10
Loading video...

By Tom Howarth
Science Reporter (Nature)
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The Colorado Supreme Court ruled unanimously on Tuesday that elephants do not have legal standing to challenge their captivity, a decision that blocks a legal effort to move five African elephants from the Cheyenne Mountain Zoo in Colorado Springs to an elephant sanctuary.
The ruling followed a lawsuit filed in June 2023 by the Nonhuman Rights Project (NRP), an organization advocating for legal personhood and rights for animals.
The court determined that habeas corpus, a legal process traditionally used by prisoners to challenge unlawful detention, does not apply to nonhuman animals.
Read More on News
Newsweek contacted both the Cheyenne Mountain Zoo and NRP via email for further comment.

...
Why It Matters
The decision highlights the ongoing debate over the legal status and rights of highly intelligent animals. Proponents argue that animals such as elephants, known for their social complexity and cognitive abilities, deserve rights that reflect their capacity for suffering and autonomy.
Critics, however, contend that expanding legal rights to animals could have unintended consequences for conservation, zoos and other human-animal relationships.
For the Cheyenne Mountain Zoo, the ruling represents a victory that reinforces its care practices for the elephants, which it argues are tailored to their specific needs as aging animals accustomed to a controlled environment.
What To Know
The NRP's lawsuit claimed that the elephants—Missy, Kimba, Lucky, LouLou and Jambo—suffer mental and physical harm in captivity and would thrive in one of two accredited elephant sanctuaries in the United States.
These sanctuaries offer larger, more naturalistic environments than zoos.
The zoo countered that relocating the elephants would cause undue stress and argued that they lack the skills to integrate into larger herds.
The court ultimately agreed that elephants, though "majestic" and highly intelligent, are not legally considered persons and therefore cannot initiate legal proceedings like habeas corpus.
The decision also reflects a broader pattern of judicial resistance to expanding the concept of legal personhood beyond humans. Courts in New York, California, Hawaii and now Colorado have rejected similar lawsuits by the NRP, the zoo said in a statement.
What People Are Saying
The Cheyenne Mountain Zoo, in a statement posted on Facebook: "While we're happy with this outcome, we are disappointed that it ever came to this. For the past 19 months, we've been subjected to their misrepresented attacks, and we've wasted valuable time and money responding to them in courts and in the court of public opinion.
"It seems [NRP's] real goal is to manipulate people into donating to their cause by incessantly publicizing sensational court cases with relentless calls for supporters to donate."
Christopher Berry, executive director of NRP, told Newsweek: "Whereas the Court refused to look beyond the species membership of our clients, we envision a legal system that respects the conscious experience of individuals regardless of their biological label.
"In upholding the lower court ruling that denied the elephants relief from their unjustified confinement in a zoo exhibit, the Court missed an important chance to deepen our compassion for other beings and to promote the core values of our justice system, such as fairness, dignity, equality and liberty."
The opinion of the court: "The legal question here boils down to whether an elephant is a person as that term is used in the habeas corpus statute. And because an elephant is not a person, the elephants here do not have standing to bring a habeas corpus claim."
What Happens Next
The NRP has vowed to continue its fight, framing this case as part of a long-term effort to challenge entrenched norms and secure rights for nonhuman animals.
The organization stated that early legal defeats are common in social justice movements and predicted that future courts would take a different view.
NRP is expected to share further analysis and set out its next steps in the coming days.
Meanwhile, the Cheyenne Mountain Zoo emphasized its commitment to animal care and conservation, pointing to its national recognition as a leader in the field. The zoo criticized the lawsuit as a "frivolous" misuse of the legal system and an unnecessary distraction from its conservation efforts.
For now, Missy, Kimba, Lucky, LouLou and Jambo will remain at the zoo.
Update 1/23/25, 12:28 p.m. ET: The article was updated with comments from Christopher Berry.
Do you have a tip on a science story that Newsweek should be covering? Do you have a question about elephants? Let us know via science@newsweek.com.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines