donald trump

...

Sean O'Driscoll

By Sean O'Driscoll

Senior Crime and Courts Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The courts will likely strike down Donald Trump's birthright order, a legal analyst has told Newsweek.

Newsweek sought email comment from the White House on Wednesday.

Why It Matters

Trump's executive order against birthright citizenship faces several legal battles in the courts. Ending birthright citizenship for children of illegal immigrants has become a central focus of the administration's hard-line immigration agenda.

Read More

Full List of Lawsuits Filed Against Donald Trump This Week8 min read

Full List of Lawsuits Filed Against Donald Trump This Week

Does Trump’s Birthright Citizenship Move Stop Kamala Harris Being President?5 min read

Does Trump’s Birthright Citizenship Move Stop Kamala Harris Being President?

Trump’s Own Cabinet Would Have Been Harmed by Birthright Citizenship Move3 min read

Trump’s Own Cabinet Would Have Been Harmed by Birthright Citizenship Move

donald trump

...

What To Know

Stemming from the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, birthright citizenship states that "all persons born" in the United States are "citizens of the United States."

Immigration hard-liners argue that the policy is a magnet for illegal immigration.

Trump has vowed to end the practice, but attempts to do so will face significant legal hurdles.

The executive order signed on Monday directs government agencies to no longer issue citizenship documentation to babies born in the U.S. without at least one parent being a U.S citizen or a permanent resident.

Attorneys general from at least 18 states filed a lawsuit in a Massachusetts federal court on Tuesday to contest President Donald Trump's executive order from ending birthright citizenship.

The following states joined the case: California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Mexico, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Rhode Island, Vermont and Wisconsin. The governors of all of those states—except Nevada and Vermont—are Democrats. The cities of Washington, D.C., and San Francisco also joined the suit. Four other states—Washington, Arizona, Oregon and Illinois—filed another lawsuit in a Washington federal court.

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) has also separately sued the Trump administration over the executive order.

What People Are Saying

Oleg Nekritin, a defense attorney at the Law Offices of Robert J. DeGroot in Newark, New Jersey, told Newsweek that the courts will likely strike down Trump's order, now that it is being challenged in Massachusetts by several states.

"The Executive Order will most likely be struck down by the District Court of Massachusetts and then be subject to appeal.

"Article II, Section I of the United States Constitution and the 14th Amendment to the United States Constitution guarantee citizenship to individuals born within the United States. The Supreme Court has also recognized in a 19th century case, United States v. Wong Kim Ark, the 'fundamental rule of citizenship by birth,'" Nekritin said.

"A president's executive order cannot supersede and infringe upon rights guaranteed by the Constitution. Even if Congress and the president enacted a law limiting birthright citizenship, it would still be struck down and held unconstitutional because birthright citizenship is a constitutionally guaranteed right."

Nekritin said that the Supreme Court, "with its 6-3 Trump-friendly majority," may decide to hear the case.

"The Court, despite its conservative-led majority, has not been shy in overturning precedent, as shown through Roe v. Wade."

"There is, of course, a difference between decades-old and over a century-old precedent. The Court also recently refused to consider President Trump's challenge to his N.Y. sentence by a 5-4 vote. Significantly, conservative legal ideology has also criticized the use of governing by executive order."

Greg Germain, a law professor at Syracuse University in New York, told Newsweek that the 14th amendment seems quite clear that it applies to "all persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside."

Germain said that Trump will have to focus on the second phrase, arguing that children born in the U.S. to illegal aliens are not "subject to the jurisdiction" of the United States.

"That seems like a question that will ultimately have to be decided by the Supreme Court. Trump can argue that the phrase about being 'subject to the jurisdiction' must have meaning, and should be read as a limitation on birthright citizenship."

What Happens Next

Given the seriousness of the constitutional issues raised, and the number of states listed as plaintiffs, the case will likely reach the U.S Supreme Court.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines