
...

By Ryan Bort
Reporter
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
"I'm just here to see you," George Clooney said before turning to the audience. "And I think that's what everybody else is here for too."
Then the very lucky crowd inside the newly renovated Ed Sullivan Theater began chanting something we've all heard countless times, just never on network television:
"STE-PHEN! STE-PHEN! STE-PHEN! STE-PHEN! STE-PHEN!"
Read More on Entertainment
This was it. The culmination of nine months of preparation. Stephen Colbert was finally, officially, the host of the Late Show, and he was making sure to bask in this moment because the excitement would probably never be this high again. George freakin' Clooney was effectively genuflecting to his mere presence behind a desk, and people were cheering his name in time. This hasn't happened to many people. Maybe to Bill Murray at some point, but that's probably about it.
Colbert's first Late Show was a huge success, because of course it was. Because what else did you expect? The man has never appeared to be even slightly uncomfortable at any point in his public life—apparently the result of Colbert not only having no fear of bombing onstage but actively loving it, just as he actively loves everything, as we learned in Joel Lovell's heartwarming profile for GQ (if you haven't read it, do so). Colbert was made to entertain, and this was his ultimate stage, designed especially for him. At the start of the show, he and new Late Show bandleader Jon Batiste danced together joyously, which they did again as the show ended, that time surrounded by Mavis Staples, Buddy Guy and a handful of other esteemed musicians celebrating Colbert and his new gig.

...
There was also a middle to the show, which featured Clooney and an adequately energized Jeb Bush. What most people have been curious about in the run-up to the premiere, though, is what the rest of Colbert's Late Show, outside of the guests and music, would look like. There was the crucial issue of whether Colbert would survive in the spotlight without the support of the "Stephen Colbert" character he played for nine years on Comedy Central. For anyone who studied Colbert on The Colbert Report, this was a silly thing to wonder, despite how often the media has beaten it into the ground since he was announced as Letterman's successor. It wasn't hard to discern Colbert's genuine intelligence, wit, enthusiasm and timing behind his bombastic pundit artifice. He was the real deal, and it's hard to believe now that anyone really doubted he could pull off an 11:30 network spot.
But the most pleasant surprise of Colbert's Late Show debut was probably how much of the Comedy Central "Colbert" remained. Instead of a traditional monologue, Colbert gave only a brief standing introduction of the night's guests, along with a few easy setup–punch line jokes, before taking his place behind the desk—which, as he noted, was "carved from a single piece of desk."
After a little more riffing and a commercial break, it was comforting to see him stare into the camera and mention the crowded race for the Republican presidential nomination. A very Colbert Report–esque graphic then appeared to the left of his head, just like old times. As it was for Jon Stewart, performing in this format had been Colbert's bread and butter for years, so why not carry it over to CBS? And cued next to his head last night were—what else?—clips of Donald Trump acting ridiculous, which Colbert feigned an urge to resist covering (he simultaneously binged on Oreos as his metaphor-of-choice), similar to what Stewart did after the great orange bloviator announced his candidacy.
It was hard to tell where "Colbert" the pundit ended and where Colbert the dapper late-night host began. It wasn't entirely clear that he was sure either. But it didn't matter because it was hilarious and, secretly, exactly what everyone wanted. We've got another 14 months of Colbert behind a desk ripping on presidential candidates, people. For anyone going through Jon Stewart withdrawal, this will get you through the winter.
Of all the aforementioned Colbert traits—his intelligence, his wit, his enthusiasm, his timing, his eyebrow arch (didn't mention this earlier but still important)—the one that might have always stood out the most was his wit, and how quick it was. Combine this with his uncommon intelligence and genuine curiosity, his plain-to-see desire to have his questions answered to his satisfaction, and you get a truly remarkable interviewer. This is what I have been most excited to see Colbert take to the Late Show, and with unconventional guests like Elon Musk, Uber's Travis Kalanick and Stephen King stopping by this week alone, it looked like he was putting real thought into this portion of the show. Could Colbert actually bring some much-needed substance to the painfully vapid late-night interview landscape?
If we're going by last night's premiere, not really; or, at least, we'll see. His interview with Clooney was all smiles and congratulations, but it was his interview with Bush, whom most feel Colbert could intellectually dismantle with little effort, that everyone was tuning in for. Colbert initially wanted Trump to be his first guest, but the GOP front-runner turned down the invitation in favor of an appearance next to the much more benign and risk-free Jimmy Fallon (who made a cameo early in the show and whom Colbert has insisted he is not competing against). Then he offered the spot to Hillary Clinton, who also turned him down for Fallon. Ratings and demographic reach might have had something to do with both of these declined invitations, but on the surface it looked like Trump and Clinton were afraid Colbert might make them look like stupid somehow, whereas there was absolutely zero chance Fallon would humiliate them with political nuance.
So what did Colbert have in store for Bush? Not much. A few softball questions like why he wants to be president and how he is different from his brother. There was plenty of smiling and no challenging rebuttals. Bush actually came out looking pretty good.
But then again, there probably wasn't going to be much of a cross-examination because this was, after all, Colbert's first show, and he was, after all, on network TV now. Colbert can't be as subversive as he was on Comedy Central by design. On CBS, everything must be clean, presentable and, most of all, devoid of controversy. If he slips up, network head Les Moonves is sitting there with his hand on a lever ready to switch the feed to a rerun of The Mentalist. (Moonves actually was in the front row with his hand on an actual lever, ready to switch the broadcast to The Mentalist if he was displeased with Colbert's performance. It was a funny bit.)
Despite the tame interaction with Bush, in the long run it's hard to believe Colbert's ability to challenge and disarm his guests isn't going to find some way to manifest itself, because it's too strong to suppress. The first thing Colbert did when he sat behind his desk last night was to thank the man who came before him, David Letterman. He said, with a smile on his face, that like Letterman, he would probably piss off the network eventually (which was the setup for the Moonves/Mentalist bit) and that he could never truly fill the icon's shoes. As he settles into his new role, at times he might very well be a little too smart or too combative or too out-there for the network's taste. Last night, though, it was all about the man behind the desk dancing and smiling and presenting himself to the world. The Late Show With Stephen Colbert has arrived. It's time to party.
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines