Anti-ICE protesters in downtown Minneapolis on January 27, 2026.

...

Newsweek Editors

By Newsweek Editors

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Shortly after Alex Pretti was shot dead amid anti-ICE fury in Minnesota, national Democrats and others began saying the quiet part out loud: "It’s time to abolish Trump’s ICE," declared Illinois Governor JB Pritzker, with many others echoing that call and funding set to play a part in shutdown debates.

The blueprint they may want to follow was released today by the Center for American Progress—a lodestar for mainstream Democrats. It calls for more local detectives and police, higher clearance rates, and federal help for crime labs and intelligence centers. The report rebukes "U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents who mask their identities and grab people off the street" as "an affront to local policing," while saying the way to reduce violence is to help cities solve more cases, faster, warning that murder clearances have fallen. The plan’s message is not "abolish" or "defund" but "arrest the right people more quickly." It says "the Trump administration has removed effective crime-fighting resources from local communities."

Strangely, the White House says the crime question is already settled. "Under President Donald J. Trump’s leadership, America is safer than it has been in over a century," it said last week, touting a murder rate "at its lowest level since at least 1900." The Council on Criminal Justice does indeed show homicides down about 21 percent in major cities in 2025 and broad declines in robbery, gun assaults and carjackings.

Read More on News

If this is a battleground Democrats or others want to exploit, are they looking in the right places?

Common Knowledge

The left’s line hardened after the Minneapolis shooting. "ICE is a rogue, violent agency… There is no reforming this lawless agency… We must abolish ICE," said Representative Ayanna Pressley, who also moved to strip ICE agents of qualified-immunity protections. And Representative Rashida Tlaib’s office has for years argued that "ICE needs to get out of our neighborhoods now."

On the right, the message is triumphalist, even when it comes to ICE raids more generally. "Murder rate plunges to 125-year low as President Trump restores law and order," the White House said, attributing the drop to a federal crackdown on "savage criminal illegal aliens" and deployments of the National Guard in blue cities.

Some right-leaning analysts sound a note of caution. "Crime is down, but so are arrests," wrote criminologist Barry Latzer in National Review last year—warning that fewer arrests may paper over unresolved violence. And outside the partisan scrum, Adam Gelb of the Council on Criminal Justice told Time: "We see very confident claims of credit in abundance, but scarce hard evidence to back them up."

Uncommon Knowledge

America’s homicide count can plunge while justice for victims still stalls. The FBI’s 2024 report shows just 15.9 percent of property crimes were cleared and less than half of violent offenses resulted in an arrest or exceptional clearance; the Center for American Progress puts the violent-crime clearance share at about 44 percent, with murder clearances down to 61 percent in 2024 from 72 percent in 1980. Even in a "safer" year, many victims never see a culprit charged. That is the gulf its report is trying to close—and it is a very different crusade from abolishing an entire federal agency.

The larger backdrop is complicated. The homicide drop is real. Major-city data compiled by the Council on Criminal Justice show 2025 homicides down 21 percent, robberies down 23 percent, carjackings down 43 percent, and motor-vehicle theft down 27 percent from 2024. However, the declines began before Trump’s second term and likely reflect multiple forces: the post-pandemic restoration of local services, better technology (from cameras to real-time crime centers), and targeted policing.

What, then, actually cuts violence? Contrary to slogans on both sides, the weight of research suggests policing works—if done right. A leading 2021 multicity study Penn criminologist Aaron Chalfin and others found that each additional 10–17 officers hired prevents roughly one homicide per year, with the benefits largest for Black victims. The same report warns that indiscriminate low-level arrests can impose real harms. That is why the Center for American Progress blueprint features more detectives, crime-lab capacity, and real-time crime centers.

Immigration enforcement is the third rail. After Pretti’s killing, elected Democrats from the Squad to Midwestern governors explicitly called to abolish ICE. But even if one accepts the White House’s premise that deporting "the worst of the worst" reduces crime, that claim does little to solve local shootings and robberies when assailants aren’t in federal custody and cases languish. Federal crackdowns may worsen distrust and complicate local casework, and Trump has already promised to "de-escalate a little bit" in Minnesota.

So, has Trump "made America safe again”? The data shows America has indeed got safer again, even as many crimes are not being solved. What abolishing ICE will not do is fundamentally change either of these talking points.


If you’re enjoying Uncommon Knowledge, please share. If you have suggestions for future editions or feedback, email subscriber.feedback@newsweek.com. We want to hear your voice.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines