10
Loading video...

By Hugh Cameron
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Republican Senator Susan Collins and her Democratic rival Troy Jackson squared off in the first of four planned debates that could shape Maine’s crucial Senate race.
On Tuesday evening in Portland, the incumbent defended her voting record and her bipartisan bona fides as Jackson—who entered the race in late July—tried to draw political links between Collins and President Donald Trump while also pushing back against allegations of inexperience.
Postdebate reactions online indicate that no consensus winner emerged. However, both candidates had their own strong moments while leaving plenty to be said at the next encounter, scheduled for Thursday evening at 7 p.m.
Read More on Politics
Why the Maine Senate Race Matters in the 2026 Midterms?
Democrats hold a polling advantage in the Senate, though these odds are far closer than in the House. With Maine’s Senate seat still in toss-up territory by most accounts, the contest is therefore being closely monitored alongside races in Ohio and Texas, among others.

...
The Pine Tree State historically leans Blue and voted against Trump in the 2016, 2020 and 2024 elections, though Collins has held her Senate seat since 1996, having cultivated a reputation as a moderate Republican and one committed to delivering for Mainers.
The national environment for Republicans is tougher in 2026, however, given the low approval ratings enjoyed by Trump, though Collins has tried to distance herself from the president when it comes to new tariffs on Canada and on other matters.
Highlights of the Collins vs. Jackson Debate
Though numerous issues were covered, the debate focused largely on the question of whether Collins should be viewed as a moderate Republican capable of advocating for the state’s interests, or—as Jackson alleges—a stalwart supporter of Trump’s agenda even at the expense of ordinary Mainers.
Jackson’s attempts to nationalize the race included connecting Collins’s 2018 vote to confirm Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh with the eventual overturning of Roe v. Wade, and attempting to tie her to the Iran war and Trump’s tariffs on Canada—of which a majority of Mainers disapprove.

...
Collins, in response, noted her votes to assert Congress’s authority over the war. She called herself "the most outspoken opponent of the tariffs with Canada" while mentioning her efforts to protect Maine businesses from the worst effects of Trump’s duties.
In one of the most commented-on exchanges, Collins said that she was able to secure a tariff exemption for road salt from Canada, to which Jackson responded: "We can’t eat road salt."
Collins also pushed back against the statistic—frequently quoted by the Jackson campaign—that she votes with Trump 96 percent of the time. Collins said that the "misleading" statistic, which was quoted in the Bangor Daily News, failed to account for all her votes and that the actual figure was 70 percent. VoteView identifies Collins as one of the most centrist Republican senators by congressional roll call votes in the 119th Congress.
Collins further attempted to distance herself from Trump saying that she was "not exactly his favorite senator" when asked whether the president would stump for her on the campaign trail.
Collins vs. Jackson: Who Won the First Debate?
Postdebate reactions did not paint a clear consensus winner, with most commentary splitting along party lines.
Democrats claimed that Jackson successfully had Collins on the defensive when it came to her Kavanaugh vote and political support for Trump. His line—that Collins "is like an arsonist who helped set the fire, and then she wants credit for bringing a cup of water to put it out"—was quoted frequently in coverage following the debate.
"He definitely dominated and won that debate," State Senate President Mattie Daughtry, a Democrat, told the reporter Grace Panetta. "He had Senator Collins on her back foot and she really showed her hand."

...
Collins had her own moments, however, including her quip about not being Trump’s favorite senator. Republicans said she was able to highlight her decades of Congressional experience and create sufficient political distance from the president.
And the Democratic political strategist and lobbyist Denny Salas praised Collins's ability to tout her bipartisanship and legislative effectiveness.
"She knows she's experienced; she's worked across the aisle. She knows exactly how to attack a lot of these folks because she can actually legitimately stand up there as a bipartisan senator that's gotten a ton done for the state of Maine because she knows how to work across the aisle," Salas said on NTD News.
Prediction markets have also shifted since the debate, with Jackson’s lead narrowing to 57 percent by Wednesday from 59 percent on Tuesday morning. Jackson’s chances have improved slightly on Kalshi, however.
Phil Harriman, a political commentator and former Maine Republican state senator, told Newsweek he considered the debate a draw.
"Jackson successfully pounded on Collins’s party affiliation and technical procedural votes to portray her as a Trump devotee," he said.
However, Harriman added that Collins’s voting record proves she is "unwaveringly representing all of us."
Will the Debates Matter?
The stakes were high for both candidates heading into the first debate, given polls show a tight race with a significant number of undecideds.
A CBS News survey released last week was a dead even split between the pair, though a notable 10 percent of voters said they could change their minds before the election takes place.
And Jackson has also been grappling with a visibility issue since stepping in to replace Graham Platner—who dropped out following a sexual assault allegation, which he denies—less than three months ago.
A co/efficient survey conducted September 28 to September 30 found that 16 percent of the 1,240 likely voters polled had no opinion on Jackson, compared with 9 percent for Collins.
A separate New York Times/Press Herald/Siena Poll—conducted September 15 to 22 among 619 likely voters in Maine—found that six percent had "not heard of" Jackson, while an additional four percent did not provide an opinion on him.
Despite this and the tight nature of the contest, Andrew E. Smith, a professor of political science and director of the survey center at the University of New Hampshire, said he does not believe the debates will be a deciding factor.
This is "barring an absolute meltdown by one of the candidates," Smith told Newsweek.
However, Harriman said that the debates could hold "a lot of influence" over how currently undecided Mainers ultimately cast their ballots.
"The one percent [of voters] who may actually be unsure of who they’re going to vote for are looking at this race and saying, ‘Well, I’m going to watch these debates and see who has the statesperson-ship to represent the state of Maine.’"
Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Daniel Orton and James Debens
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines