Judge's Jury Instructions Could Change Trump TrialOutcome

...

Kaitlin Lewis

By Kaitlin Lewis

Night Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The judge's instructions to the jury panel that will decide the outcome of former President Donald Trump's business fraud case will likely have "a lot of power," according to jury consultant Melissa Gomez.

Trump's criminal trial in Manhattan is coming to a close this week after over four weeks of testimony. The former president is facing 34 charges in connection to a hush money payment made to adult film star Stormy Daniels to allegedly keep quiet about an affair she said they had. Prosecutors claim that Trump falsified business records to conceal his involvement in the payment, which was made by Trump's former personal attorney, Michael Cohen, during the 2016 presidential election.

The former president has pleaded not guilty to all counts involved and denies having an affair with Daniels.

Read More

New Donald Trump Trial Evidence to Be Unsealed3 min read

New Donald Trump Trial Evidence to Be Unsealed

Donald Trump’s ‘Self-Inflicted Wound’ Could Cost Him Trial: Ex-Prosecutor3 min read

Donald Trump’s ‘Self-Inflicted Wound’ Could Cost Him Trial: Ex-Prosecutor

Donald Trump Prosecutors Face ‘Practical Problem’ With Jury Instructions4 min read

Donald Trump Prosecutors Face ‘Practical Problem’ With Jury Instructions

Closing arguments in the case will begin Tuesday morning, and a 12-person jury will begin their deliberations on Wednesday. But prior to handing it off to the panel, presiding Judge Juan Merchan will give jurors instructions on the law governing the case, a topic that was heavily debated by prosecutors and the defense team during the trial last week.

While speaking to CNN on Monday, Gomez said that Merchan's instructions could play a huge role in the jury's ruling in Trump's case, telling anchors Boris Sanchez and Jessica Dean, "It's when there is disagreement in the room when the juries really rely on those jury instructions."

"I think this is the context where those instructions can have a lot of power if they're clear and help guide these jurors," Gomez added.

Both sides in the case requested that Merchan include certain details in his instructions last week, which the Associated Press said are expected to take about an hour on Wednesday. Trump's attorneys had asked that the judge explain that the hush money payments at the center of the case do not inherently break the law, which prosecutors called "totally inappropriate."

The defense also requested that Merchan consider the "extraordinarily important" makeup of the case in his instructions, although the judge said doing so would deviate from standard instructions proceedings. The debates happened outside of the jury's presence.

Judge's Jury Instructions Could Change Trump TrialOutcome

...

It only takes one juror in the 12-person panel to side with Trump for the former president to dodge charges in the case, and legal experts have said that the chance of a mistrial is far higher in the former president's situation than in a normal trial.

When asked if she believed that the case could end in a mistrial, Gomez told CNN that a hung jury could happen in "any case" but concluded, "Anything can happen in a trial like this, and it only takes one holdout."

Newsweek reached out to Trump's attorneys and the Manhattan district attorney's office via email on Monday for comment ahead of closing arguments.

CNN legal analyst Elie Honig said last week that the prosecution could have a "practical problem" if the jury is not instructed on the complicated specifics around campaign finance law at the center of Trump's case, which Honig said have been "so poorly defined" by the prosecution.

"If the jury is going to be instructed that the other crime here is state or federal campaign finance law, don't they have to get into what that means?" Honig noted.

Meanwhile, conservative commentator Megyn Kelly has warned that Merchan's instructions could tip the jury against Trump.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines