Venezuelan gang members

...

Shane CroucherBillal Rahman

By Shane Croucher and Billal Rahman

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


President Donald Trump is facing another lawsuit over his invocation of the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 (AEA) to deport alleged Venezuelan gang members.

An emergency motion filed by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) on Saturday requests a temporary restraining order on the deportation of migrants from Colorado, as well as 30 days' notice of any intent to remove them.

The lawsuit states that the individuals are at imminent risk of being removed from the United States under the law, which was originally designed to remove foreign nationals deemed threats to national security.

Read More

Trump Administration Gives Status Update on Abrego Garcia4 min read

Trump Administration Gives Status Update on Abrego Garcia

Donald Trump Scores Major Legal Win Over ICE Raids: ‘Gravely Concerned’3 min read

Donald Trump Scores Major Legal Win Over ICE Raids: ‘Gravely Concerned’

US Citizen Told by Trump Admin to Self-Deport Amid Crackdown5 min read

US Citizen Told by Trump Admin to Self-Deport Amid Crackdown

It adds that the individuals are at risk of being sent to places such as El Salvador, where they face "life-threatening conditions, persecution, and torture."

Venezuelan gang members

...

Why It Matters

Trump has pledged to deport millions of undocumented immigrants as part of his aggressive immigration policy. However, critics argue that these efforts could result in the wrongful deportation of individuals, denying them proper due process or a fair opportunity to defend themselves.

This issue came to a head last month when the government deported over 200 Venezuelan nationals, who the U.S. accused of having connections to the violent Tren de Aragua (TdA) gang.

They were sent to El Salvador's Centro de Confinamiento del Terrorismo (CECOT)—a maximum-security facility widely condemned by human rights groups for its harsh conditions and mass incarceration practices. CECOT, often referred to as El Salvador's "super prison," has become a symbol of President Nayib Bukele's tough-on-crime crackdown and is infamous for holding thousands of alleged gang members in overcrowded, high-surveillance conditions.

What To Know

The ACLU's emergency motion seeks to prevent the deportations and demands that the government provides at least 30 days' notice to individuals facing removal, ensuring they have adequate time to contest.

The lawsuit states that the government has not yet indicated how much notice it will give individuals before seeking to remove them under the AEA. It notes that at a Texas hearing on April 11, the government said they had not ruled out giving individuals no more than 24 hours' notice.

The ACLU adds that as several judges have found, petitioners are likely to succeed due to the imminent risk of being sent to El Salvador, "where they potentially face lifetime incommunicado sentences in one of the most notorious prisons in the world."

The lawsuit states that the petitioners argue that Trump's proclamation is invalid under the AEA for several reasons.

First, it says that the TdA is not a "foreign nation or government," as required to invoke the AEA. Second, it says that the TdA is not engaged in an "invasion" or "predatory incursions" within the meaning of the AEA.

According to the ACLU's emergency motion, several of the deported individuals had no verified criminal history or direct evidence linking them to the TdA gang. Petitioners allege they were removed with little to no notice—sometimes in as few as 24 hours—without a meaningful opportunity to review or challenge the government's classification.

The motion argues that this violates their due process rights, especially given the irreversible consequences of being transferred to prisons like CECOT.

The lawsuit comes after the United States Supreme Court permitted the Trump administration to proceed with its deportation efforts under AEA, but with the stipulation that immigrants be allowed to present their cases in court.

What People Are Saying

President Donald Trump said in October 2024: "It gives tremendous authority to everybody to straighten out our country."

Jean Lantz Reisz, co-director of the immigration clinic at the University of Southern California's Gould School of Law, told CNN: "I think that Trump is citing this as a way to kind of bypass all of that due process and make it easier to arrest and deport people."

Katherine Hawkins, senior legal analyst at Project on Government Oversight, told Newsweek: "The Supreme Court majority overturned the order that was stopping illegal renditions to El Salvador. The majority and dissent actually agreed that people are entitled to due process and judicial review before they're sent to a foreign prison as "alien enemies"—but the court did not create any realistic way for people to actually get their day in court.

"The Trump administration already ignored a much clearer court order to turn around the planes, and is likely to see this court decision as a signal it can get away with more disappearances."

What Happens Next

The outcome of the lawsuit could significantly impact how the Trump administration applies the AEA in future deportation cases. It also raises key questions about the balance between national security measures and the constitutional rights of immigrants.

Update 4/14/25, 11:34 a.m. ET: This article was updated with additional information.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines