
...

By Robert Alexander
Senior Crime & Court Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A federal appeals court has reinstated Federal Trade Commissioner Rebecca Kelly Slaughter after President Donald Trump sought to remove her without cause.
In a 2–1 decision on Tuesday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit upheld a lower-court order restoring Slaughter to her post, citing the Supreme Court's 1935 ruling in Humphrey's Executor v. United States, which recognized statutory protections against the removal of Federal Trade Commission members except for "inefficiency, neglect of duty, or malfeasance in office."
Why It Matters
At the heart of the dispute is whether presidents can unilaterally remove leaders of independent agencies.
Read More on U.S.
The outcome will determine not only the future of Slaughter's tenure at the FTC, but also whether longstanding protections that insulate regulators like the Federal Reserve, the SEC, and the Consumer Product Safety Commission from partisan control remain intact, or whether presidents will gain sweeping new authority to remake those agencies at will.
For nearly a century, the Supreme Court has declined to overturn Humphrey's Executor, reaffirming its limits on presidential removal power in a series of cases, even as it has narrowed them in other contexts.

...
What To Know
In March, Trump dismissed Slaughter, who had been appointed by former President Joe Biden, without providing a reason.
The Trump administration maintained that Congress's limits on removal powers were unconstitutional.
"The Supreme Court has repeatedly upheld the President's constitutional authority to fire and remove executive officers who exercise his authority," White House spokesperson Kush Desai said after the district court initially ruled against Trump in July.
"The Trump Administration will appeal this unlawful decision and looks forward to victory on this issue," he said.
The case illustrates a broader conflict between Trump and independent regulatory bodies. In recent months, courts have considered challenges to Trump's removal of Democratic appointees at agencies including the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) and the Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board.
In June, a federal judge in Maryland ruled that Trump acted unlawfully when he removed three CPSC commissioners without cause. "The Court finds no constitutional defect in the statutory restriction on Plaintiffs' removal and that Plaintiffs' purported removal from office was unlawful," the opinion stated.
Trump has also faced legal challenges for attempting to remove Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook, alleging mortgage fraud—a claim she disputes—which underscores that the FTC case is part of a broader campaign to reshape independent agencies.
Supreme Court Signals
The Supreme Court has already shown interest in similar disputes. In April, Chief Justice John Roberts stayed two district court rulings in unrelated cases that had blocked Trump from removing officials at the National Labor Relations Board and the Merit Systems Protection Board.
That action suggested the justices could revisit Humphrey's Executor, a precedent that has withstood repeated calls for reconsideration but has been narrowed in later rulings.
In Seila Law v. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (2020), for example, the Court struck down tenure protections for the CFPB's single director while leaving Humphrey's Executor formally intact. More recently, in Collins v. Yellen (2021), the Court emphasized that the precedent had not been overruled but declined to extend it beyond multimember commissions.
The legal fight over the FTC echoes earlier courtroom showdowns during Trump's first term, when attorneys like Lee Gelernt of the ACLU led successful lawsuits against high-profile administration policies, including the family separation policy at the border.
The Trump administration argues that the FTC's powers have expanded since 1935, making its commissioners more akin to executive officers who should be subject to presidential control. The appeals court majority rejected that reasoning, finding that "the present-day Commission exercises the same powers that the Court understood it to have in 1935."
Newsweek reached out to Gelernt via email for comment outside of normal office hours on Wednesday.
What People Are Saying
Judges Patricia Millett and Cornelia Pillard, both appointed by former President Barack Obama, wrote in the majority: "To grant a stay would be to defy the Supreme Court's decisions that bind our judgments. That we will not do."
Judge Neomi Rao, appointed by Trump, dissented, arguing that courts "likely" lacked power to reinstate an executive branch official during ongoing litigation. Rao also pointed to recent Supreme Court emergency orders allowing Trump to remove other officials while challenges were pending, underscoring her view that reinstatement intrudes on presidential authority.
She wrote that "an injunction reinstating an officer the President has removed, harms the government by intruding on the President's power and responsibility over the Executive Branch."
What Happens Next
The next step is almost certainly the Supreme Court, where the Trump administration plans to appeal the D.C. Circuit's ruling reinstating Slaughter. Trump may also seek emergency relief to suspend Slaughter's return to the FTC, as the Supreme Court has granted in other recent removal cases.
The justices are likely to view this alongside similar disputes over the Consumer Product Safety Commission and other boards, making it a coordinated test of whether the Humphrey's Executor precedent still shields independent agencies from at-will dismissal.
If the Court sides with Trump, it could greatly expand presidential control; if not, existing protections for regulators would remain in place.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines