10

Loading video...

Daniel Orton

By Daniel Orton

News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


President Donald Trump suffered his most concentrated series of endorsement defeats of the 2026 primary cycle on Tuesday, when three Republican candidates he supported lost races in Florida and Wyoming.

Representative Cory Mills was defeated in the Republican primary for Florida’s 7th Congressional District, Catalina Lauf lost the contest for the GOP nomination in Florida’s 19th District, and Wyoming Superintendent of Public Instruction Megan Degenfelder fell short in the state’s Republican gubernatorial primary.

The three losses do not erase Trump’s long list of successful endorsements, including several victories on the same night. But they add to a run of August defeats that has exposed the limits of the president’s ability to carry candidates past local opposition, controversy or questions about their fitness for office.

Read More on Politics

Former NBC News moderator Chuck Todd summarized the political moment in a post on X late Tuesday, writing: “August has been a cruel month for Trump politically.”

Trump remains the dominant national figure in the Republican Party, and candidates continue to compete for his backing. Yet Tuesday’s results showed that an endorsement from the president does not necessarily override concerns Republican primary voters have developed about an individual candidate.

The three defeats accounted for one-third of the nine losses across House, Senate and gubernatorial contests, according to a Newsweek analysis of Ballotpedia data.

President Donald Trump speaks during an executive order signing event in the Oval Office of the White House on March 31, 2025.

...

What Happened to Trump’s Candidates in Florida and Wyoming

In Florida's 7th District, Mills lost to former television journalist Ryan Elijah. The Associated Press projected the result Tuesday night. Trump had endorsed Mills in February, although the president did not include the congressman in a group of Florida endorsements he publicized shortly before the election.

On Wednesday, in a post on Truth Social, Trump called Mills a friend but said he had urged him "to get out of the Race, but he wouldn’t listen."

Mills’ campaign unfolded against a difficult political backdrop. Controversies and investigations shaped his reelection bid and gave Republican voters reasons to judge the race on more than presidential loyalty. Mills has denied allegations against him.

The loss was therefore not a straightforward rebellion against Trump. It was also a test of whether the president’s support could insulate an incumbent from problems attached to his own candidacy. On Tuesday, it could not.

In Florida’s open 19th District, conservative media executive Jim Schwartzel defeated Lauf in a crowded field to succeed Byron Donalds, who left the seat to run for governor.

Trump endorsed Lauf late in the campaign. With most votes counted Tuesday night, Schwartzel had about 29 percent of the vote, and Lauf had roughly 22 percent, according to reported results. The Associated Press called the race for Schwartzel at 8:03 p.m. ET.

Representative Byron Donalds speaks in Washington, D.C., on February 12, 2026.

...

That timing complicates any attempt to use the result as a clean measure of Trump’s influence. Florida’s early-voting period ran from August 8 through August 15, meaning some Republicans cast ballots before the endorsement had much opportunity to shape the race.

Still, Lauf’s loss matters because the district is heavily Republican. The primary was the decisive intraparty test, not merely a preliminary contest before an evenly divided general election.

In Wyoming, Republican state Senator Eric Barlow defeated Degenfelder in the race to succeed term-limited Governor Mark Gordon. Degenfelder leaned heavily on Trump’s support, while Barlow emphasized his Wyoming roots and state issues including public lands, schools and rural health care.

Together, the three outcomes produced an unusually visible contrast: Trump-backed candidates lost in a Florida congressional district represented by an incumbent, in an open Florida House seat and in a strongly Republican state’s gubernatorial primary.

Trump nevertheless had notable victories Tuesday. Donalds, whom he supported for Florida governor, won the Republican nomination with approximately 47.8 percent of the vote, compared with 25.2 percent for Lieutenant Governor Jay Collins and 10.5 percent for James Fishback, with 99 percent of the expected vote counted.

That result underlines the central tension in Trump’s endorsement record. His political support can remain highly valuable even if it isn't universally decisive.

Why August Has Been Different

Tuesday’s defeats followed three earlier losses by Trump-backed candidates in August.

Mike Lindell lost his bid for the Republican nomination for governor of Minnesota. In Michigan, Amir Hassan lost a congressional primary. Tennessee Representative Andy Ogles was also defeated. That means two-thirds of the nine endorsement defeats recorded by Ballotpedia occurred within roughly three weeks.

The other candidates in the tally include Iowa Representative Randy Feenstra, Georgia Lieutenant Governor Burt Jones, and South Carolina Lieutenant Governor Pamela Evette, all of whom lost gubernatorial primaries or runoffs in June.

The pattern is striking, but its scale needs perspective. Before the latest votes, Trump had still endorsed far more winners than losers.

A White House official told Politico before Tuesday’s contests that Trump had a 98 percent success rate, with 233 wins from 238 endorsements. The official called his support “the most powerful endorsement in the history of American politics” and said anyone claiming otherwise was “a complete and utter fool.”

Politico reported that the White House did not provide the underlying list. It also noted that a similar Ballotpedia tally included many effectively uncontested races, including incumbents without primary opponents.

The difference in methodology matters. A topline win rate can make an endorsement operation appear nearly flawless if it includes candidates who faced little or no meaningful opposition. A smaller group of competitive races may offer more information about whether the endorsement changed voter behavior.

The relevant question, then, is not simply how often the Trump-backed candidate won. It is how often Trump took a genuine risk, whether his support altered the race, and what happened when the candidate entered the contest with vulnerabilities.

What the Losses Say About Trump’s Hold on the GOP

The short answer is less than Trump’s critics may hope, but perhaps more than his allies would care to concede.

Trump’s endorsement remains a powerful signal in Republican primaries. It can generate national attention, establish ideological credibility and give voters a quick way to differentiate between candidates whose policy positions may otherwise appear similar.

That influence was evident in a South Carolina Senate poll in July. Forty-six percent of undecided Republican primary voters in the survey said a Trump endorsement would make them more likely to support a candidate.

August, however, has shown what that influence cannot always accomplish.

The candidates who lost were not uniformly defeated by anti-Trump Republicans seeking to repudiate the president. In several cases, GOP voters instead appear to have concluded that candidate quality, controversy, electability, experience or local relationships outweighed Trump’s preference.

The distinction is important. A voter can remain strongly supportive of Trump while rejecting one of his endorsed candidates. Primary results measure a choice between people on a particular ballot, not a binary referendum on the president.

Trump’s support may therefore be powerful enough to move a candidate into contention without being strong enough to overcome every weakness attached to that candidate.

The next test for Trump will be two runoffs on August 25, where South Carolina Senator Darline Graham looks to secure the GOP nomination to replace her late brother on November's ballot, and Mike Mazzei is in a close race with Gentner Drummond as both men seek to be the Republican nominee in Oklahoma's gubernatorial election.

Related Story

Map Shows Seats Democrats Have Flipped in Trump’s Second Term

Map Shows Seats Democrats Have Flipped in Trump’s Second Term

Why Governor’s Races Present a Different Test

The limits have been particularly visible in gubernatorial contests.

Political scientist Justin Vaughn previously told Newsweek that House races and governor’s races ask voters to make different judgments.

“House races have become extraordinarily nationalized, particularly in primaries, where party and presidential loyalty can be powerful shortcuts for voters,” Vaughn said. “Conversely, voters are more likely to ask if a candidate for governor seems capable of actually running their state, and established state political relationships and reputations matter more.”

That framework helps explain why an endorsement may work differently across offices.

A Warning Sign or Republican Quality Control?

Republicans may find some reassurance in the recent results.

One interpretation is that primary voters are operating as a quality-control mechanism. They may accept Trump’s leadership of the party while refusing to nominate candidates they consider particularly weak, controversial or ill-suited to the office.

If those judgments produce stronger nominees for November, the losses could ultimately benefit the Republican Party. Avoiding a problematic candidate in a primary may matter more than preserving the president’s statistical endorsement record.

That interpretation also guards against overreading a burst of results from different states as one national political trend. The Florida and Wyoming races involved different offices, electorates, candidate histories and campaign dynamics.

The less flattering interpretation for the White House is that Trump’s political mystique has weakened at the margins.

His endorsement still gives candidates something their rivals want. It can elevate relatively little-known contenders, focus media attention and shape how Republican voters understand a race. But recent results suggest it does not automatically settle every competitive primary, especially when local concerns or candidate-specific liabilities push in the other direction.

It is too early to write the kingmaker’s obituary. Trump can still elevate a candidate, and Tuesday’s Florida governor result demonstrated that his preferred contender can win an important and crowded race.

Increasingly, though, the 2026 cycle suggests that he cannot always save one.

For more analysis on the numbers shaping U.S. politics and the 2026 midterms, sign up for Newsweek's Midterms Monitor newsletter from Daniel Orton and Alex J. Rouhandeh.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: John Fitzpatrick and Sam Wilson.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines