
...

By Hugh Cameron
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A leading economist has said the White House is "full of lunatics" as debates over the legality of President Donald Trump's sweeping tariff plans have resulted in a federal court showdown.
On Thursday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit paused a previous ruling from the Court of International Trade (CIT) in Manhattan, which argued that Trump had overstepped his executive authority in imposing the majority of his tariffs.
Commenting on the muted market reaction to these two developments, Justin Wolfers, a professor of economics and public policy at the University of Michigan, said investors had already reconciled themselves to the fact that the current administration is "out of control."
Read More on Politics
Newsweek has contacted the White House for comment via email outside regular business hours.
Why It Matters
The legal dispute over Trump's tariffs playing out in federal courts could hold broad implications for the future of his trade agenda, which has already elicited criticism on constitutional grounds from Democrats and Republicans.
Pending the result of its appeal, the administration has signaled its intention to take the case to the Supreme Court if necessary.
What To Know
"It's still true that the White House is full of lunatics and that still weighs on people's minds," Wolfers said in an interview with the Australian Broadcasting Corporation.
On Wednesday, the CIT ruled that Trump's use of emergency powers—specifically the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) of 1977—did not grant him "unbounded" authority to impose a global "baseline" tariff of 10 percent, the currently paused reciprocal tariffs, or the tariffs on China, Canada and Mexico in response to the fentanyl epidemic.
"Because of the Constitution's express allocation of the tariff power to Congress … we do not read IEEPA to delegate an unbounded tariff authority to the President," the three-judge panel wrote in its ruling. "We instead read IEEPA's provisions to impose meaningful limits on any such authority it confers."

...
How Markets Reacted
While the CIT's decision potentially voided the majority of Trump's trade measures, markets reacted modestly to the news.
The S&P 500, Dow Jones Industrial Average and Nasdaq rose slightly the next morning, but these gains were tempered only hours into trading. The reaction to the appeals court pausing the decision was similarly underwhelming, with all three indexes finishing in the green on Thursday.
Wolfers—who similarly characterized the president's invocation of the IEEPA as unconstitutional—told the Australian Broadcasting Corporation that, given the significant reactions to previous tariff pauses or developments, markets would have presumably risen dramatically.
"The other possibility is that the original policy announcement was so incoherent, so poorly thought through, so dramatic, so unconstitutional on its face, so absurd, with so much overreach in both the economic, political, and legal domains, that it signaled an administration that's out of control," Wolfers said, adding that investors had already learned in early April that "this is an economically unhelpful administration."
Alex Edmans, a finance professor at London Business School, told Newsweek that markets had largely "priced in" the effects of the CIT's legal challenge, given that so many of Trump's tariffs have been paused or amended.
"Markets are typically very sensitive to new information, but in this case, they have already adjusted to the idea that any new information is actually much less significant than it might appear at face value," he said. "The Liberation Day tariffs seemed shocking yet are being renegotiated, and other promises of extreme tariffs have been delayed or reversed."
He added that the broader "volatility" in trade policy had "created a kind of 'noise' in the market, diminishing the potential for any one legal decision to trigger a large market move."
What People Are Saying
Economist Justin Wolfers told the Australian Broadcasting Corporation: "I'm an economist and what I can see is a consistent pattern of behavior, which is the president genuinely believes that tariffs are a good idea."
"His lawyers will be telling him, as of this afternoon, Mr. President, the statutory authority you're using will come under question, but if you want to push ahead with tariffs, I've got lots of other ways you can do it. My guess, based on recent history, is that he'll say, 'That's terrific, let's keep going.'"
President Donald Trump wrote on Truth Social on Thursday: "Hopefully, the Supreme Court will reverse this horrible, Country threatening decision, QUICKLY and DECISIVELY. Backroom 'hustlers' must not be allowed to destroy our Nation! The horrific decision stated that I would have to get the approval of Congress for these Tariffs. In other words, hundreds of politicians would sit around D.C. for weeks, and even months, trying to come to a conclusion as to what to charge other Countries that are treating us unfairly."
Alex Edmans, a finance professor at London Business School, told Newsweek: "The market was already pricing in the fact that the previously announced tariffs would be renegotiated anyway, so the 'good news' of the legal challenge was already priced in."
"In this context, the court's ruling was just another point in a series of similar events, contributing to investor fatigue," he said, adding that the reaction to the outcome of the appeal would not be "as substantial as one might think."
"If the appeal were to overturn the decision and reinstate the tariffs, the reaction might not be strongly negative because it may be that the tariffs are renegotiated anyway (Trump has shown that not even he is immune to market movements). If the decision is upheld, there might not be a significantly positive reaction since the original court ruling had little impact, and the market is pricing in renegotiation anyway."
What Happens Next
The tariffs related to the CIT's decision are set to remain in effect as the administration's appeal progresses. The appeals court has given the plaintiffs until June 5 to issue a response, and the government until June 9 to reply.
"If, as I expect, they find this to be unconstitutional, then the tariffs will be back off again," Wolfers said on Thursday. "Then we'll be off to the Supreme Court."
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines