Trump speaks at rally with raised hand

...

Sean O'Driscoll

By Sean O'Driscoll

Senior Crime and Courts Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A former federal prosecutor has said that the judge in Donald Trump's election-fraud trial should either jail him or hold him in contempt the next time he breaks his gag order.

Neama Rahmani told Newsweek about his reaction to a Washington, D.C. court of appeals decision to reimpose Judge Tanya Chutkan's gag order on Trump. The appeal court narrowed her gag order so that Trump will be free to criticize Justice Department Special Counsel Jack Smith, who is the chief prosecutor in the case.

However, the appeal court ruled that Trump cannot criticize Smith's family, as he did in the past, nor court staff and officials, after they received a torrent of threats from Trump supporters.

Read More

Donald Trump Questions First Amendment After Gag Order Ruling3 min read

Donald Trump Questions First Amendment After Gag Order Ruling

Donald Trump Moves to Freeze Election-Fraud Case3 min read

Donald Trump Moves to Freeze Election-Fraud Case

Donald Trump Won’t Listen to Judge Chutkan Anymore3 min read

Donald Trump Won’t Listen to Judge Chutkan Anymore

Rahmani, a former federal prosecutor and now president of the West Coast Trial Lawyers law firm, said that it was time for Chutkan to get tough with Trump.

"All of this is meaningless unless Judge Chutkan is actually going to enforce the gag order and revoke Trump's bond or hold him in contempt. So far, no judge has been willing to do so, aside from minor, meaningless fines," Rahmani said. If Chutkan revoked Trump's bond for bad behavior, he would have to go to jail until his trial, which is due to begin next March.

Trump was indicted on four counts of allegedly working to overturn the results of the 2020 election in the run-up to the January 6, 2021 riot at the U.S. Capitol. It is one of four criminal cases that Trump is facing while he campaigns as frontrunner for the Republican presidential nomination. He has also pleaded not guilty to charges in the other cases, denying any wrongdoing, and has repeatedly said that they form part of a political witch hunt. Newsweek sought email comment on Friday from Donald Trump's attorney.

Trump speaks at rally with raised hand

...

Rahmani, who prosecuted major federal cases before going into private practice, said that he was not surprised the appeal court reinstated the gag order. It was imposed by Chutkan and temporarily lifted by the appeal court until it delivered Friday's ruling.

"Obviously, there are First Amendment issues at play for a presidential candidate, but Trump has pushed the limits of free expression and gag orders have been routinely upheld by appellate courts, including the Supreme Court," Rahmani said.

"I am surprised Special Counsel Jack Smith was excluded from the order, but the court probably reasoned that Smith is a party and knew what he was getting himself into when he charged Trump. You can't say the same for the trial judge and other court staff," Rahmani added.

In a statement, the Trump presidential campaign said that the appeal court has lifted "a huge part of Judge Chutkan's extraordinarily overbroad gag order."

In its written ruling, the three-judge appeal court said it had to reach a balance between the administration of justice and Trump's free speech.

It noted that "the former President has also lashed out at government officials closely involved in the criminal proceeding. He has repeatedly labeled the trial judge as 'biased,' a 'fraud' and a 'hack' and has called the prosecutors 'deranged,' 'thugs' and 'lunatics'. He likewise has posted about the Special Counsel's wife and spoke publicly about her at a rally following our administrative stay of the [gag] order."

The appeal court's ruling narrows Chutkan's gag order in two ways—Trump can criticize Smith and case witnesses, as long as his criticism is general and not about their roles in the case.

"[TRUMP's] appeal involves the confluence of two paramount constitutional interests: the freedom of speech guaranteed by the First Amendment and the federal courts' vital Article III duty to ensure the fair and orderly administration of justice in criminal cases," the judges wrote.

They added that Chutkan's court had ensured that Trump's public comments criticizing Washington, D.C, where the trial is due to take place next March, will not affect his trial.

"The district court first explained that an order restricting Mr. Trump's speech about the District of Columbia or its residents was not necessary at that time to protect against contaminating the jury pool. Instead, the district court held that, on the record before it, any such taint could be addressed through rigorous questioning of potential jurors before empanelment," the appeal court wrote.

"We do not allow such an order lightly," Judge Patricia A. Millett wrote for the appeal court panel. "Mr. Trump is a former president and current candidate for the presidency, and there is a strong public interest in what he has to say. But Mr. Trump is also an indicted criminal defendant, and he must stand trial in a courtroom under the same procedures that govern all other criminal defendants. That is what the rule of law means."

The court was sharply critical of Trump's past comments about people connected to the case.

"Many of former President Trump's public statements attacking witnesses, trial participants, and court staff pose a danger to the integrity of these criminal proceedings," Judge Millett wrote. "That danger is magnified by the predictable torrent of threats of retribution and violence that the district court found follows when Mr. Trump speaks out forcefully against individuals in connection with this case and the 2020 election aftermath on which the indictment focuses."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines