Majority of Companies Maintain DEI Programs

...

Aman Kidwai

By Aman Kidwai

Workplaces Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The first few months of Donald Trump's second presidency and changes in the federal and cultural landscape have had a dramatic effect on corporate diversity, equity and inclusion efforts, but for many companies those policies appear to remain an integral part of a sound talent strategy.

A recent survey of corporate leaders, including general counsel, HR and diversity officers, by employment law firm Littler found that 49 percent of C-suite leaders were not considering new or further rollbacks of DEI programs, despite the Trump administration's moves to end such initiatives. Littler found that only 8 percent are seriously considering changes, and in 2024 three-quarters of the businesses surveyed maintained (46 percent) or increased (30 percent) DEI commitments and activity.

Of the leaders continuing their efforts, around three-quarters said that employee expectations played a role, "suggesting that [DEI] remains an important talent retention and recruitment strategy for many employers even as the environment around those efforts becomes more hostile," said a Littler report in response to the findings.

Read More on News

Amid the surging sense of DEI backlash in January, Newsweek noted survey data from Gravity Research that showed 43 percent of firms in the Fortune 100 mentioned DEI in 2023 earnings calls. That fell last year to 31 percent, but there was a 59 percent rise in neutral, related terms such as "belonging" or "diverse perspectives."

Majority of Companies Maintain DEI Programs

...

"Companies are looking at their DEI programs to ensure that they're not engaging in any sort of high-risk areas that have already been challenged, such as fellowship programs that may not be open to all, or having quotas," Jeanine Conley Daves, Littler's New York office managing shareholder, told Newsweek.

She added that companies have been using the Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard case as a reference point to assess their risk. The Supreme Court ruled that race-based university and college admissions violated the Equal Protection Clause in Title VI of the 1964 Civil Rights Act.

On January 21, the White House issued a statement in which the president ordered "all agencies to enforce our longstanding civil rights laws and to combat illegal private-sector DEI preferences, mandates, policies, programs and activities." It has also made moves to end DEI hiring practices within the federal government.

There have been some high-profile DEI rollbacks. Google users recently noticed it had stopped automatically scheduling some cultural events on calendars, including Black History Month, Pride Month and Holocaust Remembrance Day.

"Maintaining hundreds of moments manually and consistently globally wasn't scalable or sustainable. So...we returned to showing only public holidays and national observances from timeanddate.com globally, while allowing users to manually add other important moments," Google told the Associated Press.

In December, Amazon employees received a memo saying that it was scaling back DEI initiatives, citing legal risks and shifting corporate policies, according to Bloomberg. "We are focusing on programs with proven outcomes—and we also aim to foster a more truly inclusive culture," the memo said, per the outlet.

But Littler's research suggested that the majority of firms are staying the course on DEI. Daves also pointed to Title VII of the Civil Rights Act—which prohibits employment discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex and national origin.

"The law hasn't changed since its inception, and it continues to be the same. You can't and you shouldn't discriminate in any employment-related decisions based on any protected category," she said. "It continues to be the law that these things are governed under, and the law employers are using to assess all of their programming."

woman office colorful chairs

...

Of the companies making changes to programs, six in 10 were "waiting for further details on the new administration's priorities—including enforcement mechanisms—before making any modifications," Littler's report said.

"Organizations considering future rollbacks...are mainly focused on minimizing external communications, rather than eliminating programs." It added: "Approximately half (55 percent) are more worried post-inauguration about the risk of [DEI]-related lawsuits, government enforcement actions and shareholder proposals."

In addition to the firms making no change, 27 percent were making changes "to a small extent," indicating that most are still involved in DEI strategy. However, recent events suggest pullbacks may continue. The rate of leaders expecting firms to decrease commitments rose from 38 percent before Trump's inauguration to 53 percent after, according to Littler.

The chief diversity officer role has seen tumultuous times, but that was true prior to the start of Trump's latest presidency, Daves noted. The Students for Fair Admissions Supreme Court decision and the stock market dip that led to corporate layoffs across 2022 and 2023 have precipitated some change for that role.

"We're seeing a lot of companies who are maintaining those positions and see their value and the importance of them," Daves said. "Some are maintaining those positions but calling them by a different name. Some are getting rid of those positions, but still maintaining a lot of the practices of DEI in their companies."

"One of the most prudent things companies can do is to make sure that they are assessing their DEI programs and making sure that they continue to be in compliance with the law, which a lot of them are," she added. "I think a lot of companies are continuing in that vein."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines