Woman Does Skincare Routine

...

Claire Dodds

By Claire Dodds

Life & Trends Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A dermatologist’s blunt ranking of popular skincare ingredients is gaining attention after he broke down what actually works—and what may be more hype than science.

Posted by creator dannyguo.md, the TikTok video lays out an “anti-aging ingredient tier list,” placing well-known staples like retinoids (or their alternative, bakuchiol), vitamin C and sunscreen in the top “S tier,” while pushing trending ingredients like PDRN into the lowest category.

The breakdown has sparked discussion across social media, particularly as consumers navigate an increasingly crowded skincare market.

Read More on Life

The video arrives at a time when dermatologists and researchers continue to emphasize evidence-based ingredients over viral trends, even as newer formulations and celebrity-backed treatments gain popularity.

Woman Does Skincare Routine

...

Why Dermatologists Still Favor the Basics

Experts have long pointed to a core group of ingredients as the foundation of effective skincare. Retinoids, for example, are widely considered one of the most researched anti-aging treatments.

According to Harvard Health, retinoids, “boost collagen, improve skin thickness and smooth the outer layer of the skin,” helping reduce fine lines and wrinkles.

Similarly, vitamin C remains a staple for protecting against environmental damage.

Harvard Health notes that it, “helps brighten the skin, even out skin tone and reduce the appearance of dark spots,” while also protecting against free radical damage.

Sunscreen, another “S tier” pick in the video, is consistently highlighted as essential. Daily sun protection is, “one of the most important steps for slowing skin aging,” according to Harvard Health, which warns that ultraviolet exposure accelerates collagen breakdown.

The dermatologist quips in the clip: “Do we even need to talk about this?”

The Rise—and Scrutiny—of Trend Ingredients

While established ingredients dominate clinical recommendations, newer additions like PDRN have surged in popularity, particularly in K-beauty and celebrity-driven treatments.

PDRN, derived from salmon DNA, has been marketed as a regenerative ingredient.

Some dermatologists highlight potential benefits.

“PDRN can do some heavy lifting behind the scenes,” said cosmetic dermatologist Dr. Shereene Idriss to Harper’s Bazaar, noting it may support collagen production and skin repair.

View on TikTok

View this video on TikTok

However, the TikTok creator ranked topical PDRN products in the lowest tier, arguing there is little evidence they are effective without procedures that enhance absorption—reflecting a broader skepticism among some clinicians about over-the-counter formulations.

Even proponents acknowledge limitations.

Dr. Catherine Chang told Harper’s Bazaar that many products, “likely don’t contain PDRN at active concentrations, so their effectiveness may be limited.”

What People Are Saying

The video has prompted mixed reactions from TikTok viewers, many of whom expressed surprise at the rankings.

“So LED masks are not a fad? I really thought the beauty industry was trying to scam us,” an individual shared.

Another asked of the skincare expert, “Please do the acids. Glycolic/lactic. And where would topical glutathione be. I received an eye cream with it… and it reduced dark circles dramatically in three nights of use.”

Others weighed in on supplements.

“Oral collagen does one thing that is really worth it for me, it makes my eyelashes stay longer, they're like long for longer cause they don't fall out,” another person commented.

What This Means for Skincare Shoppers

The discussion highlights a recurring divide between trending products and evidence-backed skincare. While newer ingredients may offer potential benefits, experts continue to stress the tried and true with proven options like retinoids, antioxidants and sun protection.

As social media continues to shape consumer habits, dermatologists are increasingly stepping in to clarify what is supported by research—and what may still be catching up.

Newsweek has reached out to dannyguo.md for comment via TikTok. We could not verify the details of the case.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines