Sonam Sheth

By Sonam Sheth

Evening Politics Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


On Tuesday, President Donald Trump warmly shook Chief Justice John Roberts' hand as he prepared to deliver a speech to a joint session of Congress.

"Thank you again," Trump was heard saying in a hot mic moment that's since gone viral. "Won't forget it."

Hours later, Roberts and Justice Amy Coney Barrett—who was nominated by Trump during his first term in the White House—joined the High Court's liberal contingent to deliver Trump a notable setback, thwarting his efforts to freeze $2 billion in foreign aid and halting, at least in part, his crusade to make drastic budget cuts.

Read More on Politics

It was the second time since Trump took office in January that the High Court, which has a 6-3 conservative majority, reined in the administration's efforts to dramatically expand the scope of executive power.

Last month, the Supreme Court declined to grant Trump's request to immediately fire the head of the Office of Special Counsel, saying it would not interfere with a temporary order from a lower court that temporarily left him in place.

Amy Coney Barrett John Roberts

...

The court issued its decision in an unsigned order. Four justices—liberals Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson and conservatives Neil Gorsuch and Samuel Alito—dissented.

Roberts and Barrett did not disclose their votes, but they also didn't join Gorsuch's written dissent.

A U.S. appeals court ultimately sided with the president, ruling this week that Trump could fire Hampton Dellinger, the special counsel.

The Supreme Court's refusal to immediately grant Trump's request combined with its ruling ordering him to unfreeze the foreign aid this week indicates Barrett and Roberts are, at least to some extent, willing to side against Trump in legal challenges.

"In both of the rulings the court has handed down so far, we've seen the justices step quite gingerly—but, in both cases, in ways that have not given the Trump administration what it's asked for," Steve Vladeck, a professor at Georgetown University Law Center, told CNN about the rulings.

Payvan Ahdout, a law professor at the University of Virginia, told the New York Times that Wednesday's ruling indicated the court is "open to a role for judicial review of these decisions," but they "just have not yet reached consensus on what that judicial role is."

She added that Barrett "seems like she is not coming into these disputes already subscribing to a philosophy that closes the door to reasonable limits on the presidential power."

Roberts and Barrett also delivered a blow to Trump earlier this year, before he took office, when they sided with the court's liberal wing and scuttled the president's last-ditch effort to halt his sentencing in his New York hush-money case.

"The application for stay presented to Justice Sotomayor and by her referred to the Court is denied," the court said in a brief order. Trump was later sentenced to "unconditional discharge," which means releasing a defendant without punishment or probation. Trump's lawyers are currently appealing his conviction.

The ruling sparked immediate blowback from conservatives and Trump supporters.

Tom Fitton, the president of Judicial Watch, wrote at the time, "Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Amy Coney Barrett joined with their leftist colleagues to allow this unprecedented abuse. The ruling makes no sense..."

Benjamin Weingarten, a senior contributor at The Federalist, echoed Fitton, writing, "Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Barrett strike again! Utterly asinine. That word doesn't even do it justice really."

This was not the first time that the pair of justices were criticized from those on the right. Roberts and Barrett faced conservative scrutiny earlier in Joe Biden's presidency, when they joined the court's liberals in backing the Biden administration in a critical case related to border security.

And during Trump's first term, Roberts cast the deciding vote in a landmark case that upheld the Affordable Care Act, which Trump and his allies had repeatedly tried to gut.

Barrett's role, in particular, as a potential foil on Trump's plans isn't lost on the president's most ardent supporters, many of whom directed their ire toward the conservative justice after Wednesday's ruling on foreign aid.

"Disgraceful," one X user, Paul Szypula, wrote in reaction to the ruling. "Amy Barrett was a bad SCOTUS nominee."

"Looking that way," Charlie Kirk, the founder and CEO of TPUSA and one of Trump's most high-profile backers, wrote in response.

Mike Cernovich, a longtime conservative activist and Trump supporter, amplified a video of Barrett and Trump interacting during his Tuesday address to Congress.

"She is evil, chosen solely because she checked identity politics boxes," Cernovich wrote. "Another DEI hire. It always ends badly."

Newsweek reached out to the Supreme Court for comment via email.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines