10

Loading video...

Andrew Stanton

By Andrew Stanton

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Senator Susan Collins and her Democratic challenger Troy Jackson are set to face off in the first of four Maine Senate debates on Tuesday, as polls show a tight race between the two candidates.

Maine has emerged as one of the most competitive races in the battle to control the Senate in the November 3 elections. The Pine Tree State leans toward Democrats and voted against President Donald Trump in each of his three runs, but Collins has been able to win by large margins in the past due to her moderate image and personal popularity among Maine voters.

Democrats view Collins as more vulnerable this year as the national environment sours for Republicans amid Trump’s declining approval rating, voter frustration with the economy and soaring gas prices amid the Iran war. Historically, the party in the White House loses seats in the midterms if the president is unpopular, and Democrats believe they can exploit his poor approval to expand the electoral battleground and win in key races, such as the Maine Senate election.

Read More on Politics

The upcoming Maine Senate debate will bring Collins and Jackson face to face as they hope to win over undecided voters in the final weeks of the campaign. Polls have pointed to a close race, with no clear front-runner. The two candidates are likely to discuss issues including the economy, healthcare and foreign policy, which have been top of mind for Maine voters.

A spokesperson for Jackson's campaign told Newsweek: "Mainers know the contrast between Troy Jackson and Susan Collins couldn't be more clear. Collins has raised costs across the board for Mainers and made life harder for Mainers by gutting their health care to give tax cuts to billionaires, signing off on another endless war that’s jacking up energy costs, repeatedly voting to weaken Social Security, and failing to stop Trump's reckless tariffs from going into effect.

"Troy Jackson on the other hand will fight to lower costs by passing Medicare for all, ending the war in Iran and taking on the president’s tariffs while protecting Social Security and ensuring billionaires pay their fair share. While Susan Collins puts billionaires first and has voted with Trump 96% of the time, Troy will always fight for working Mainers and stand up to anyone who gets in the way."

Newsweek reached out to the Collins campaign for comment via email.

When Is the First Debate Between Susan Collins and Troy Jackson?

The first debate is set to be held on October 6 and will be broadcast on local television news station WGME.

It is the first of four debates between Jackson and Collins.

Maine Senate candidate Troy Jackson, left, speaks during a town hall event on September 13 in Biddeford, Maine, while Senator Susan Collins, right, attends the annual Moxie Day Parade in Lisbon, Maine, on July 11.

...

The second debate will also be held next week, on October 8, and will be hosted by WMTW.

The following week, on October 13, WABI and WAGM will host a debate. Finally, the two will face off on October 15 in a debate hosted by News Center Maine, The Portland Press Herald and Maine Public.

Five Key Issues for Maine Senate Race

The debate will give Collins and Jackson an opportunity to present their differences on a range of issues.

Collins has established a record as a moderate Republican who has broken from her party on several issues, while Jackson, the former president of the Maine Senate, is running as a progressive Democrat.

Here is a look at where they stand on five of the most important issues that are likely to come up in the debates.

The Economy

Perhaps no issue has defined the midterms more than the economy, as voters have continued to grapple with high prices. Maine already has a relatively high cost of living, so affordability issues have been a major focus for voters. Trump’s tariffs, as well as high fuel prices, are important issues in the state.

Trump has imposed 50 percent tariffs on Canadian imports, and that policy could have real impacts on Maine’s economy, though Ottawa did drop a tariff on lobster, a major relief to Maine lobstermen.

Opposition to the tariffs is one thing both Collins and Jackson have in common. Both have raised issue with the way it could affect the economy in Maine, but Jackson has also accused Collins of not doing enough to block Trump from enacting the tariffs.

Collins has warned about the tariffs’ impact on the state. She said she has heard from paper mills about “the crushing increased costs that they will incur and the potential impact on their employment levels.”

Jackson has described the tariffs as a “betrayal to our working families" in an August 26 post to X. He also said Collins has “completely failed to stop him.”

“As always she’s got concerns about what these broad new tariffs will do to Maine, but she’s got no action. And when given the chance to actually vote to stop Trump from raising our costs, she voted NO," he wrote.

Another local issue shaping the race is home heating oil. It's a unique issue to Maine, where more than 50 percent of residents use oil as a primary heating source, and rising fuel costs amid the Iran war could add strain to their wallets. The price of oil for home heating has increased to more than $6 per gallon in Maine, a record high point, according to the state Department of Energy Resources. That means as winter approaches, Mainers can expect to pay more to keep their houses warm, playing into a broader affordability theme that has shaped this year's elections.

Jackson spokesperson Cheyenne Gallivan previously told Newsweek that Jackson “has a record of working to lower energy costs and will always stand up to put Mainers first – not billionaires, corporations, or a reckless president,” while Collins has “spent decades selling out Mainers by supporting an agenda that raises their energy costs.”

Collins has urged Trump to release supply from the Northeast Home Heating Oil Reserve and has urged an early release of funds for the Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP), which provides funding for low-income households’ energy costs in Maine.

Healthcare

Healthcare is another issue that is likely to be discussed during the debate.

Jackson has embraced calls for a single-payer healthcare system, Medicare for All. He told News Center Maine this week that he believes the current system is “not working for the majority of people.”

Collins, however, has opposed a Medicare for All healthcare system. Her Senate website states that she believes the healthcare system “requires substantial reform,” pointing to rising prescription costs and provider shortages across Maine.

“I frequently work with my colleagues on both sides of the aisle to address these and other important issues facing our nation, such as enhancing mental health care, expanding drug treatment programs, supporting America’s caregivers, and improving nutrition programs,” her website reads.

Notably, Collins voted against the repeal of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) during Trump’s first term in office.

Voters may also be concerned about the candidates’ proposals to address the shortage of health providers in Maine, as well as the closure of maternity wards across the more rural areas in the state. Twelve centers have closed in Maine since 2015, according to the Press Herald.

Foreign Policy

There are major divides between Collins and Jackson on foreign policy, including the Iran war.

Jackson has cast himself as opposing the war in Iran. He is also a critic of Israel and supports restricting aid to the nation amid its actions in Gaza, which he has referred to as a “genocide.”

Collins is a supporter of Israel, telling Fox News earlier this year that she is not changing her position in light of polls showing that Americans have soured on the country's government.

“I remain a very strong supporter of Israel, the one democracy in the Middle East. Our true ally in the Middle East, and I think this sadly reflects a rising antisemitism in our country that Graham Platner certainly is part of, and has been since his high school days,” she said, referring to her original opponent who dropped out amid sexual assault allegations, which he has denied.

Collins initially declined to support War Powers Resolutions to limit Trump’s ability to wage war in Iran, writing in a statement earlier this year, soon after Trump ordered strikes against Iran, that passing the resolution “would send the wrong message to Iran and to our troops.”

But she has become increasingly critical with regards to the conflict and has voted in support of subsequent resolutions.

In April, she said in a statement that the War Powers Resolution “establishes a clear 60-day deadline for Congress to either authorize or end U.S. involvement in foreign hostilities.”

“Further military action against Iran must have a clear mission, achievable goals, and a defined strategy for bringing the conflict to a close. I voted to end the continuation of these military hostilities at this time until such a case is made,” she wrote.

Donald Trump

Trump will also be a key issue for the two candidates. Trump has never been particularly popular in Maine, as he lost the state in all three of his presidential races. His approval rating has fallen to record lows in recent polls, and Democrats have sought to make the midterms a referendum on his administration.

Collins has highlighted her independence from the president, but Jackson’s campaign has noted she votes with him the majority of the time—95 percent, according to a report from CQ Roll Call.

Democrats say Collins only breaks from Trump when her vote does not make a difference, but Collins has voted against the president on major priorities including those War Powers Resolutions, the One Big Beautiful Bill and several of his cabinet appointees.

How Collins approaches the Trump question during the debate could weigh heavily on how Maine voters view her ahead of the midterms, especially as independent voters and moderate Democrats, who do not like Trump but could still vote for a more centrist Republican, may be critical to her chances of winning reelection.

Social Security

Maine is the oldest state in the country, with an average age of 44.8, according to the state Department of Administrative and Financial Services. This means the Social Security issue will resonate with many voters in the state.

Both candidates have cast themselves as strong supporters of the social program.

Collins, in August 2025, described it as “one of the most effective lifesaving programs in our nation’s history.”

She crafted the Social Security Fairness Act, which her office said would restore benefits for millions of people by repealing the Windfall Elimination Provision and the Government Pension Offset that “unfairly reduce the Social Security benefits that public employees or their spouses have earned.”

Jackson also pledged to protect Social Security in a September opinion piece in The Bangor Daily News. He called for “scrapping” the income cap and increasing the benefits received by retirees.

“I believe the debate in Washington should be about how to strengthen retirement security, not how much we can ask retirees to give up,” he wrote. “I will never support raising the retirement age.”

Susan Collins vs. Troy Jackson: What Latest Polls Show

Collins and Jackson are facing a tight race in Maine, according to the latest polling data.

Collins held a 3-point lead in the latest poll from The New York Times, Siena University and The Portland Press Herald released last week, with 49 percent of respondents supporting her reelection bid compared to 46 percent planning to vote for Jackson. It surveyed 619 likely voters from September 15 to 22.

However, Jackson had a 4-point lead in a University of New Hampshire poll released the same day. He had support from 51 percent of respondents to Collins’ 47 percent, up from July, when he led by 3 points. It surveyed 1,312 likely voters from September 17 to 21 and had a margin of error of plus or minus 2.7 percentage points.

Another poll from the University of Massachusetts Lowell gave Jackson a 5-point lead, 48 percent to 43 percent. Among independent voters, a critical voting bloc in the Pine Tree State, he led by 8 points, 40 percent to 32 percent, with 22 percent still undecided, the poll found.

Collins and Jackson were tied in an InsiderAdvantage poll, which showed them both at around 46 percent. It surveyed 1,200 likely voters from September 22 to 23, with a margin of error of plus or minus 2.83 percentage points.

Why the Maine Senate Race Matters in 2026 Midterms

Maine is a must-win Senate seat for Democrats this year if they want to flip control of the chamber.

Democrats are facing a difficult map but have become increasingly optimistic about winning the Senate. Republicans presently have a 53-47 majority, so Democrats need to flip four seats for a majority, as Vice President JD Vance serves as the tiebreaker in an evenly-divided Senate.

To flip the Senate majority, Democrats must win every seat they currently hold, flip GOP-held seats in competitive states, and win some seats in more traditionally conservative territory.

Democrats are defending seats in Trump-won states Georgia and Michigan. In addition to Maine, they view a GOP-held seat in North Carolina as a top flip opportunity. The race in New Hampshire, which backed Harris by about 3 points, is also competitive.

No other Senate races are in Harris-won or single-digit Trump states, meaning Democrats must expand the Senate battleground and compete in more conservative areas if they want to win the majority. They are targeting GOP-held seats in Alaska, Iowa, Ohio and Texas as potential states to flip. The Cook Political Report classifies those four races as tossups.

Update 10/1/26 7.15 a.m. ET: This article was updated with a statement from a spokesperson for Troy Jackson's campaign.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines