Are Men Attracted to Women on Birth Control? Maybe Not, Study Indicates

09_woman on phone_15_01
Women who don't take the birth control pill could have an advantage when it comes to attracting the opposite sex. Photo courtesy of Matthew Kane/Unsplash

Updated | Most women are familiar with the ups and downs of their menstrual cycle: they get their period and feel fatigued; post-period, their energy rises; mid-cycle, they're at their most fertile and feel sexy; and then their body prepares to repeat the cycle. Each month, women experience bloating, appetite changes, muscle pain, and/or mood swings, and even voice changes. A recent study published in PLOS One found whether a woman is on the pill or not can influence her voice tone, and potentially how attractive she is to men.

In the study, women not on birth control showed some interesting voice changes during their menstrual cycle. The minimum pitch of their voices during the stretch of the cycle when fertility is highest was lower compared to other stages.

During the luteal phase, after ovulation and before a woman's period starts, these women had a lower voice intensity. Meanwhile, women using monophasic hormonal contraceptives—pills that deliver the same amount of estrogen and progestin every day—did not experience any significant vocal changes throughout their menstrual cycle.

Related: Novak Djokovic Wades Into Indian Wells Sexism Debate to Talk About 'Women's Hormones'

Irena Pavela Banai, study author, believes there's a discrepancy between women on a natural cycle and those on birth control due to their sex hormones. Previous research has found during the ovulatory phase (with the highest level of estrogen), women had the "best voice"; in the premenstrual phase (least amount of estrogen, increased amount of progesterone), women had the "worst" voice, also referred to as "premenstrual voice syndrome." Birth control could interfere with these hormone fluctuations.

"[P]ill usage may disrupt naturally occurring changes in voice production and make voice more stable throughout the cycle, or even less feminine to some extent," Banai told PsyPost.

Banai recruited 44 naturally cycling women and 21 on the pill to examine the effects of the different phases of the menstrual cycle on their voice. To examine changes to their voice, she recorded the women speaking the five vowels at three different points in their menstrual cycle. The results indicated that sex hormones were affecting their voices, with women in the naturally cycling group speaking in higher-pitched voices during the fertile phase of their menstrual cycle.

Related: Why Aren't Birth Control Pills Sold Over the Counter? They Should Be

Interestingly, this could put naturally cycling women at an advantage when it comes to male attraction. In a 2012 study in Hormones and Behavior, men were more attracted to women with higher levels of estrogen and lower levels of progesterone.

Similarly, when women were asked to rate other women's photographs and vocal recordings based on two measures: flirtatiousness and attractiveness to men, subjects scored higher on both measures when they were in their more fertile phase.

This supports the idea that women's faces and voices change over the menstrual cycle, which both men and women perceive as attractive. These voice-induced hormonal fluctuations, experienced by naturally cycling women, could have an influence on mating preferences. But, Banai suggests "future studies are needed to address the question of vocal changes in relation to fluctuations of sex hormones in a defined social/mating context..."

It's possible men may subconsciously be able to pick up on women's vocal changes, or "subtle fertility cues," hence find them more attractive, because they will have more reproductive success.

This story has been updated to clarify study findings.