
...

By Rachel Dobkin
Weekend Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
John Yoo, a law professor and former clerk for conservative Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas, said on Fox News' Cavuto Live on Saturday morning that Biden's reported plan to change the U.S. Supreme Court would be a "banana republic tactic."
He was referring to a Washington Post report from Tuesday that said Biden was planning to endorse major changes to the Court, such as establishing term limits for the justices and an enforceable ethics code, citing unnamed sources briefed on the plans. The president also is still deciding whether to support a constitutional amendment to eliminate broad immunity for presidents and other top officials.
"It would be sad if President Biden were to end his decades of public service by adopting another banana republic tactic like this," Yoo said.
Read More
Aileen Cannon Took ‘Cue’ From Clarence Thomas—Legal Analyst4 min read

George Conway Trolls Trump for Complaining About People Laughing at Him5 min read

Could Mitt Romney Replace Joe Biden? Suggestion Sparks Fury4 min read

The Context
Biden's reported plans for the Supreme Court come at a time of great tension between the Court and the American public following recent controversial rulings and ethics scandals surrounding some of the conservative justices.
One recent ruling by the Court that had Democrats and Republicans critical of former President Donald Trump up in arms was its presidential immunity decision.
On July 1, the Court ruled in a 6-3 decision that former presidents have immunity for official acts conducted while in office, but not for unofficial acts. The ruling was related to an argument by Trump in the federal election interference case against him.
The DOJ has accused Trump of attempting to overturn Biden's 2020 election victory, but the former president claims that he is immune from prosecution because he was in office when the alleged scheme took place. Trump has pleaded not guilty to all charges against him and claims the case is politically motivated. The former president has continued to repeat false claims that the 2020 election was stolen from him via widespread voter fraud, despite there being no evidence of this.
Meanwhile, Justices Thomas and Samuel Alito have been under fire over ethical concerns stemming from undisclosed gifts and perceived biases in cases involving Trump and attempts to overturn the 2020 election, which both justices have not recused themselves from. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, a New York Democrat, filed articles of impeachment against Thomas and Alito last week. However, they are almost certain to fail in the Republican-controlled House.
What We Know
Yoo talked about the chaos that could ensue if Biden went through with his reported plans to alter the Supreme Court.
"It is not in the American tradition because you disagree with the Supreme Court to start monkeying around with who's on the Court, the number of justices on the Court, changing the configuration of the Court. And it's not just it's gonna set off tit-for-tat retaliation, where each side just responds to the other, but it's a threat to all our individual liberties," Yoo said Saturday.
He continued: "The Court is there as a last resort to protect all of our individual rights against the majority. And if the Court becomes afraid of being attacked in this way every time it renders an unpopular decision, then that last resort is going to be weakened and our Constitutional rights are all going to suffer."
Yoo further explained his position in an email to Newsweek on Saturday afternoon: "I think changing the Supreme Court, such as imposing term limits or adding (or deleting) the number of Justices, will encourage a spiral of tit-for-tat retaliation that will destabilize the Court and undermine the independence of the judiciary."
He continued: "Democrats want to change the structure of the Court because they disagree with its recent decisions on abortion, guns, or presidential immunity. Republicans will respond in kind. Would Democrats have thought it OK for Republicans to have imposed term limits and expanded the number of justices after the Court approved gay marriage, at a time when 60 percent of Americans opposed it? That is what will happen in the future if Biden and his party succeed."
The source of Yoo's statistics on gay marriage opinion is unclear. However, a Pew Research poll from early June 2015, a few weeks before the Court nationally legalized gay marriage in its Obergefell v. Hodges ruling, found that 57 Percent of Americans favored same-sex marriage while 39 percent opposed it.
Newsweek has reached out to the White House via email for comment.
Yoo is a regular contributor to the editorial pages of the Wall Street Journal, New York Times, Washington Post, Los Angeles Times and National Review.
He has also appeared on Fox News on several occasions, including in late May, when he criticized Trump's New York hush money trial, saying that there were "serious legal errors" made.
At the National Conservatism conference in Washington, D.C., last week, Yoo called for Republican district attorneys to prosecute Democrat officials who have, in his opinion, wronged Trump and his allies.
"People who have used this tool against people like [Trump's former lawyer] John [Eastman] or [former] President Trump have to be prosecuted by Republican or conservative DAs in exactly the same way, for exactly the same kinds of things, until they stop," he said, according to a Semafor report.

...
Views
In an op-ed for The Atlantic, titled, "Biden Is Right to Take on the Court," published on Saturday morning, author David Litt, a former speechwriter for ex-President Barack Obama, made the case for why the president should make major changes to the Supreme Court.
"As the Court has become more politicized, its conservative judges have insisted that checks and balances ought not apply to the judicial branch," Litt wrote. "Chief Justice Roberts declined an invitation to appear before the Senate Judiciary Committee, citing separation of powers. Alito went further, arguing that Congress doesn't have the ability to set rules and guidelines for the Court at all."
He continued: "Meanwhile, although no one has formally declared the change, it has become generally accepted that no justices will be confirmed while the Senate and the White House belong to opposite parties, and that justices will not retire while a president of the opposite party is in office. When you combine these two factors, the old method of checking the Court—winning elections and letting time take its toll—has been rendered unworkable."
What's Next?
As Litt mentioned in his op-ed, the old method of checking the Court is "winning elections and letting time take its toll." Four Supreme Court justices are getting up there in terms of age. Chief Justice John Roberts who has a conservative lean is 69 years old and Justice Sonia Sotomayor, a liberal, is 70 years old. Meanwhile, Thomas and Alito are 76 and 74, respectively.
If Biden, or another Democrat, were to win the presidential race in November and the two oldest justices, Thomas and Alito, were to retire, as the rules stand now, the Court's 6-3 conservative lean could be flipped—four conservatives to five liberals. However, it's extremely unlikely that justices retire when the opposing party is in power.
Update 7/20/24, 12:49 p.m. ET: This article has been updated with additional information.
Update 7/20/24, 3:04 p.m. ET: This article has been updated with comment from Yoo.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines