Mark Zuckerberg attends the 2025 Breakthrough Prize Ceremony at Barker Hangar in Santa Monica, California, on April 5, 2025.

...

Newsweek Editors

By Newsweek Editors

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Mark Zuckerberg will take the witness stand later today in a landmark trial that could help shape the future of social media regulation in America.

The lawsuit alleges that Instagram contributed to a young woman’s depression and suicidal thoughts. The courtroom is expected to include grieving families who believe social platforms played a role in their children’s suffering. Meta's CEO will face tough questions from attorneys representing the now 20-year-old woman, identified in court as KGM.

The stakes are enormous—not just for Meta, but for Silicon Valley as a whole. The case is one of several bellwether trials that could influence thousands of similar lawsuits.

Read More on Analysis

The scrutiny of tech companies is warranted. But amid the focus on corporate accountability, an uncomfortable question lingers: When did we decide that Mark Zuckerberg was responsible for raising our children?

Designed to Hook

Meta should not be absolved. Social media platforms are not passive tools; they are highly engineered products built to capture and keep attention. Infinite scroll removes natural stopping points. Algorithmic recommendation systems learn users' preferences and vulnerabilities. Appearance-altering filters reshape faces and bodies with a swipe.

These features are not accidental. They are refined through data, testing and behavioral research to maximize engagement. When those systems are placed in the hands of adolescents—whose impulse control, emotional regulation and self-image are still developing—it raises serious ethical questions.

Plaintiffs argue these features were engineered to maximize engagement in ways that harmed vulnerable teens, claims Meta disputes.

If companies knowingly design tools that amplify comparison, reward compulsive use or push vulnerable teens toward harmful content, that is a serious matter. It is not merely a public relations issue; it is a question of corporate responsibility.

The issue isn’t whether social media influences behavior. It clearly does. The real debate is how much responsibility corporations bear when influence becomes dependency—and when engagement strategies may deepen anxiety, depression or self-harm.

Instagram Is Not a Parent

Teen mental health struggles rarely have a single cause. Defense attorneys in this case have pointed to evidence of turbulence at home and preexisting psychological challenges. That does not erase the potential harms of social media. But it underscores a basic truth: Instagram is not a parent, a guardian or a primary caregiver. It is an app.

Zuckerberg's testimony comes a week after that of Adam Mosseri, the head of Instagram, who said in the courtroom that he disagrees with the idea that people can be clinically addicted to social media platforms. Mosseri maintained that Instagram works hard to protect young people using the service, and said it's "not good for the company, over the long run, to make decisions that profit for us but are poor for people’s well-being."

For years, parents have handed smartphones to children, often with minimal or zero guardrails. Many have allowed unrestricted access to platforms whose business models are plainly visible. Age limits are routinely ignored. Bedroom screen use is normalized. Conversations about digital boundaries are often reactive rather than proactive.

It is easier to blame a corporation than to confront the broader cultural shift that has made constant connectivity a big part of growing up for many children.

Age Limits and Protections for Young Users

Governments around the world are stepping in as concerns about youth mental health and online safety grow.

Australia has moved to ban social media access for children under 16, requiring platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and YouTube to remove underage accounts. In Europe, several countries are pursuing similar paths. France has passed legislation banning social media for those under 15 and strengthening age verification requirements. Spain is considering restrictions for under-16s and investigating harmful content involving minors. Denmark is weighing prohibitions for younger teens, while countries including the U.K., Italy and Norway are debating tighter consent rules and stronger protections.

In the United States, some states are experimenting with limits. Virginia has introduced a one-hour daily cap on children’s social media use, though such measures face legal challenges.

Importance of engaged parenting

Stronger youth protections, clearer age verification and design reforms are legitimate policy debates. But no jury verdict can substitute for engaged parenting. Courts cannot enforce bedtime screen limits. Judges cannot require family conversations about self-worth, comparison and online pressure. Congress cannot monitor what happens behind a closed bedroom door at midnight.

There is a risk in outsourcing moral responsibility to Silicon Valley. If society convinces itself that removing certain features or awarding damages will solve the youth mental health crisis, it may overlook deeper questions about supervision, resilience and accountability at home.

Zuckerberg will answer questions under oath. He should. Companies with enormous influence over young lives deserve scrutiny.

But he is not your child's parent.

If this trial becomes solely about corporate blame, we will miss the harder truth: protecting children in the digital age requires more than regulation. It requires parents willing to set boundaries, pay attention and actively engage with the world their children inhabit: a very different world from the one in which they were raised.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines