10

Loading video...

Nick Mordowanec

By Nick Mordowanec

Staff Writer

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


El Paso officials are considering some surgical bans on domesticated animals including dogs.

The proposal would "ban surgical procedures on domestic animals with no medical necessity," as part of a broader years-long movement that has been successful in some other cities and states.

In 2019, the state of New York became the first in the nation to ban the declawing of cats and file civil penalties against pet owners after cities like Los Angeles, Denver and San Francisco preceded it with similar measures. While states like Maryland followed and others like Michigan are weighing similar policies, declawing remains legal across the rest of the United States. Less than a dozen California cities have enacted bans, but the state overall has not banned such procedures. Two cities in Pennsylvania, Pittsburgh and Allentown, have also outlawed it.

Read More

Dog Has Heartbreaking Reaction to Owner Taking Out Suitcase: ‘She Knows’5 min read

Dog Has Heartbreaking Reaction to Owner Taking Out Suitcase: ‘She Knows’

Golden Retriever Who Lost BFF Learns To Be Happy Again With New Puppy3 min read

Golden Retriever Who Lost BFF Learns To Be Happy Again With New Puppy

Giant and Mini Schnauzer Siblings Go Viral: ‘What’s Better Than One?’3 min read

Giant and Mini Schnauzer Siblings Go Viral: ‘What’s Better Than One?’

Dog Surgery Declawing Cats El Paso

...

Aside from declawing, the policy introduced in El Paso by Councilman Chris Canales would ban aesthetic procedures including cosmetic caudectomy and cosmetic otoplasty, known as "tail docking" and "ear cropping," respectively.

Ear cropping, an elective surgery now mostly deemed cosmetic due to a lack of evidence that it aids hearing, affects some 20 dog breeds including Dobermans, Great Danes, boxers, schnauzers, bully breeds, some mastiff breeds, cane corsos, Beaucerons, Manchester terriers and others.

Declawing, known formally as onychectomy, and ventriculocordectomy—the act of "debarking" or "demeowing" dogs and cats, respectively—would also be outlawed. However, the proposed amendment includes the caveat that spay and neuter procedures in addition to ear clipping conducted as part of a sanctioned trap-neuter-release program would remain allowed.

"I have always felt that these kind of non-medically necessary procedures, very invasive ones that are purely aesthetic or for the owners' convenience, are cruel and inhumane," Canales, a representative for District 8, told Newsweek via email. "When I realized that the municipal code doesn't already ban them, it was a no-brainer for me to bring this proposal forward.

"Pets are a part of the family, and I would hope that nobody would inflict these kinds of procedures on their children or other family members, especially those who are not able to choose for themselves."

The primary motivation behind this proposal is to prioritize the well-being and ethical treatment of domestic animals within El Paso, he added, saying it "aligns with contemporary standards of animal welfare and veterinary medicine and embodies El Paso's values as a community that strives to be compassionate and responsible."

Canales cited stances made by the American Veterinary Medical Association, which has opposed such procedures and discouraged them from being conducted.

If approved to move forward, his proposal would be presented to the local Animal Shelter Advisory Committee for its recommendation. A draft amendment would then be returned to the city council within 90 days.

Onychectomies have been forbidden at many veterinarian hospitals nationwide. Multiple pet hospitals owned by Mars Inc. banned declawing at all 875 of their Veterinary Centers of America locations, which followed the same procedural bans at 1,050 Banfield Pet Hospitals and 80 BluePearl practices, according to a report published by Today's Veterinary Business in 2020. In 2018, all 115 VCA locations across Canada implemented the same ban.

Declawing cats and tail docking are usually deemed by insurance companies as elective surgeries, so they are not typically covered by most pet insurers. Breed-specific disorders and preventive care procedures, like dental cleanings or vaccinations, are not covered in some plans, either, unless owners have opted in through their insurer as part of some type of wellness plan.

Pet insurance tends to cover animal accidents and injuries, including broken bones, torn ligaments or attacks from other species—such as insect bites that could pose serious risk.

Diseases and illnesses like cancer, arthritis and diabetes can also be covered.

"The Animal Legal Defense Fund (ALDF) applauds the El Paso city council for considering a cat declaw ban," ALDF Strategic Legislative Affairs Manager Kathleen Schatzmann told Newsweek via email. "Declawing is an invasive surgical operation in which the last bone of each toe is amputated—similar to severing a human finger at the last knuckle—with the procedure commonly being performed for human convenience rather than for the cat's well-being.

"We urge more jurisdictions to enact such bans and ask the Texas legislature to make this a statewide ban to prioritize animals' health and respect for their natural behaviors."

The ALDF is also working to pass statewide bans in states including Massachusetts, Pennsylvania and New Jersey."

Update 01/16/24, 3:32 p.m. ET: This story was updated with comment from the Animal Legal Defense Fund.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines