratic establishment.
"AOC really set that model, making it easier to imagine someone like Zohran actually pulling this off," said Democratic strategist Kaivan Shroff. "She gave people hope that this kind of win is possible — and it's happened before."
While some — including Nate Silver — consider Ocasio-Cortez the most likely Democrat to lead the 2028 presidential ticket, others argue her next move could be closer to home: challenging Minority Leader Chuck Schumer's long-held Senate seat in New York.
"The big loser tonight isn't Andrew Cuomo. It's @ChuckSchumer," wrote Frank Luntz, the pollster, on X. "Grassroot Democrats are demanding a more ideological, confrontational approach to policy and politics. If @AOC has the guts to challenge the Senate Minority Leader, she will win the Democratic primary and Schumer will lose. ...And he doesn't get it."
A recent poll from the Honan Strategy Group suggests trouble ahead for Schumer. In a hypothetical 2028 Democratic primary, Ocasio-Cortez leads him by 21 points — 54 percent to 33 percent — among likely Democratic voters in New York City. She also holds a double-digit edge among Jewish Democrats, a bloc that has long anchored Schumer's political base.
For his part, Schumer appeared to acknowledge Mamdani's momentum with a conciliatory post on X the day after the election.
But party tensions are deepening. Schumer, the highest-ranking Jewish elected official in U.S. history, has come under fire from both progressives and mainstream Democrats. In March, his decision to back a Republican-led government funding bill to avert a shutdown provoked backlash within his own ranks. Only nine Democrats supported the measure, which some described as appeasement of the new Trump administration.
Criticism of Schumer now cuts across the party spectrum. Leaders including Hakeem Jeffries, Nancy Pelosi, and James Clyburn were said to privately express dissatisfaction with how Schumer handled the negotiations.
The situation has become serious enough that the push for Ocasio-Cortez to challenge Schumer now has support from both centrists and progressives, according to CNN. Several House Democrats — including members of the Congressional Progressive Caucus — reportedly urged her to run during a caucus policy retreat, with one lawmaker speaking to her directly about the idea.
Lessons for a Party in Crisis

...
For a Democratic Party still licking its 2024 wounds, the results in New York City are more than a fluke — they represent a cautionary tale for incumbents everywhere. The loss of a candidate backed by major unions, the Clintons, and Times editorial board underscores the risks of relying on institutional muscle to win races that increasingly hinge on authenticity and trust. (The Times did not explicitly endorse Cuomo, as it no longer makes endorsements in local elections, but wrote: "We do not believe Mr. Mamdani deserves a spot on New Yorkers' ballots...As for Mr. Cuomo, we have serious objections to his ethics and conduct, even if he would be better for New York's future")
"Mamdani was the only candidate laser-focused on local issues like housing affordability and fixing the city's struggling schools," Max Burns, a Democratic strategist, told Newsweek. "In a race where most candidates focused on fighting Trump, Mamdani was one of the only people actually talking to New Yorkers about fixing the city's problems and making their lives easier."
Burns pointed to the party's struggle to energize its base as a growing liability. "The lesson of 2024 is that candidates who can't build a movement can't win. Mamdani didn't just build one — he built it despite every structural disadvantage thrown at him."
Still, voices inside the party urge caution before reading Mamdani's win as a blueprint. "He's inspired a lot of people, and that's undeniable," said Shroff, the strategist. "But do I think he's the future of the Democratic Party? Distinctly not."
Shroff emphasized that the debate within the party does not have to be a binary between outdated leadership and inexperienced activism. "It's constantly framed as either we have someone like Chuck Schumer tweeting Taylor Swift lyrics, which doesn't connect, or someone like Mamdani running on viral videos and no experience," he said. "That's a false choice."
Josh Lafazan, a former New York state legislator and political analyst, was more direct in his critique. "Candidates like Mamdani can win primaries," he told Newsweek, "but if they want to govern, they'll have to earn the trust of centrist voters who actually decide general elections."
For Shroff, the moment demands Democrats get back to their roots as the "big tent" party.
"There are young leaders who are both policy-ready and authentic," he said. "The party doesn't have to choose between experience and excitement. It needs both."
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines